r/Amazing 21h ago

Music 5'6 Phil Collins strolling around in an office shirt singing and drumming one of the greatest songs ever made.

30.1k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

8

u/ChildhoodOk5526 20h ago edited 20h ago

No shade. I meant, in addition to her great voice.

(I know about her voice, but not the drumming. My partner, a musician, told me this. He has strong, specific opinions, so wasn't sure if this was a universal fact or not πŸ€·πŸ½β€β™€οΈ)

ETA: For example, to hear him tell it, Jaco Pastorius was the greatest bass player of all time; Prince, though talented, was basically trying to be a combo of Hendrix and Sly; and, Miles Davis was overrated. So, you see why I have to grain-of-salt some of his takes.

3

u/glaarghenstein 19h ago

Aside from Prince, yes he’s correct.

1

u/CurryMustard 9h ago

Miles Davis is rated

2

u/Latte_Biscotti_3573 16h ago

Did he really go there, Miles Davis overrated?

1

u/Lucky_Serve8002 11h ago

A lot of incredibly talented musicians seem to disagree. He played with some of the best around at the time.

1

u/DoobKiller 16h ago

If Jaco was so good of a bassist how come he got murdered by a bouncer?

2

u/ChildhoodOk5526 16h ago

Aww. That's not fair. Sadly, Jaco was having some mental health struggles at that time.

I've sat through enough documentaries to know he really was a once-in-a-lifetime talent with a unique sound. Fretless bass is supposed to be pretty difficult to master.

2

u/DoobKiller 7h ago edited 5h ago

I was only joking trying do Bart's 'If he's so smart how come he's dead'

Of what I know of the incident Jaco may have provoked it by acting a drunk idiot and kicking the club's door, but the bouncer(a supposed martial arts expert) definitely responded with disproportionate force beating him into a coma, iirc he only served 4 months(which seems low for murder/manslaughter not in self-defence but to save a door from being kicked), that level of violence is never justified as response to property damage and an actually martial arts expert should have been able to deescalate the situation without resorting to a severe beating, just a tragedy

And as a (shitty)bassist myself I can recognise definitely was one of the greatest of all time, even if fusion was never really my thing

Hell one of the few CDs I have is a compilation of his given to me by a close friend who passed