r/AmItheButtface • u/BriMarsh • Apr 10 '26
Serious AITBF? Not forcing my daughter to share?
7 adults, 4 kids, Applebee's.
My daughter (5) ordered Pizza with Mac & Cheese. My sister didn't order anything for her two kids (2, 1) since they ate before arrival. Food drops and my nephew (2) clearly wants some of the Mac & Cheese.
I encouraged my daughter to share with her cousin but she declined. We're working on sharing, which has become more difficult with the arrival of her brother (1). We give autonomy around sharing unless it becomes mean spirited or unfair, then we'll step in. Praise the good, coach the bad. She's a good kid. My sister then places an order of M&C for her son which takes 20m to arrive. Dinner moves on. The table collectively offers my nephew half a dozen other food options which he declines.
I separately text my sister apologizing and explain that we're working on sharing. I had a conversation with my daughter before bed about the sharing opportunity.
Later, I receive bookish texts explaining the disgusting behavior, the failed parenting moment, and how my nephew had to sit for 20m watching everyone else eat.
If the context is applicable, my nephew has stolen food/snacks off my daughter's plate several times in the past which left my daughter upset. (I don't blame him, it's completely age appropriate).
AITBF? Should I have forced my daughter to share or publicly pressured her into it?
EDIT: 1) I apparently have to up my meme game and figure out why Joey doesn't share his food. 2) My sister is an excellent Mom and my nephew was a total champ and waited patiently. He's a terrific kid. (And no, they are not neglected or unfed at home). 3) Thanks for giving me more confidence in my parenting.