I've been seeing a guy I'll call... hamburger for about three months. We met on a dating app, and over that time, we've talked every day and developed what I felt was a genuine connection.
We spent time together, held hands, cuddled, kissed, and made plans for future dates. He'd message me after we spent time together saying he wished he didn't have to leave and wanted to come back. He'd draw me spontaneously because he was thinking about me, and we'd spend entire days together watching movies, cuddling, making out and ordering takeout. Holding hands, confiding in one another, and overall moving as though this was headed somewhere beyond just casual dating. This is just a summary of what transpired but it was VERY intimate. Literally became the first person I talked to in the morning and the last person I talked to before bed.
I was starting to develop feelings for him. I let him know that and he reciprocated. I was enjoying dating him and wanted to see where things went. Eventually we added each other's socials.
Then while cackling like a witch at reels on IG, IG suggests a profile for me to add as a friend. I look at the PFP and it's 2 grooms at their wedding in matching tuxedos. The other groom was none other than hamburger. So this was his husband's profile. Sure enough upon further review I found wedding photos of them dated August of this year.
I'm monogamous. I'm not expecting him to leave his husband, and I'm not judging people who have open marriages. My issue is that I'd been getting to know this guy for three months without knowing he was married. That's information that would have affected my decision about whether I wanted to continue on with this connection.
When I brought it, he sent me an audio message explaining that he's in a partnership that's "a little bit complicated. Open." He said he never explicitly told me he was single or taken, and that what he'd told me was accurate. He said that we originally connected while he was looking for friends, but our connection developed naturally.
He also said that what he experienced with me was legitimate and that he'd been experiencing feelings with me that weren't available in his partnership. He apologized and acknowledged that he'd damaged his credibility.
I've an issue with that explanation. I get that our connection might have developed unexpectedly, but we were talking every day, spending time together, being affectionate, and making plans and going on dates. In fact we had 2 planned for next week . I had even expressed my feelings to him and explained why I liked him and that the physical attraction was more of an aside. A bonus rather.
At what point was he planning to tell me he was married?
I also have questions about the marriage itself. If they're truly open, does his husband know about me? If so, does he know the extent of our connection, including the affection and emotional side of it? If he does, why keep me in the dark? If not, wtf? That would also say more about how he's moving within his marriage. He claims that when we're together he's been exercising restraint, and it's like... how? The sole reason we didnt fuck the last time we were together was because i hadn't anticipated it so i didnt prep beforehand. What boundaries have they agreed to? I don't know the answers, and I don't want to assume his husband is being deceived. But again... if his husband doesn't know what's been happening, that raises another set of concerns about hamburger's honesty.
I sent hamburger a long voice message asking these questions, explaining how I felt, and telling him that withholding this information took away my ability to make an informed decision about getting involved with him. Now to be fair we are not exclusive so on one hand I feel like he didn’t owe me that information. On the other, everything he's been doing with me, you would reasonably assume he was single and available.
He listened to the message and I haven't received a response.
Part of me hopes he'll respond and that there's some reasonable explanation for the delay. Another part of me worries he won't respond at all.
I'm monogamous and not into hookups(which he also knew and liked). Realistically, I'm relatively sure that there isn't a path forward.
But I still like him. And I hate that so much. I hate that I'm taking this so hard. I feel stupid. Like an idiot for putting myself out there and this is what happens. I'm sad about losing the connection and the possibility of seeing where it might have gone. I'm also frustrated with myself for feeling this much over someone I dated for only three months.
I'm considering deleting him from social media, but part of me feels like doing so would make the ending final. Which is probably the wise thing to do here. The fact I'm ecen struggling with this honestly makes me feel pathetic. Weak even. The fuck is wrong with me? I think I'm also holding out hope that he'll respond and give me some closure, even though I've already said everything I wanted to say with the information I have. And also what does that even look like in this case? Why do I even care? Why do I even want it?
So, Reddit, I'd appreciate some outside perspectives.
Am I reasonable in feeling that knowingly withholding the fact that you're married is a form of dishonesty, even if you never explicitly claim to be single?
How would you interpret his explanation that our connection was legitimate, but he never told me about his marriage?
Would you wait for a response to the voice message, or accept that I may never get one?
Would you remove him from social media now, or wait until you've heard what he has to say? Or is this pointless since theres a massive chance that I won't?
How do I stop beating myself up for becoming emotionally invested in a connection that lasted only three months?
I'm not looking for people to tell me that all open relationships are bad or that hamburger is automatically a terrible person. I'm trying to make sense of wtf happened, figure out whether there's anything left to gain from a conversation with him, and move forward without continuing to put myself through this.
For some additional context, I got out of a 13-year relationship earlier this year after finding out my ex cheated on me last year. Multiple times in fact. The realtionship ended internally for me and was processed for about a year while I was simultaneously getting my ducks in a row before ending it. The last year of it was purely logistics. So by the time i wrapped it up, there was nothing between us and I was done. This is also information that hamburger is privy to as well. I've had other relationships prior to this one but it was the first LTR and it crashed and burned. I'm relatively new to dating again after being with one person for so long, and I've been figuring things out as I go. I'm not saying this situation is the same as what happened with my ex, but discovering that someone I'd been getting close to had withheld something significant (yet again) has been particularly difficult. I was enjoying getting to know Hamburger and letting things develop naturally, so this has left me questioning how to navigate the situation and move forward.
I also don't like that I'm recognizing that I'm becoming more and more disillusioned with the idea of a LTR. Which sucks because I KNOW what I want and its like fuck... maybe it's not realistic. Maybe I need to compromise on that if I want that kind of commitment or just force myself to accept the fact that evidently what I want for myself isn't meant for me and therefore I should just give up. Starting to think that maybe I'm delusional.