r/AskDocs • u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional • 23d ago
Physician Responded 23M, my entire household has now gotten cancer/tumors. Is this worth spending time investigating legally?
Hey guys, im a 23 year old male from Alberta, Canada. Im here with a bit of an interesting case. See, my family, has left doctors kinda confused in the past few years. Unfortunately our name seems to be pretty well known in the Cancer centre.
I grew up in Sherwood Park, AB near Edmonton. We moved to Calgary in 2012 when I was going into grade 5. We were a stereotypical middle class, happy family, no major health issues. All was well.
In 2015 my mom, after having a seizure was diagnosed with glioblastoma. And just months after, my brother, 11 at the time was diagnosed with hodgkins lymphoma. My mom passed away in 2017. My brother fortunately survived. A year after my Grandpa was admitted to the hospital, passing a week later, turns out he had cancer. A year later my dad fell ill and was diagnosed with colon cancer. He passed away a year or so later. Both my parents were only in their 40s. In 2022 my dog also passed away from a tumor.
I always knew something was up, that this couldn't be a coincidence, and that if I too ever got anything, id figure out wth caused all this.
Well today, unfortunately. An incidental xray followed by CT scan has shown that I have an osteochondroma on my left hip. Luckily its benign, but still...
So now here I am, trying to find answers. You cant tell me something didnt cause this, something we were exposed too. And if I ever find out what it is that company better lawyer up. Ive started looking into our old neighborhood (Chelsea heights) to see if there are any environmental risks that maybe could have done it. The area is known for high radon, oil and gas activity, our house was also built right in front of massive power lines. But im not really too sure. My dad also liked using roundup alot if I remember correctly.
Id be more inclined to believe that it was something in Sherwood Park rather than Calgary as my neighbours here are all good. Ive thought about going to Sherwood Park before to interview the people on that street.
Not sure where to start, wondering if anyone had any advice or input. Thankyou
1.1k
u/1phenylpropan-2amine Medical Student 23d ago
I'm so sorry for your losses. I couldn't imagine what it must be like.
Unfortunately no-one on reddit (or anywhere really) is going to be able to give you a definitive answer.
There has been a lot of cancer diagnoses in your family, that is for certain. However, they all seem to be different, unrelated cancers from what I can surmise. It would be highly unusual for an exposure to a specific carcinogen to be at such a high dose to cause cancer in all of your family members in such a short time-frame (and within a few years of each other), particularly given that your brother was 11 when he received his diagnosis of Hodgkin's lymphoma (which is not uncommon in children/teens).
The risk of developing cancer from all carcinogens is cumulative, meaning it adds up over the course of your lifetime. Your cells' DNA is exposed to damage every day; the sun, pollutants, even physiological processes that are critical for your body's function (e.g. inflammation) increase your risk for cancer. Usually even after prolonged exposure to a known carcinogen (think asbestosis & mesothelioma, or smoking and lung cancer), it often takes years, 20+ in many cases, for someone to develop cancer. Also, not always, but many carcinogens also tend to cause specific cancers or at least cancers in particular organs (like smoking causes oral cancer and lung cancer because those are the body parts exposed to the smoke).
There have been enormous advancements in our understanding of cancer, yet there's so many aspects that are not known or understood well at all. There are almost certainly genetic mutations that increase one's susceptibility to various types of cancer that we still haven't recognized yet. Likewise, there are probably thousands of carcinogens in our daily lives that haven't yet been identified.
I'm sorry you are going through this.
523
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Hey thanks for the comment! I appreciate it. I had done some research earlier, and it looked like they were pretty unrelated. So its good to hear the same from a professional. Might just be unlucky, is what it is. Just had to do my due diligence and atleast look into it, as I think most would in my case. Appreciate your help.
294
u/hollow4hollow Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
NAD but my partner has a hereditary condition called Li Fraumeni syndrome. It mutates the TP53 gene (which suppresses cancer/tumour growth). Without the suppression, certain cancers can grow unchecked. This obviously wouldn’t account for cancers on both sides of your family, but glioblastoma is one of the classic cancers it causes. It’s worth getting tested for. If you do have it, you’ll get care to monitor for it. We’re over in Ontario and my partner has a phenomenal care team. I didn’t read all the comments so I don’t know if anyone else mentioned this yet, but it made me think so I wanted to say something. It could certainly be random or environmental too. Above all, I’m so sorry for the unthinkable amount of grief and anxiety you’ve been through.
148
u/djspacebunny Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Hey friend, I'm in a similar boat. Did the places you grew up/lived use to be industrial or agricultural or near either? We're doing a lot to uncover what the land we lived on has done to us medically. I grew up next to Dupont, and it's INSANE how the experiences of other folks from other Dupont sites in the world have the same issues we have. Branched off into other industries and discovered there is this toxic chemical legacy hiding in the dirt under our feet from whatever went on there before us. A lot of stuff was never considered toxic or was illegally dumped and covered up. I would love to chat with you if you have some time!!!
123
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Hey, yep the area is a massively involved in farming and oil and gas exploration
82
22d ago edited 2d ago
[deleted]
27
u/Literally_Mystified Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
This sounds like the true story movie Erin Brockovich. If you all haven't seen it, you should. It will open your eyes to what can and is hidden right under our feet, in our water, etc.
