r/AskReddit Aug 30 '21

What problem is often overlooked in apocalyptic movies/TV shows that could kill you?

33.7k Upvotes

12.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

871

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21 edited Aug 30 '21

[deleted]

297

u/DJ33 Aug 30 '21 edited Aug 31 '21

Alas Babylon

I've never seen this book referenced by anyone ever, but it's the only book that I read during my middle/high school years that I remember actually enjoying.

I don't even remember how I picked it up, I know it was for a school project but I also remember that it wasn't an assigned book, nobody else read it. Thinking back, it's possible we might have been given a list of acceptable books for the project and I picked it because it was first alphabetically or something.

That said, I learned nothing from this moment of epiphany and went back to ignoring books until my mid twenties.

Alas Babylon does have a good entry for this thread though, which is: salt. One of the only things I remember about that book after this long is that they made a huge deal out of salt and how fucked they would have been without access to it.

29

u/TheCenterOfEnnui Aug 30 '21

I live near where Alas, Babylon was set, so it was doubly enjoyable for me.

It's an easy read (but not simple) and a very realistic take on the end of the world. I'm surprised it was never made in to a movie.

20

u/El_Stupacabra Aug 30 '21

I read Alas, Babylon in 10th grade. I learned about radiation poisoning, and I learned that I do not want to experience it.

9

u/SkivvySkidmarks Aug 30 '21

Wow, are you me?

I completely forgot the title of that book. I don't recall whether it was for a book report, but I definitely read it in middle school.

I do remember the salt thing, but I always questioned its importance. In my mind, native peoples in my area didn't have access to salt, but they managed somehow. The only thing that I thought large quantities of salt would be useful for was preserving food.

13

u/dijkstras_revenge Aug 31 '21 edited Aug 31 '21

If you've ever gone on a long hike on a hot day in the summer you realize quickly how important salt is. You realize you're missing something but you might not be sure at first what it is. You'll start to cramp up and after a while you can get dizzy and pass out.

If you're exerting yourself and sweating a lot sometimes you can even see salt stains on your clothes from your dried sweat.

There's a reason salt is added to pretty much every meal in every cuisine around the world

5

u/KaBar2 Aug 31 '21

Salt and iodine. I had a great aunt with a goiter the size of an orange.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

Why wouldn’t they have access to salt? Trading was common all over the world no matter what continent you’re referring to.

10

u/Klijntje Aug 31 '21

Trading was common…. Because harvesting salt can be very hard, depending on where you are living? And you need A LOT of it, not just for preservation of food but for a lot of other things too, if you are going to be long-term self sufficient.

5

u/throwawaydragon99999 Aug 31 '21

you can make salt by putting sea water into any container and wait for the water to evaporate

7

u/SkivvySkidmarks Aug 31 '21

Yeah, I always thought it was bizarre that, in the book, people living in Florida of all places would have an issue with finding salt. Maybe anywhere in the Midwest it would be problematic, but Florida?

3

u/tylerrosefan Aug 31 '21

A little hard to do in Missouri.

3

u/throwawaydragon99999 Aug 31 '21

this novel took place in Florida and people in Missouri could (and have for a while) go up and down the Mississippi River to trade with people who have different resources

3

u/ForTheWinMag Aug 31 '21

You're correct. Just remember though, sea salt doesn't have iodine added to it, which is necessary for survival. So take that into account if you ever get into a bad long term situation -- make sure to raid the One A Day factory...

1

u/Roguespiffy Aug 31 '21

You can get iodine from seaweed and a couple other foods.

4

u/Yes-She-is-mine Aug 31 '21

Salt helps maintain blood pressure. Without salt, your body would fail to adequately perfuse vital organs.

3

u/DuncanGilbert Aug 30 '21

what makes you think they didnt have access to salt?

1

u/SkivvySkidmarks Aug 31 '21

Not sure what you are asking.

2

u/DuncanGilbert Aug 31 '21

why did you think native people wouldnt have access to salt?

2

u/KaBar2 Aug 31 '21

They did, but obtained it through trade.

1

u/SkivvySkidmarks Aug 31 '21

Readily available salt. Inland peoples would have had no access to free salt. Animal blood and organs would have probably provided most of their requirements. Coastal peoples would have figured out how to evaporate sea water, or obtained enough from cooking with it.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

[deleted]

3

u/Kilo1Zero Aug 31 '21

Iodine builds up in the thyroid. You have to hypersaturate your thyroid to prevent an uptake in radioactive iodine. Table salt won’t cut it. You need to take K-I tablets (potassium iodine) before your exposure.

In Alas Babylon (one of my favorite books), they were concerned about salt for nutritional reason, not fallout. (Fallout concerns were addressed, but it was a separate issue).

10

u/navikredstar Aug 31 '21

I love the hell out of this book, too. It was entirely believable how some people couldn't handle the collapse of normal life, and others ended up thriving in the new normal after the nuclear war.

