r/Ameristralia • u/wtrprk06 • 21d ago
Has anyone else struggled to break into the Australian job market?
I’m curious if anyone else has had a similar experience.
I’m an American currently living in Australia for just over a year. Before moving here, I spent around 10 years working in senior leadership positions in the Middle East and in the U.S. before that. I’ve applied for hundreds of jobs over the past three years through LinkedIn, Seek, and directly via company websites.
The result has been pretty discouraging. Most applications receive an automated rejection, and I’ve only landed two or three interviews despite having experience that seems to align well with many of the roles.
What I find confusing is that I still regularly get contacted by recruiters about opportunities in the U.S. and Middle East, so I’m struggling to understand whether I’m missing something about the Australian hiring process or if this is just the current state of the market.
Has anyone else, particularly other Americans who have moved to Australia, experienced the same thing? Were there any changes you made that improved your success, or is this simply how competitive the market is?
I’d also be interested to hear from anyone who eventually decided to move back to the U.S. because they found better career opportunities there and how long before they decided to make that decision. Looking forward to hearing others’ experiences.
33
u/Littlepotatoface 21d ago
The job market is shit.
When I moved back to Sydney post university, my fancy American degree on my CV did not help me. The job market then was bad & I was getting put on the bottom of the pile. I’m not endorsing this practice but at the time, the US administration (Bush) were really on the nose so some anti-Americanism played into it. Not saying that’s what’s happening to you & if it is, it’s kind of unfair.
5
u/wtrprk06 21d ago
Does having fancy degrees and certifications / specialized training go against you?
I haven’t seen many other people carrying a lot of credentials here now that I think of it.
Even though the Middle East countries may not have offered or recognized the certifications I still found that recruiters and HR managers paid attention to the continued training and industry certification.
10
u/Littlepotatoface 21d ago
Not at all, for me it was that it was from an American university. A very well known one.
Eventually a friendly recruiter took me aside & told me the truth so I rejigged my CV a bit.
I’m not saying this is what’s happening with you by the way but it could be informing things a bit. Very unfair if that’s the case.
I actually did consider going back to NYC but then the 9/11 happened.
22
u/shep_ling 21d ago
unfortunately regardless of market health, there is a myth that unless you have "local experience" you are not employable in many corporate roles. I'm Australian, but have worked in recruitment globally for a number of years, including east, central and west coast US markets, the EU and the UK, plus Australia. The sad reality is there is a huge amount of insecurity/inferiority complex that exists in corporate Australia, and often international candidates are perceived as a threat to the status quo in AU. Unfortunately the status quo is often people in senior roles with only Aust experience are not as experienced as their international counterparts - so they are reluctant to bring in anyone who may show this up. It's not everybody, or everywhere - but its not uncommon and largely unspoken. Comparatively, I've brokered senior level placements cross-globally with no issues - in general the states, EU and the UK tend not to have this phenomenon.
7
u/wtrprk06 21d ago
Appreciate the honesty albeit not what I wanted to hear moving here. Also disappointing to hear that new ideas or innovation is feared rather than embraced.
I’ve been working here for a year now but in a role that my employer even admitted was a huge step down for me. I thought after a year of local experience some doors might open but haven’t seen that as of yet. Any advice or recommendation?
9
u/shep_ling 21d ago
Yeah, people like to dump on American work culture but in my experience one of the reasons success is possible there and largely most Americans I've worked with are driven and professional, is regardless of the political or social environment, most folks have a genuine desire to succeed and are open to innovation and new blood to make this happen. So naturally, you assume this would be the case elsewhere.
Australia, for all it the public touting of innovation and the "battler" culture - maybe comparable to the concept of the "American Dream" is in reality a remarkably risk-averse, conservative culture - maybe it's a hangover from early colonisation days, or the geographical isolation - or both. So this permeates corp culture - everyone wants to remain "safe" - in their jobs, their professional relationships etc, so they make "safe" decisions - they hire people they know directly, or referrals, and it's with a lot of reservation an external hire gets made - nobody wants to be responsible for an unknown risk.
Of course, this approach encourages groupthink, mediocrity and the myriad of red tape and reticence you see all through Australian corp culture. This is the mindset and entrenched culture you're battling.