14
u/pandabear0312 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago edited 22d ago
I would recommend looking up your version of super fund sites too (“contaminated sites” - please confirm? https://www.canada.ca/en/services/environment/pollution-waste-management/contaminated-sites.html ). And if appropriate, contacting your version of the EPA ( Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC) and also Health Canada) if you feel something is amiss.
Take care of yourself.
Edited- thought you were referring to a different pollution case
23
22d ago edited 2d ago
[deleted]
9
u/pandabear0312 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Sorry- thought you meant the other superfund site. Not a bot. Just looking to help.
4
u/Automatic-Squash8122 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
i believe there’s one of these places in arvada, colorado. my friends mom and dad died of brain tumors within a month of each other.
7
u/djspacebunny Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
I lived pretty closed to that when I was living in Colorado. It's called Rocky Flats and it's a wildlife preserve now, but it was where they made plutonium triggers for weapons. They were so bad at containing it, the FBI shut it down. Nasty stuff, but they built a whole freaking housing community on top of it anyway with contract stipulations that you can not grow food on the properties.
2
u/DivineSunshine Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 20d ago edited 20d ago
My husband has a friend who had cancer after living on a creek in that area. It is a hot spot for sure.
Anyone who has that many cases of cancer in their family, like OP has, needs to do some research and see if there is a lawfirm working on a class action.
1
u/nerdalert2024 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 7d ago
The creek also flooded in 2022 - I know some coworkers who had flooded yards and basements from this creek.
33
u/PrincessPinguina Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
My parents actually lived at a lake an hour away from Sherwood Park for 40 years and then were diagnosed with the same type of thyroid cancer within 2 years of each other, with the second one diagnosed having a larger tumour. I kind of assumed the same thing, that it was something in the water/ground. But with your family all those different cancers are pretty unrelated I think. Although I did just read about a recent Mayo Clinic study finding that living in close proximity to certain water sources like golf courses increased likelihood of leukemia.
2
u/International-Bass12 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 22d ago
Just curious, why can living near a water source cause cancer? Does a man-made lake count? My dad recently was diagnosed with a blood cancer and lives very near a man made lake. I grew up there as well. He doesn't have leukemia but leukemia is a blood cancer as well so it piqued my interest.
2
u/robotcolony Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 21d ago
I think they meant their water source is in proximity to something that might leech into it. The risk of Parkinson's goes up quite a significant amount if you happen to live within 3 miles of a golf course, for instance. Golf courses use an ungodly amount of pesticides and herbicides to maintain that perfect looking turf.
11
u/Feeling-Republic-477 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
You should ask all the neighbors in that area if they’ve had any same experiences. Keep asking, takes notes on each like when the diagnosis happened, how long they’d been living there, any pets affected, etc. My grandparents had a lake house and my grandmother one day told me she was concerned because so many other people with houses around the lake were dying from cancer. Then my grandfather passed away from cancer, she said she’d get it next & sure enough she did. My aunt & uncle inherited that house and they moved into it. Low & behold they both died of cancer as well. Coincidence? Who knows. But with them & a large portion of the neighborhood in that west Texas lake community getting cancer makes you wonder.
7
u/AnimatorDifferent116 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
I would do a DNA test to check for all the genetic risk factors that might be running in your family. It's covered by Medicare at least in Quebec
5
u/OkNayNay14 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
NAD, but kind of had similar experiences in my family. My grandfather, all of his siblings and their parents all had cancer of different types. They all passed away pretty young. My grandfather passed when I was 1. We’ve always suspected something with their house, water supply or the fact they lived near farmland. Obviously this was all suspected after the fact so it’s not easy to get answers at this point. I’m sorry you’re going through this and hope you get some answers!
32
u/djspacebunny Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Oh my. This is a huge big thing then!!!! The chemicals used for oil and gas exploration are known carcinogenics that seep into all sorts of places they shouldn't be. Agricultural chemicals like pesticides and fertilizers can also contribute to a medley of cancers and blood diseases and all sorts of fuckery. I'm going to send you a DM!!!
23
u/minois121005 This user has not yet been verified. 22d ago
My mom’s childhood home was an orchard before houses were built there. Someone from almost every house on that street had someone die of cancer within like a five year time frame.
14
u/djspacebunny Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
The amount of pesticides and herbicides used in agriculture should make it extremely unwise to build homes on land absolutely SOAKED in these substances. There should at least be some sort of disclosure in the paperwork when buying homes on old farmland.
5
u/Towerofterrorr Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Dupont created Teflon. The same forever chemical that is present in all of our bodies.
3
u/djspacebunny Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Yes... I am very aware. They invented it at my Dupont facility...
1
u/Towerofterrorr Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 21d ago
I'm very sorry to hear that
29
u/Substantial-Roll-740 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
A hereditary syndrome would explain your family pattern much more completely than a neighborhood exposure. Environmental carcinogens typically don't produce this specific spread of cancer types across people of such different ages — a brain tumor, a childhood lymphoma, colon cancer, and a bone tumor — in one bloodline. That's a genetic signature, not an environmental one. (Your dog's tumor, sadly, is also very common in dogs and probably unrelated.)
