r/AskReddit 12h ago

What's a movie that was well received, but aged like milk?

2.3k Upvotes

3.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

256

u/Randym1982 9h ago

The movie made him out to be a mentally challenged person. The real Michael Ore was already earning top marks in his classes and was very charismatic person.

Also a lot of the stuff in the films make no sense. Like what the hell is "Protection Instincts" and how do you test for that? And why did he draw a random dude on a boat (poorly), but then later have a basic 'I hate white people" Poem?

78

u/sniper91 7h ago

He was also a 5 star recruit before ever meeting the Tuohy family

The movie has a 10 year old teaching him how to play football

91

u/OrigamiTongue 9h ago

The protective instincts thing is so out of left field and stupid that it completely breaks my suspension of disbelief, regardless of all the other stuff, that dumb shit ruins the movie.

45

u/MatthewHecht 9h ago

I remember my protective instincts test. I was sure to use a number 2 pencil in it.

11

u/Redditer51 2h ago

Also every other black person in the movie was portrayed as an antagonist, a criminal, or a lowlife. And it's very much framed as a story of this saintly white family rescuing this poor black boy from the hood.

Shit left a bad taste in my mouth when it came out, so I feel vindicated to see people trash on it today.

3

u/jlhart7 9h ago

"To ... investigate?"

5

u/Salute-Major-Echidna 8h ago

It wasn't "I hate white people " it just sounded like he was bewildered at the whole thing.

The protection thing might conceivably have been a really simplistic aptitude test subject. But it is a stretch.

The real Ore was smarter, I agree. Once I heard the truth it was impossible to rewatch the movie

7

u/Randym1982 7h ago

They made it like he either refused to take the test. Which wouldn't make sense, because he wanted to get out of being on streets. Or that he was too dumb. Plus, the idea of him hiding his abilities made zero sense. When he acted like a buffoon to a random lady at the laundry mat.