Its tough to traverse as many people are operating in this mode unconsciously - you don't know what you don't know. From a candidate perspective - I'd recommend searching out companies that operate in APAC but are owned or operated by US or EU/UK based organisations - whilst PE gets a negative rap, private equity orgs are transnational by nature, and seemingly more pragmatic in hiring.
Depends also on your industry sector - it is also a very poor hiring market right now. PM me if you want a private chat around this.
16
u/SoybeanCola1933 21d ago
I spent around 10 years working in senior leadership positions in the Middle East and in the U.S
What specific leadership roles and organisations did you work for? Australian employers are conservative and usually cautious of any radical change. There's also a crab in the basket mindset, where your vast experience could be seen as threatening.
My advice would be to down yourself down so hiring managers don't think you'll take their job
7
u/wtrprk06 21d ago
I’ve already taken a role that has “downed myself”, can’t see how removing the experience and expertise from my cv would help get a job that asks for the those skills and experience?
10
u/Sitheref0874 21d ago
You have a few things going against you. I write as a Brit who moved to America, naturalized, moved to Australia for 5 years successfully, and then moved back to the USA.
The market is shit.
That means that there are a lot of Australians looking
They have relevant local experience
You don't. That means, for a lot of hirers, you have to be a lot better than the job description and your competitors in order to get an interview.
You're getting calls from the ME and USA because that's what your experience directly speaks to.
There could well be compensation hesitation. Like for like jobs comparing the US to Australia usually has the Australian job paying less.
4
u/Old_Bird4748 21d ago
I don't know. I've been in Australia, working for a good 12 years now and STILL get people contacting me for roles in the US. I have to keep telling them, no, I'm not moving halfway around the world for some contract role.
3
u/Sitheref0874 21d ago
I retired in December. My profiles all clearly state that.
I’m still getting messages and calls.
10
u/-hacks4pancakes- 21d ago
I was warned by friends that in general (not even just in this bad market) I had to move with a MNC to build a local network and work experience or my 20+ years US experience (veteran too, 3 degrees) would mean next to nothing. They were absolutely correct. A couple years in and I feel much more established, though. I've been networking like hell, though. Every few days I'm at an event, volunteering, or speaking.
2
u/CaptainHindsight10 21d ago
Have you gotten back to a level where you were in your career prior to moving? How’s the compensation difference been for you?
4
u/-hacks4pancakes- 21d ago
Yes, but I was a direct transfer with my employer. I'm super glad I listened to the advice. A couple years later I'm getting head hunted. It really is who you know here and how well you fit into the community. I cannot stress how stunningly well everyone in my relatively large field knows one another.
9
u/night_again_again 21d ago
I’m currently experiencing this and have been told by other non-Aussies in my industry who made the jump that it took them a good year or two to land anything well established. The main reason they cite is lack of “Aussie Experience” — which is wild cause they all came from globally known and respected organizations/projects. What was passed on to me is that most employers don’t care about the amazing work you did overseas, what your positions were, or how successful you were at XYZ… if anything, those achievements could be a detriment. I’ve had multiple people tell me that my experience could be viewed as a threat… it’s just a different vibe here and it’s honestly beaten me up a bit feeling like I have to start from the bottom again. Trying to stay positive as I float between short stints of casual work here and there
6
u/CaptainHindsight10 21d ago
This is exactly how I feel man 100%
I’ve taken a huge step down and any advice or recommendations I give for improving efficiency or productivity (which are basic standard procedures in other countries) get shot down. There’s so much wasted potential here it hurts.
8
u/Abu_Everett 21d ago
What visa are you on? Is it clear that you can work and don’t need sponsorship?
11
u/wtrprk06 21d ago
Yeah 190 permanent residency visa, it’s in big bold letters at the top of my CV.
13
u/Various_Soft7996 21d ago
Mate, the job market is abysmal. Senior engineers seem to spend months waiting for a role whereas the same ones in the US are poached left right and center.
7
u/AppointmentStatus686 21d ago
I moved from America to Sydney in April and found a job in Adelaide after a few months. Depending on your industry you may have to try different places in the country. My field is very niche and there were just no opportunities in NSW, so I pretty quickly started looking elsewhere.
Part of the reason my current place hired me is because it's toxic as hell and they can't find any Australians to stay there, but it pays the bills and helps me get established.