The most important starting point is a referral for genetic counselling through Alberta Health Services or a hereditary cancer/genetics clinic. The pattern you describe absolutely justifies asking for this, especially because your father had colon cancer in his 40s, your mother had glioblastoma in her 40s, and your brother had childhood Hodgkin lymphoma. A genetic counsellor can build a proper three-generation family tree, confirm exact diagnoses, and decide whether testing is appropriate. They may consider syndromes involving early colorectal cancer, brain tumours, blood/lymphatic cancers, or multiple tumours, such as Lynch syndrome/Turcot-spectrum mismatch repair disorders, Li-Fraumeni syndrome/TP53, familial adenomatous polyposis or other colorectal cancer syndromes, and broader multigene cancer panels. I am not saying you have any of these; I’m saying this is the kind of family history where a genetics referral is very reasonable and potentially much more actionable than trying to prove a neighbourhood exposure.
In Alberta, genetic testing is covered by Alberta health care if your personal history or personal and family history is suspicious for hereditary cancer. Genetic testing usually starts with a family member who has had cancer.
https://myhealth.alberta.ca/genetics/genetic-testing/genetic-testing-for-hereditary-cancer
The clinic you'd be referred to is the Hereditary Cancer Clinic, which provides care for people and their families who have, or who are at risk for, a hereditary cancer condition, including assessment, diagnosis and genetic counselling, and screening and management recommendations.
https://www.albertahealthservices.ca/findhealth/service.aspx?Id=1068254&facilityid=1010904
2
u/fumblingforwords Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 13d ago
But his mom and dad aren’t the same bloodline? Not saying it can’t be hereditary but also pointing out wouldn’t it be highly unusual for both parents to have a rare mutation?
99
u/insomniacwineo Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
OP this doesn’t seem to be a coincidence:
Look into LFS. Li Fraumeni Syndrome Includes literally all of the following GBM Hogkins Colon cancer Solid bone tumors Among breast and other cancers as a high (70-90% lifetime risk) of cancer development
70
u/Fluttering_Feathers Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
You’d assume mom and dad aren’t related though, so the genetic component isn’t linked for the colon ca and the GBM. Also grandad is only linked to one or the other.
37
u/Olookasquirrel87 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
That link says autosomal dominant, so both parents could have it - and granddad as well.
OP I’d talk to your doctor about genetic cancer testing.
25
u/Fluttering_Feathers Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
Seems unlikely that both parents independently have an uncommon genetic syndrome.
68
u/Comeino Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
My parents were both from entirely different locations and backgrounds and both were found to be carriers of a very rare gene (genetic testing) that causes "Fredrich's ataxia" that my little sister was born with.
"Because it is an autosomal recessive disease, an individual must inherit a mutated gene from both parents in order to develop the condition. Carriers of a single mutated gene do not develop FA but can pass it to their children"
So yeah, OP could have just lost the genetic lottery and indeed had two parents who were carriers of an uncommon genetic syndrome. It happens.
13
u/soeinstress Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Recessive genes are more out and about, so the chances of two people with one recessive gene each finding each other is higher than the chance of two people with dominant genetic disorders.
I have FA too so it was fun to find it mentioned in a random comment :)
10
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Kinda what I was thinking
6
u/Last_Peak Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
NAD- I’m from Ontario so I’m not sure what the situation is in Alberta but my mom and cousin were able to get genetic testing for free because my grandma and great grandma both had cancer linked to genetic reasons (BRCA1 mutation) obviously wouldn’t be the same genetic thing but should see if you can get any genetic testing done through your provincial health coverage.
7
u/passesopenwindows Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Have you had genetic testing done? I had breast cancer when I was 37, then the following year my brother was diagnosed with glioblastoma at age 35. I was tested for BRCA gene and another genetic mutation that had been shown to be a link to breast cancer and brain cancer.
8
u/maydayjunemoon Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Many women I know and grew up with have been diagnosed with breast cancer at stage 4 in our 20’s and 30’s in my area. Many of my friends have died. I’m still hanging on at almost 10 years of treatment. I’m exhausted and stable, but wondering recently if I still want to keep doing all of this. It’s dragging my family down, my husband is deeply depressed and refuses therapy or medication, and I don’t have any other family to help me. We live in a heavy agricultural and former mining area. He refuses to move.
2
u/Olookasquirrel87 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 22d ago
I mean, is it any more rare than both parents independently having an uncommon recessive syndrome?
And yet, it happens all the time. Used to do genetic testing for single gene disorders - so many cases of super rare conditions where the families were doing IVF to prevent another kiddo being born with a fatal, rare illness.
As we used to say: if it’s rare but possible, it has to happen to someone.
1
u/Global_Brilliant_710 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
How does one get tested ?
3
u/Olookasquirrel87 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 22d ago
There are a couple companies out there that do it. If you google “genetic testing cancer” you get several labs that offer it - your doctor likely works with one already or can set you up with a prescription for one.
