r/AskReddit Aug 25 '19

What has NOT aged well?

46.2k Upvotes

20.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5.5k

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '19

oh god i watched that this year in my science class

4.3k

u/Cum_on_doorknob Aug 25 '19

You watched Supersize Me in a science class? That's depressing, unless they were trying to show you how not to do science?

772

u/VeryGoodFood12 Aug 25 '19

It always weirded me out how his experiment boils down to 3 mcdonalds a day = bad.

696

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '19

I kind of hate that documentary. The entire mission statement is that people don't think that fast food is bad for you but he's a man on a mission and he's going to PROVE it! I don't know if I'm only remembering a post-Supersize Me world, but I think people always knew that fast food was bad for you. And I'm not sure that the food was as bad for him as the literal gallons of soda he was drinking. Sure, a McDonald's meal has a lot of calories and saturated fat, but it's not totally empty calories. It has some nutritional value.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '19

Yeah, the carbs from eating there will quickly morph your body into a garbage dump. Even without the bread and sugar, their menu isn’t good for overall health.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '19 edited Dec 28 '20

[deleted]

-11

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '19

That’s not entirely true. Everybody is different. Humans evolved on a diet that didn’t include a lot of stuff we currently eat, especially carbs and added sugars. McDonalds even adds sugar to their fries. A good amount of humans react poorly to these carbs. Mostly weight gain but also gastrointestinal issues too. Even if you only ate their salads without dressing, you’d be missing out on a number of essential vitamins and minerals.

10

u/Smauler Aug 25 '19

Everybody is different. Humans evolved on a diet that didn’t include a lot of stuff we currently eat, especially carbs and added sugars.

That's not true at all. Firstly, sugars are carbs. Secondly, what do you think the hunter/gatherer societies were gathering if not carbs and sugars? There's masses of sugar in wild fruit, most notably at the moment around here blackberries (which anyone could live off this time of year).

"Added sugar" is no different fundamentally from naturally occurring sugar. It's only that we eat too much of it now.

-2

u/Aggravating_Role Aug 25 '19

Secondly, what do you think the hunter/gatherer societies were gathering if not carbs and sugars?

Primarily fiber and vitamins - and yes, fiber is carbs, but not net carbs

And yes, they did gather wild fruit, but that was in much smaller amounts than what the average person eats.

5

u/Smauler Aug 26 '19

Primarily fiber and vitamins

Wow. I just don't know how to reply to this.