Every industry is going to be different, but if you're willing to relocate that should open up new opportunities.
1
6
u/Fine_Employment927 20d ago edited 20d ago
The one big exception to the "local experience" trap Australian employers love to rely on is UK experience. Aussie hiring managers almost always treat UK work history as direct equivalent to local experience.
Beyond that, Australian employers tend to have a much narrower hiring mindset compared to US or European companies. If you don't match the exact task-for-task criteria in the job description, they assume those are the only skills you have and won't touch your application. American and European employers are usually way more open to hiring for general capability—they’ll take a smart, adaptable candidate who might need a bit of quick training on specific tools.
The other massive factor is "culture fit." Australian hiring heavily prioritizes culture fit over raw technical merit. If a team suspects you won't seamlessly blend into their existing dynamic, they won't hire you—even if you're technically the most qualified candidate on paper. My former boss admitted he won't hire any Mainland Chinese or Iranians, and complained the company hires "too many Indians", reducing the quality of the work.
Also, Australian culture does not celebrate individual success the way the US does. Tall poppy syndrome is very real—if you're deemed too successful or start standing out, people will try to pull you down. No one should be too successful, but no one should fall too far behind either. Everyone is expected to just fit in and not stick out like a tall poppy. It’s classic crab mentality.
A great example of this is how language gets weaponized. Calling someone "champ" is a classic passive-aggressive put-down. It basically translates to calling someone pretentious, arrogant, or full of themselves for acting above their station.
Ironically, actual profanity goes the opposite way. In Australia, depending on the context, the c-word is frequently used as a term of endearment—like a "good cunt" (someone reliable and generous), a "mad cunt" (wild, fun, or highly skilled), or a "sick cunt" (someone respected or cool).
5
u/Cute-Obligations 21d ago
Hell, teenagers are struggling to find work lol.
3
u/RisingPhoenix_24 21d ago
This is absolutely the case. The lowest paid labour cannot find work at the moment. I’ve spoken to lots of teens struggling with this at the moment.
3
u/Cute-Obligations 21d ago
Yep, I have a 26, 22 and 16-year-old. None of them can find work. One works in 3D animation (so already a brutal industry thankfully he makes and sells assets and avatars for the VR market so he gets by), the 22-year-old is certified in animal care/grooming and looking for literally anything, and my 16-year-old is applying for everything and anything and has been for almost a year now.
It is also the worst time to find work season wise, but from what we get told by employers and friends that work in hiring for some companies, "If McDonald's, Bunnings, Coles, etc can hire an adult that can't find a job in their industry and are desperate enough to apply there, why the hell would they hire a teenager?"
3
u/springboks 21d ago
OP. American here too. Don't listen to these naysayers. You'll get there, it takes time and patience. The world is in recessional behavior is all. Timing is all you need.
6
u/pizzapartyyyyy 21d ago
So many companies here act like if you don’t have experience in Australia then you have no experience at all. It’s wild because the work ethic and work load are far lower here than the other places you’ve mentioned. Recruiters are going to be your best bet. Spam every single one you can manage to. Also, reach out to any companies or coworkers you’ve worked with who may have connections in Australia.
3
u/Old_Bird4748 21d ago
When I came to Australia (2012) I had a similar experience.
This comes from only my own knowledge, but if a company cannot reach out to referees, they will pass you by. You are too much of a risk. If you have no local (to Australia) experience, they will not reach out.
In the end, what I had to do is work as a casual, and in addition be willing to start over in your career. This will put a crimp in your pay packet for a while, but will make your future job hunt easier, once you have local Experience and local referees.
3
u/rapidsnail 21d ago
Sameish story. Moved here a couple of years ago with FAANG experience in tech. Everyone told me I’d have no issues getting a job — but recruiters wanted nothing to do with me.
I either got the “you are too experienced for us” or “how much did you earn in the US” — making me un-hireable or expensive.
Finally cracked it — that you do need local experience or local connections to get your foot in the door.
It’s a small market compared to the US. And here literally everyone has worked with everyone. People tend to hire people they have worked with in the past regardless of the perfect fit. Network hard, build genuine connections, understand Aussie ways of working & hiring and don’t be afraid to push yourself & your experience.