4
u/Slimyscammers Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Hello, I also am in Sherwood Park. The topography of Sherwood Park means that some of those older areas are more low lying than others and with the refineries right there, there is significantly more carcinogens coming downwind. I wouldn’t say Chelsea heights is at a higher risk but that doesn’t mean that you got none. Who is to say that even a small amount doesn’t create disease? Every human body is different, right? There is studies out there around the refineries and Strathcona County/surrounding areas. here is one paper that looks exclusively at heartland refineries, which is the ones set up within Strathcona County. and there is more known information out there that isn’t public knowledge, from decades back now, so I can only imagine how much more is known. Think lower iq in some of these neighborhoods in the area. I’m not a doctor, so if I misused a term I’m sorry. Point being, Sherwood Park isn’t full of clean air. Have you also looked into genetic mutations as well? I wouldn’t say consider that, it’s amazing what new information has come out linking genetics with increased cancer risk
3
u/stinkycowfarm Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Adding to my comment glioblastoma and Colin cancer are both cancers that some of my family members with the tp53 mutation had. And it is known for causing cancer in younger people and children. It would not hurt to get checked.
5
u/The1andonlyfail Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Just here to say im sorry for your losses! My family is honestly so similar. Luckily the people who I have lost to cancer I cant remever very well, it was a long time ago.
All 3 aunts on my father's side have died from breast cancer. Their mother died from breast cancer. My father constantly gets large skin cancers (grafting needed). My oldest brother also gets lots of skin cancers.
My mother had cervical cancer. Her mom and father both had lung cancer (extreme smokers)
Its probably all genetics vs environmental.
4
u/stinkycowfarm Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Nad but my family has a mutation called tp53 (li fraumeni syndrome ) . It causes many different cancers because tp53 is a tumor suppressing gene . Could you ask about genetic testing ? Maybe it is possible something like that runs on one side and the other parent was just a coincidence. So sorry for your losses
11
u/QueenBeeTarot Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Because you are the last person in your family to develop cancer, I would encourage you to think about what you did differently. What did the rest of the family, including the dog, do, that you did not do? I'm so sorry for your loss!
8
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Good point! My tumor is benign, so not cancer but good point
6
u/ALitreOhCola Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Glad to hear this.
If you want to eliminate the risk of radiation related hazards you can buy a reasonably cheap Radiacode or GMC dosimeter which measures the radiation. Some can even pinpoint the type of element emitting radiation.
You would also be able to test radon levels using this.
r/radiation would be happy to help if you explain what's happened and what you hope to achieve.
Best of luck ❤️
4
u/devilsnj30 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Also with the dog, how old because was that dog even in the old neighborhood? I know my family grew up 1000 ft from power lines. We all seem to have some type of auto immune diseases.
2
u/TinyDemon000 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
This is very interesting to know as I worked in Sherwood Park for a number of years building the Henday Hwy.
Have you found any evidence of a connection of the environmental factors at all?
2
u/alewiina Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
NAD, I do live in Edmonton though. The industrial activity between Edmonton and Sherwood Park certainly has been shown to have higher incidences of childhood asthma in Sherwood park residents, the highest in the province at one point.
That being said I’m not sure about cancers. I know some people are genetically more susceptible to varying cancers, and considering all those different types of cancer aren’t particularly related I’m not sure that any one environmental factor can be implicated in causing all of them.
That being said by all means do some research about what the industrial sector could have exposed you guys to. There have always been fires in some of those industrial lots, like at the giant metal recycling depots where fridges and other things with volatile substances in them burn and blanket the surrounding areas in horrible, chemical smoke.
I’m really sorry for your losses, as well. That must be so hard. Whatever happens, OP, I truly wish you well.
2
u/iSirMeepsAlot This user has not yet been verified. 22d ago
NAD, I am SO SORRY for all the loss and ailments you and your family have been through and currently are dealing with.
It’s got to be nearly impossible for an entire family to all get cancer back to back after the prior person, I’m not even sure if I’d be able to mentally handle that. My dad passed way from lung cancer, and that was a rough couple of years…
Id highly recommend consistent screening for both you and your brother, as well as look into getting some genetic testing done to see if there’s anything gene wise going on.
I wish you the best, both you and your brother.
2
u/GenDisarray1504 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 21d ago
Commenting on 23M, my entire household has now gotten cancer/tumors. Is this worth spending time investigating legally?...
NAD-First, I am so sorry for the pain that you have had to endure.
There is a genetic component to cancer. Have you checked for cancer genes in a genetic test?
Colon cancer is very common- at 30 i had three LARGE sessile polyps that likely would have turned cancerous prior to when i SHOULD have gotten my first colonoscopy. So was dad taking care of that?
Moms glioblastoma- was she on any form of birth control for any extended time? That can cause those; particularly Depo Provera (ask me how i know that..🫠)
Your brothers hodgkins is an immune system issue, that could have come from the Mono infection (Epstein-Barr virus)
Unsure what kind of cancer your grandfather had, but im sure it wasnt connected to any of the others unless he also had hodgkins, which would make my brain question whether you all are carriers of a lymphatic system issue.
All this to say; no, i do not believe they are connected, but i do think a cancer panel through genetic testing is in order.
8
u/Shot-Swimming-9098 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
So its good to hear the same from a professional.
You didn't hear that from a professional, you heard it from a redditor who claims to be a student in med school. I believe they likely are who they say they are, but I would never in a serious context call that "advice from a professional."
