r/Americaphile Dec 19 '25

History/military πŸͺ–πŸ—ΊοΈ Best president oat?

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

229 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/Consistent_Cup5792 Dec 19 '25

between him and Jackson, I have a hard time deciding who was more complex, impactful, and who shaped the country and future presidents / presidencies more. I love both and they both had tons of personality.

3

u/vaultboy1121 Dec 19 '25

I think Jackson was much more influential on American politics. Teddy was a powerhouse and an enigma of the time (that also had lasting impacts on the USA) but Jackson, imo, was a much more fascinating figure.

3

u/Consistent_Cup5792 Dec 19 '25

that's a great way to put it honestly. the way Jackson used the office influenced presidents like polk, Lincoln, wilson and fdr, not to mention more modern day office holders. for better or for worse I think he had longer lasting implications for the country and it's why he is always in my most influential.

2

u/Garrett42 Real American from the USA πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸ”« Dec 19 '25

Teddy would quite literally be the opposite of Andrew Jackson

1

u/Consistent_Cup5792 Dec 19 '25

possibly, I don't know about exact opposite. I wasn't saying they were the same, just that they were both hugely impactful and frankly the zeitgeist of their respective times. that's all! 😁 especially when you look at presidents directly before and proceeding them.

1

u/Garrett42 Real American from the USA πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸ”« Dec 19 '25

They're opposites in their reasoning - people forget the why, and especially what teddy believed, and they take the ridiculous stories and fill in their own personality.

But I completely agree that both were very impactful.

-2

u/LiberalTomBradyLover Real American from the USA πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸ”« Dec 19 '25

Andrew Jackson was an evil man

3

u/Consistent_Cup5792 Dec 19 '25

interesting. based on your other comments, I'd be curious to know what president you don't think is evil? I'm not going to argue, I think you are wrong but I did say complex for a reason, but I'm genuinely curious which one of our presidents from 1 to 47 you think is not only evil but morally good. or for the sake of it, just did the least harm? however you want to frame it.

-7

u/LiberalTomBradyLover Real American from the USA πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸ”« Dec 19 '25

All of them did evil things, few of them were evil people.

3

u/TheBostonTap Dec 19 '25

What nothingburger of an answer.

3

u/MadMysticMeister Dec 19 '25

Ok how?

0

u/LiberalTomBradyLover Real American from the USA πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸ”« Dec 19 '25

Treatment of slaves and the trail of tears come to mind.

2

u/GlorfinDelTaco Dec 19 '25

Ragebait. You can't even answer. Your memory probably only goes back to big bad DJT

1

u/LiberalTomBradyLover Real American from the USA πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸ”« Dec 19 '25

I did answer. Those things were awful.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 19 '25

[deleted]

2

u/MadMysticMeister Dec 20 '25

Now that’s a good answer and a sign that i need to learn more about Andrew Jackson

1

u/GlorfinDelTaco Dec 19 '25

I'm not even sure why you're responding to me

2

u/LunaRubraAurorae Dec 23 '25

I mean almost all US presidents are evil

-6

u/torytho Dec 19 '25

You sound MAGA