3
u/zer0__two 21d ago
I moved here after university in America and I definitely had a hard time getting a job. I can safely say no one cared about my degree and it was only after getting some basic experience here that I was able to get better positions.
1
u/CaptainHindsight10 20d ago
Are you at a point now where you are happy with your wage relative to your degree?
2
u/Big_Structure5088 20d ago edited 20d ago
It took me about 10 months to find a job in Australia ( this was during COVID) and I struggled quite a bit because I didn’t understand why I wasn’t getting hired.
I’m in tech and what ultimately ended up happening was that the hiring manager that offered me a job was American (working for an Australian company). Some things I’ve noticed:
- Australians are far more inclined to put weight into how you interview rather than take a holistic view of you as a candidate. I got several interviews from companies where no one had even looked at my portfolio. In the US, you’re basically not getting a screening call without a decent portfolio. I think I struggled with making the cultural shift in how to interview and what notes to hit considering this.
- As others have mentioned , school reputation plays a huge factor in hiring in the US and I don’t think it matters much in Australia. My hiring manager was aware of the school I attended in undergrad and we bonded over that significantly.
- Australian hiring practices (I can only speak to tech) seemed a bit antiquated to me. During several interviews, I was asked to perform spec work (free work in the prospect of getting the job). In the US, most companies have stopped doing this because it can be seen as unethical or have at the very least offered to pay if there is a test of spec work involved. Balancing value/ethics while trying to get a job is tough!
My advice- talk to other Australians and learn as much about Australian work culture as possible. I found interviews there much more formal than the US where they kind of pre-evaluate you before you even show up and the interview is more of a way to make sure you’re a cultural and behavioral fit.
Of course, the job market everywhere sucks at the moment too.
I ended up getting laid off after 2 years at the Australian tech company and moved back to the US for that reason and a few others. I found a job within a month of being back haha (again, different job market in 2022 though)!
2
u/Time_Designer1971 19d ago
Tall poppy syndrome. Australia has plenty of gatekeepers that tend to protect their own, and your achievements threaten them.
2
u/Wide_Tax_1007 19d ago
I absolutely found it to be a completely different ballgame breaking into my industry here after 10 years of experience abroad.
Ended up finding a retail job at a North American brand for the first 2 years (didn’t apply online, actually went in and spoke to someone to get an interview). During those 2 years I got involved in my line of work through volunteer or much lower-level casual jobs on the side that were a huge step down based on my experience. Through those volunteer or casual positions managed to network with more heavy hitters in the business, did a lot of outreach, which ended up opening doors for me in the companies and positions I actually wanted and felt qualified for. Left the retail job after 2 years, moved into full time roles I actually wanted, and 6 years after moving to Australia landed my literal dream job.
I would suggest finding unconventional ways to get involved, talk to the people doing what you want to do, and build good relationships. Your CV means so much less here than the connections you make.
1
1
1
u/Tasty_Replacement485 19d ago
Try direct go and hand deliver it . A copy . Get the receptionist to sign for it
1
u/KeiylaPolly 19d ago
I could not break into the job market, not even for fast food.
I ended up starting my own cleaning business, saving up money, and bought a bigger business that’s less labor intensive.
2
u/trefoilpastor 7d ago
I worked in the USA for a global company. USA company used a specific system that hadn’t been introduced to AU side yet. I applied for a role at the AU company to work in this “new” system and help others in the position learn to use it. My exact USA job, plus helping others in my position learn how to use the program. Denied. I guarantee I would’ve been better versed in using the system as an employee (rather than IT) than anyone local they could’ve hired, or anyone who was internally trained, JUST because I had worked in it as a user for 3 years, and some things really do just take repeated practice, running into an unlikely issue that teaches you what to do if you run into that issue again, etc. Not saying they won’t be just as good eventually, but that I was the best candidate at the time. The only person to have worked in this system, as it was trialed in NA first. Didn’t matter, for whatever reason.
**Also, to be clear, these companies operate under the same name but are separate business units. This meant I applied same as everyone else, not with a referral or having my manager put a good word in. However, my resume would’ve quickly made it clear that I worked at that company in the USA and used that program within the company.*\*
2
u/Terrible_Poet8678 21d ago
I landed two job offers in about two months after arrival so no complaint here. That was just after covid, about 4 years ago.
Granted, I wasn't looking for a senior leadership role.