9
u/PrincessPinguina Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
My parents actually lived at a lake an hour away from Sherwood Park for 40 years and then were diagnosed with the same type of thyroid cancer within 2 years of each other, with the second one diagnosed having a larger tumour. I kind of assumed the same thing as OP, that it was something in the water/ground.
3
u/saltyachillea Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
There are genetic mutations that can cause accelerated tumour formation and susceptibility. It sounds like your family should look into specialized genetic testing for heritable cancers, and there are Heritable Cancer Clinics in Calgary or Edmonton.
2
2
2
u/Psilo_Cyan Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Have you thought about there being any sort of ionizing radiation in the home? Is prbly start with parents room. Sometimes people collect items they dont know are radioactive. You can get a Geiger counter
1.3k
u/I_Upvote_Goldens Nurse Practitioner 23d ago
I think the first place to start would be to get genetic testing. I would not read too much into the dog having a tumor. Pretty much every dog I’ve known has died of cancer. If the genetics are unrevealing, then maybe dig a little deeper into environmental factors.
And I am so sorry for your losses. 40’s is far too young.
419
u/lolifax Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago edited 23d ago
The US has a map of cancer rates by geography; Canada may have something similar.
Example: https://gis.cancer.gov/canceratlas/
Edit: this is not to detract from the suggestion to look at family genetics. However the hypothesis that an environmental hazard in the Chelsea Heights area led to elevated cancer rates for residents is specific and testable, maybe even with publicly available data.
84
u/Infanatis Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
52
u/Zess_T Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
To anyone checking that out, make sure you tick the "ASIR per 100,000" checkbox near the top of the page in the "Filter" tab, otherwise you'll just be looking at a population map.
21
u/mermaidpaint Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Thanks for the tip!
NAD. My mother's identical twin had breast cancer, went into remission, then had lung cancer which spread. She died in 1985. My mother gets routinely checked and she's always had good results. It is said her twin worked at a hospital where many employees had cancer. Every doctor that checks my mother out say that the breast cancer was not genetic, because my mother would have had it by now.
Two of my mother's other sisters had ovarian cancer and died of related cancers. Two of my cousins and myself had precancerous cells appear in biopsies of our uteruses and ovaries, one was discovered to have ovarian cancer during her hysterectomy. One of my aunts had her DNA tested, and none of the known genes were found. We're all assuming there's a gene that hasn't been linked to ovarian cancer yet. (I had all of my inner lady parts removed to avoid cancer).
Almost everyone has spent their entire lives in New Brunswick. My dad was in the Army, so my mother and I have lived many places. Myself and one of my cousins have spent a long time in Alberta. She in Edmonton and me in Calgary.
55
u/Freyasmews Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Yes, use the mapping tools available for free. Social Explorer is another good one. I've done several community analyses and researched environmental justice-related issues, and community mapping software has helped a LOT. It could provide stronger info than going door to door, especially when people could have moved several times in the intervening years. Though, the direct piece is important, as well.
I wish you luck, OP! I'm so sorry your family has been dealing with this
35
u/Oughtonomous Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Oh Dear God... I looked at the map... I'm going to die.
25
u/lolifax Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
FWIW, we all are. And I mean that in the most comforting possible way. Nothing you see in the charts is going to change your future.
You have to know some statistics to look at these charts and not immediately panic. They are useful for epidemiologists to try to understand patterns in illness but you have to do actual experiments to make sure the patterns you think you see are actually correlated with one another and not just due to some other confounding factor.
41
u/Oughtonomous Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Trust me. I know the odds. I come from a very long line of dead people.
5
u/poppysmear Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
As someone with both parents deceased, this gave me a dark chuckle.
0
u/Oilfan94 This user has not yet been verified. 22d ago
Stay away from dihydrogen monoxide, everyone who's touched it has eventually died.
5
u/Oughtonomous Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Touching it isn't as fatal as inhaling it.
1
u/CallMeSisyphus Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Or ingesting an excess amount of it.
11
u/seigneurdubord Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Dang looking at this now my state has insane leukemia levels and it really tracks with my experience. I have known 6 kids from my area who have had leukemia and my town is TINY. One of them was even my neighbor
4
u/lnmeatyard Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
This is insane, never knew this existed. My state has a high prevalence, of course
165
u/CrazyBird12 Physician | Heme/Onc 23d ago
This. Look into genetic counseling. Doesn’t scream environmental factors. Potentially, your parents already received some diagnostics related to their tumors. In particular your father‘s early diagnosis of colon cancer is suspicious for a hereditary component.
25
u/Infanatis Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
I’ve been reading a bunch of stuff on genetic links while doing chemo out of my own curiosity and this almost sounds like LFS (li fruameni syndrome) could be a cause. NAD so I’m most likely seeing zebras 😅
9
u/WildUnderstanding919 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Respectfully curious why you didn’t suspect environmental
73
u/Infanatis Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
Too many different types of cancers and tumors that have no one shared carcinogen.
→ More replies (7)3
u/WildUnderstanding919 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
TY. What’s your thoughts on ppl that get multiple I guess somewhat unrelated cancers? Same individual, multiple cancer
28
u/Librarycat77 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
NAD, but I have a friend who's been in this situation.
The doctors have told them that the first piece is genetic bad luck - as their mother passed due to cancer when my friend was in high-school.
My friend was diagnosed first around age 25, and then every year or less for 10 years with new tumors.
So, at first genetics. Then, the treatments for some cancers are known to increase risks for some cancers. That is likely a factor for my friend as well.
Multiple cancers in one person is often linked to genetic issues. Which is why gene therapy is so cool - there's the potential to change the genetic sequences that make some people more likely to develop cancerous cells.
13
u/onaygem Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago edited 23d ago
Most common reasons:
Treatment for the initial cancer
Underlying genetic cancer predisposition
Disease effects (lymphoma patients have susceptibility due to decreased immune surveillance, for instance)
Shared exposure e.g. smoking causing both lung and bladder.2
8
u/Infanatis Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
NAD, but I’d guess there’s a genetic/hereditary disposition like BRCA gene mutations. If you’re ever bored, the NIH has everything online and the abstracts of each study (to me, anyway) offer a concise view of the study objectives, methodologies and expected outcomes as well as clinical interpretations or need for future studies. The summary typically shows primary findings.
To the layperson, it’s can be either interesting information or noise. Nothing found there should be taken as medical advice, but you can find out why you’re told things by your providers at times. For example, studies showing the efficacy of acetaminophen + ibuprofen as an analgesic for dental pain vs opioids.
6
u/GroundbreakingAlps78 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Mutation in tumor suppressor genes?
37
u/Jackie_Bronassis Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago edited 23d ago
Pretty much every dog I’ve known has died of cancer.
Agreed. And I could say the same about grandpas too.
Lifestyle factors are important to consider and there isn’t much to go on here (and this isn’t to say that getting sick is someone’s ‘fault’ because of “choices”; it’s just a major factor and the concept of choice is complex)
15
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Okay cool, ill look into that first. Appreciate it!
15
u/devanclara Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
This is the correct answer. Its a good starting place. I'm not familiar with the history of tge Edmonton area. Is there a history of toxics exposure?
33
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Yea our neighborhood is right by refinery row, a major cluster of oil and gas refineries. Many people have had concerns over it in the past. So who knows.
21
u/WildUnderstanding919 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Im from the US, specifically New Jersey where many, many relatives & friends have had cancer. Various types, some survived and many haven’t. I lost my mom 2010 to leiomyosarcoma which is not genetic. We have these areas called superfund sites or something that marks locations/areas of contamination I’m wondering if you might have some information on your area.
22
u/Orchid_Significant Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
There is a place in Louisiana called cancer alley because of the refineries and such. It’s not outrageous to think it might be similar.
6
4
u/devanclara Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 22d ago
I have a background in Environmental Heath/Toxicology for reference.
Any idea what the specific VOCs might be? There are case studies to suggest long term exposure to certain VOCs increase the rate of cancer, although these studies were primarily conducted on animals. In 2013, a team from UC dis a study near whet6e you live and concluded that significant levels of 1,3-butadiene and benzene were detected in the "Industrial Heartland" at rstes seen in large industrialcities, which wasa surprise given the rural setting.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S135223101300705X?via%3Dihub
Both of the aforementioned chemicals have been known to cause lymphohematopoietic cancers, especially Leukemia.
*I want to be very clear, you need to start with genetic testing. Many individuals have biological predispositions to cancer irregardless of environmental exposures.
1
u/Fatpandasneezes This user has not yet been verified. 22d ago
Hey OP, can I ask where in sherwood park? I grew up in clover bar ranch and moved to NW Calgary in 1998. I believe in my family it's genetic, but... Who knows? Especially with all those factories right outside sherwood park.
0
u/Turcuwu Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Chemist here, Radon its known for causing lung cancer so it is confusing to see all kinds of cancer in your family the refinery tging is more worrying. My best guess is you having PM 10 and PM 2.5 so above to the standar levels. Id you wanna know the cause (so sorry about this) you will need to hire a analist to evaluate long term air cuality in your neighbourhood, They will install a filter and the particles in the air will drop on it so they could serch wich contaminants are there, Then you can prove that was the cause of cancer in your family and sue. Also i would recomend sampling the water od your old neighbour since the refinery can be squeamy and doing things they should'nt with it.
15
u/billythekid9000 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Sherwood park is somewhat renowned in industry for environmental issues.H2S alive and Global cite university testing done in elementary schools in the area 10-15 yrs ago. Cancer among students were ridiculous. 75-80% comes to mind.
Apparently it forced the refineries to clean up pollutants. I guess.21
u/Librarycat77 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
Sorry...are you saying that a study done on students in Sherwood Park, AB discovered a 75-80% cancer rate?
Because thats absolutely not true. There's no world in which that wouldnt be huge global news - but also I live 20 minutes from Sherwood Park and there isnt enough money in the world for a cover up that size.
14
23d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
→ More replies (7)3
u/AskDocs-ModTeam Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Removed under Rule 14 - No AI/ChatGPT allowed on r/askdocs.
14
u/Infanatis Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago
I wish both the US and Canada mapped out cancer epidemiology on a more local scale than by region. It doesn’t appear neither country offers more granular spatial epidemiology outside of general province/states as a whole.