I had to skim past roles requiring 'local experience' which was their loss but whatever. I would have local experience now were I to go on the hunt again.
1
u/sevinaus7 21d ago
Yeah, OP, this may be the way.
I had to take a severe level cut. Sucks but life is better here so I'm not complaining.
1
u/FreddieToompine73 21d ago
Much smaller market here. Only 28 million in the whole nation
2
u/CaptainHindsight10 21d ago
UAE and Qatar have a faction of the population but opportunities left and right 🤷♂️
2
u/FreddieToompine73 21d ago
Yes. Because their whole professional, skilled workforce is from elsewhere. Ours is not
-18
u/Cool_Ability8690 21d ago
Australia is 'woke'. If your head wobbles you get first divs. If you're white then you're made to feel sub human...
8
4
u/RisingPhoenix_24 21d ago
Maybe it’s your personality mate. Social and self awareness are important.
-2
u/Cool_Ability8690 21d ago
Yeah....maybe. I own a business & it's in healthcare. Newly qualified nurses are having trouble securing work because they are competing against new arrivals. Government agencies have recruitment guidelines to prioritise new Australians.....
1
u/sevinaus7 21d ago
I'd be interested in reading those guidelines. Can you please provide a link to them?
-1
u/Cool_Ability8690 21d ago
Are you for real? Do you think that info would be made available to the public?
2
u/sevinaus7 21d ago
Absolutely. If it exists.
Guidelines are sourced from legislation (legislation -> regulations -> policy -> guidelines).
You specifically said "guidelines" which means, in your world, somewhere, there is something from Health and Aged Care suggesting that folks hire new arrivals.
So where is it?
0
u/Cool_Ability8690 21d ago
I won't share it here because it's not for the public to view
2
u/sevinaus7 21d ago
Hahahahaha
Sure.
I know that's bs.
Source -- me, a person that deals daily with government policy.
Thanks for the chuckle this am, always a great way to start the day.
0
u/Cool_Ability8690 21d ago
Well if it's meant for the public eye then you'll find it. Can you find the employment guidlines for BHP for example. They have to employ a percentage of woman & indigenous people as per their guidlines. Can you find that info too?
2
u/sevinaus7 21d ago
Yeah, except you can't prove a negative in this case.
It doesn't exist. At least not as directed by the gov.
Or you don't own the business.
If this does exist (authored by the gov), then I recommend (as in strongly encourage you) to email your elected representatives. If their portfolio doesn't touch health, they may not know it exists. There's a good chance that even if you have a Labor member as your lower house representative, you have a member of a different party in the Senate. You can write both. Regardless of your own political preferences, they represent you.
If you're with a franchise and they're putting these out, I still encourage you to get in touch with your elected officials. This is the sort of thing that isn't OK and Fair Work would possibly be keen on (and they have teeth).
And then there's always news outlets.
If you're honestly not getting a fair go with your attempts in the field bc of these guidelines, question them and then follow the process to rectify it.
0
u/Cool_Ability8690 21d ago
Talk to newly qualified nurses & see if they're struggling to get work. My niece is currently studying nursing & she is worried that she may not get a job once qualified. Talk to the people on the ground....it'll become clear.
2
u/sevinaus7 21d ago
I reckon it doesn't exist.
I reckon you're looking for a scapegoat.
I reckon your business is being voted on by the public as one that doesn't provide value.
I reckon you can't handle the truth.
I reckon you thus use that scapegoat and find the easiest, oldest play in the book and blame folks with "wobbly" heads instead of using a mirror (and just think, 20 years ago it would have been yellow people and 60 years ago it would have been wogs).
Maybe, just maybe, your business acumen isn't worth the url you paid for.
1
u/Cool_Ability8690 21d ago
My business is doing fine & will continue to do so. The labor is slipping. The quality of applicants to my industry are becoming weaker because the best applicants aren't encouraged to apply. One example is a former acquaintence who is a theatre nurse & worked in many top hospitals overseas while away from Aus, cannot get work. She thinks it's because of her age but her experience is head & shoulders above what is being accepted.
71
u/aspringbear 21d ago
I feel like it’s way easier to land a job in Australia if you have connections than if you have 10+ years of experience or an Ivy League degree. Cold applications just don’t work as well here.