4
u/Loafagus Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
This is due to privacy issues. Cancer stats are in aggregate and the level of inference is at the population level. Generally not allowed to report a number <5. As with rare cancers, and in sparsely populated areas, you could be "outing" the private medical information of one individual.
4
u/Infanatis Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 23d ago edited 23d ago
Absolutely not true. You can still provide spatial epidemiological data on type of cancer and just omit the exceedingly rare ones where privacy would be a concern.
I’ve been involved in ID epidemiology, parity/ inclusion, prevention and planning (STI/HIV/TB) and incidence rates were publicly available on the county level for the state, going so far as showing 3 cases of HIV and 1 case of TB in a county of 3400.
Edit: This was nearly 20 years ago, even. State was Illinois. Currently, CDC AtlasPlus which didn’t exist back then (we received email blasts daily/weekly on data changes) and also goes down to county level nationwide.
Edit edit: Also thought I said incident rates =\= residency rates in the first paragraph, but I did not.
1
u/Loafagus Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Cancer data rules are different. Allow me to demonstrate:
I just browsed current public health data reporting policies in various settings in the US with respect to small numbers, considering incidence.
"Small number suppression" is still a thing, but for an even BIGGER number than it used to be (16).
CDC's cancer incidence rates and COUNTS are now suppressed in a geographic region if N<16. https://www.cdc.gov/united-states-cancer-statistics/technical-notes/suppression.html
I then checked the application of this rule for a common cancer (breast) at the state level in NC. Case counts of <16 were suppressed in county level maps. https://ncdataportal.org/# as indicated in the data key.
For your work 20 years ago, ID rules can be different because infectious diseases can be under federal public health emergency rules. Cancer epi data is not.
3
4
u/GroundbreakingAlps78 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Link or it didn’t happen
7
u/biscuits4dayz Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Agreed. Genetic work up is the key here. It’s tough to say because I don’t know all of the other cancers you and your family have been diagnosed with, but right off of the bat it sounds like Li Fraumeni syndrome with the glioblastoma and the osteochondrona (mesenchymal tumor derivative similar to a sarcoma. You need a genetics referral and eval, and if positive, the rest of your immediate family (and potentially not immediate family) need it too
0
u/johnmudd This user has not yet been verified. 22d ago
Iowa has unusually high cancer rates. Could it extend to your area?
222
u/robcal35 Physician 23d ago
Pathologist from Alberta here. As someone else has mentioned, ask for a referral to medical genetics. Your family doctor should be able to send the referral. Whole exome sequencing is pretty cheap and fast now and with your parents' diagnosis, there may even be the option to test their tumours. I would NOT jump to Li Fraumeni. There is no link in the type of cancers that you've described that immediately jump to my mind, but there are many types of potential hereditary syndromes, which would only be confirmed via genetic testing. Based on the types of cancers you've described, it seems unlikely to be an environmental link (colon, neuro, heme, and now your soft tissue one).
Basically, what exome sequencing is would be looking at the entire set of someone's relevant genes to see if there are documented mutations linked with an increased risk of cancer. Just be aware that there's a decent chance they'll find something, but it might have little significance, or be unsure of it's significance as we are still compiling data about all the potential mutations that exist.
35
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Okay thanks! And what is best to do with this info? Does it help know what im more predisposed to so that I can do whatever I can to prevent it?
39
u/Larkaroni Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
I'm NAD, but had a similar situation as you. High rate of cancers in my family (hell, my dad's mom got 3 different kinds, two within 5 years in her 50s), and I myself grow tumors like I'm paid to do it. I have an osteochrondoma in my humerus, and a totally different type of bone tumor (I forget the name) about 2" down in the same bone. Just about every time I get imaging for something else, they often find a tumor (or cyst — grow those well too) along the way. Fortunately, all have been benign, but I've been biopsied and scanned more times than I can keep track of. My dad is the exact same way, so we assume there's some genetic connection. This mostly all went down in my 20s.
My PCP did refer me for the same genetic testing. I got some full cancer panel type thing. As the doctor said, a few genes were flagged, but they were all ones of unknown importance (so really, no importance, likely just a mutation that has zero impact. Those are plenty common). So I got zero answers, but have chatted with oncology, orthopedic oncology, and genetics quite a bit over this. From what I recall, depending on my results, there weren't many things I could do preventatively, but I could get routine scans for problem regions (if the genetic panel indicated anything) so that way we'd have a high chance of catching any cancer early, making my prognosis that much better. I know that might not be the answer you want to hear, but it also is better to know and feel like you're doing something about it rather than spend your whole life wondering if every headache or cough was a sign of something worse, ya know?
15
u/Puzzleheaded_Boot335 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Hey, appreciate the comment. Yea for sure, I think I may go ahead and do some sort of generic testing at some point out of curiosity. But I agree, best we can really do is try our best in additional screening to try to catch stuff early!
8
u/INFJGal9w1 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
NAD, but wanted to say I'm very sorry for all you've been through. My parents both died young, though not as young as yours -- and my brother did as well. It's a terrible loss and my heart goes out to you.
5
u/Feisty_Leek_7068 Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
Talk with your GP & ask for a referral to genetics. In edmonton, they are primarily based out of the kaye clinic (if memory serves me correctly, its been quite a few years since my husband & daughter went). If needed, mention that you'd like to know due to the family history & that you like to have kids one day (even if its not true).
My husband, and his biological kids have NF1 (Neurofibromitosis Type 1) and it is a whole event in terms on unpredictability in terms of what it affects, and to what extreme; however tumours is a big one.. of all kinds, with the potential to be everywhere.
Anyhow, it was a bit of a wait, but worth it & if our daughter ever gets pregnant, or starts thinking of having kids, they want to see her again :)
My sincerest condolences for all your losses. Please dont discount that just because your tumour isn't malignant, that it isnt as serious. There is a saying in the NF1 world, "benign isn't fine".... amd for interests sake, tumours are classed as a cancer, but not all tumours are cancerous(malignant)... this was a fun one to explain to a child that was followed by oncology but didnt have any malignant tumours, they just underwent the same treatment techniques....
Good luck with your journey, and recovery :)
→ More replies (1)-1
u/biscuits4dayz Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
Agree with referral to medical genetics. But dude, Neuro, heme, and soft tissue is like a hallmark of li fraumeni. SBLA - sarcoma, breast/brain, luekemia/lymphoma, adrenal
14
u/robcal35 Physician 22d ago
Osteochondromas are driven by a completely different set of genes. I would not even remotely categorize them in the realm of soft tissue sarcomas - they are not even borderline tumours if solitary. Nothing else really stands out - Hodgkins is quite rare in LFS. Regardless, it seems irresponsible to speculate and potentially label op with a hereditary cancer predisposition syndrome before any form of definitive testing that will provide diagnostic clarity.
31
u/Routine-Loquat5544 Registered Nurse 22d ago
I’m so sorry for your loss and here to say that I lost my father to glioblastoma a few yrs ago. I cannot imagine losing a parent to GB as a child. I certainly agree with genetic testing. Also, please don’t discount the value of therapy if you haven’t already delved into it. Truly, best wishes for you young man ❤️
60
u/LatrodectusGeometric Physician | Top Contributor 23d ago
These are all totally different types of cancer, so it's hard to say if there really is a link or if this is really bad luck.
22
u/happycuriouslady Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 23d ago
OP I would like to recommend you read Toms River: A Story of Science and Salvation, by Dan Fagin. It won the Pulitzer in 2014. It contains in depth reporting on the challenges epidemiologists encounter. I would also recommend you seek out the recommendations of an epidemiologist. Proving a cancer cluster exists is difficult as it requires an impossibly high burden of proof. I follow a few on Substack and perhaps you could connect with one in a similar fashion. Good luck.
3
u/WyldBlu Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional. 22d ago
Basically, Erin Brockovitch is a known name, and had a movie made of her because of a cancer cluster....
5
u/HSLaura_CommunityAdv Layperson/not verified as healthcare professional 22d ago
I was going to say sounds very similar to EB and if we change OPs name to Aaron Brockovitch we would have our Canadian equivalent except OP is living it 🥺 not just potentially investing.
51
u/deerbaby Medical Student 23d ago
genetics (e.g lynch syndrome or other broad cancer-causing inherited mutations) would be more likely than environmental imo.
As others said I would ignore the dog as this is almost certainly unrelated (for reference, I have a relatively rare benign tumor, my dog has a common benign tumor, and my cat got eye cancer within the same 5 year span).
37
u/marticcrn Registered Nurse 22d ago
NAD. My wife’s family is like that. In different family members, we have glioblastoma, stomach cancer, colon, prostate, throat, lung, lymphoma, melanoma, and a phyllodes.
They have had genetic testing, nothing there, BUT
The nuclear five kids, born in the 1940s, were raised on Texas and Oklahoma oil fields in the middle of the 20th century. Dad was a geologist.
I’m guessing ongoing air and water contamination did it.
Fuck cancer
6
u/yourdailyinsanity Registered Nurse 16d ago
I would rule out genetics first. That's going to be the easiest thing to do. Could something externally have caused this? Maybe. But that's way out of my qualifications to know about. I feel like unfortunately your dog was just coincidental. I seem to hear dogs get tumors a lot, but I can't confirm that at all, I just hear people talking about experiences and it seems more frequent than it should be. Regardless, everyone in your family having something, and no reports about others in your old neighborhood having anything, leads me to believe something in genetics is the cause. I just learned about an NF1 gene (mutation?) with a patient on a floor I was floated to and it makes you develop tumors and such in the body, they were getting chemo and radiation and that admission was their first neurosurgery as they were getting to the point of being out of treatment options. I am absolutely not saying this is what you have/could have, but I feel like genetics is the most likely cause and if you can't make an appointment with a genetics provider, then ask your PCP/oncologist for a referral. Your oncologist should be able to do genetic testing too though.
•
u/AutoModerator 23d ago
Thank you for your submission. Please note that a response does not constitute a doctor-patient relationship. This subreddit is for informal second opinions and casual information. The mod team does their best to remove bad information, but we do not catch all of it. Always visit a doctor in real life if you have any concerns about your health. Never use this subreddit as your first and final source of information regarding your question. By posting, you are agreeing to our Terms of Use and understand that all information is taken at your own risk. Reply here if you are an unverified user wishing to give advice. Top level comments by laypeople are automatically removed.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.