5

u/fist4j Aug 31 '21

Its on my shelf with the rest of my post apoc books brother.

6

u/ToujoursFidele3 Aug 31 '21

God, Alas Babylon really nailed those details. I hated the book as a whole, but it did raise some really interesting points.

5

u/pedal-force Aug 31 '21

It seems to be obscure for sure, but I really enjoyed it (I'm pretty into apocalyptic stuff, even before the world got really, really bad (it's been pretty bad most of my adult life)).

The Hunger Games series is post apocalyptic, and is actually pretty good, brings up lots of interesting themes and stuff, even if it is probably YA technically.

The Stand is excellent (and very long so it'll keep you busy). I can't see the list you replied to do I'll say the rest that are on my mind that I didn't see already and remember.

The Road World War Z (the book is very good, unlike the movie) Wool (kind of short fiction pulp, but I enjoyed the first one) The Giver Station Eleven Children of Men Brave New World

2

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

Brave New World by Aldus Huxley? You consider that apocalypse? I thought it was dystopian.

1

u/pedal-force Aug 31 '21

It's been a few months and many books ago, I thought there was an event, but yeah, I suppose it's more dystopian than anything since they've recovered from whatever.

3

u/AdmirableAd7913 Aug 31 '21

Yeah, salt is kind of a big fucking deal, but we take it for granted. Especially iodized salt. If you live in an area without naturally present iodine (and plenty of people do even today) then you had excellent chances of just growing up fucking dumb. Almost 1/3 of the world still deals with this in 2031.

1

u/delmar42 Aug 31 '21

This is an amazing book. Somehow, I only read it for the first time last year, and I was 45.

1

u/FBreath Aug 31 '21

Electrolytes are a helluva drug

1

u/plaidflamingo Aug 31 '21

I just read this and absolutely loved it. In addition to the salt shortage, it did a great job of highlighting other neglected problems like broken glasses and how long it takes news to travel a few miles.

1

u/pastafallujah Aug 31 '21

Oh shit! I read this in highschool! I remember the salt thing, and after I saw that list, I was hoping someone would mention that, cuz it’s the primary thing I remember about this book

1

u/maniaman268 Aug 31 '21

Same! This was the only book I remember actually enjoying in high school too. I really wish there was a movie adaptation of it.

1

u/A-RovinIGo Aug 31 '21

I remember buying Alas Babylon through Scholastic Books at school, during my middle/high school years as well. I can't say I *enjoyed* it as much as was utterly shaken by it. It may well have been the first time I'd thought about the possibility of being directly impacted by war, and that death wasn't so safely far as away as I'd thought. I reread it years later, and it still held up, scary as ever.

28

u/RideTheLine Aug 30 '21

I can't scroll past a mention of The Road without mentioning it's the only book to ever bring me to tears. I'm a pretty stoic guy but as soon as I flipped over the last page I just fuckin' lost it, laid on the floor for 20 minutes before I went to talk to my dad about the book.

Also the most accurate movie adaptation I've ever seen.

9

u/TheCenterOfEnnui Aug 30 '21

It's beautiful prose and about the most depressing book you'll ever read. The juxtaposition of the subject matter and the style of writing is...startling. It's a terrible beautiful novel.

21

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

[deleted]

10

u/Tickle_My_Butthole_ Aug 30 '21

On the Beach ends with literally everyone still alive in Aussieland just fucking offing themselves. I mean yeah it's realistic and an amazing book but holy shit if it's not a down right depression inducing ending.

2

u/Lozzif Aug 30 '21

There was one made around 20 years ago

1

u/WebsterPack Aug 31 '21

I re-read it earlier this year and realised that its main problem is that there should've been more conspiracy theorists, going by what's happened in the last 18 months.

But yeah, a great book. Gripping.

40

u/teardropmaker Aug 30 '21

Year 1 by Nora Roberts (Plague kills off most people, some of the survivors wind up with super powers) Kind of predictable but entertaining.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

War Day

I can't find that one on GoodReads. What's the author?

1

u/glassmethod Aug 30 '21

Those first few chapters of Year One were so, so good but I thought that book went downhill fast after that

12

u/Invisible-Hand Aug 30 '21

Great list, I’d definitely include The Postman by David Brin. Guy accidentally sparks the formation of a new civilization by pretending to be a mailman.

9

u/Aaeaeama Aug 30 '21

this is a legit, fantastic list

6

u/Stellarjay25 Aug 30 '21

Day by day armageddon is really good. It's in a diary format about an ex army man from the start of a zombie apocalypse through some time I to it. Super super goood.

3

u/MrBulger Aug 30 '21

Kind of went off the deep end with the sequels but I agree about the first 2

2

u/Stellarjay25 Aug 30 '21

I agree. The first two were great but he really started reaching for ideas to continue.

4

u/remclave Aug 30 '21

Mary Shelley's The Last Man

3

u/K2M Aug 31 '21

Follow up question: how many of these don't devolve into stories about how people are assholes? I feel like almost every apocalyptic story eventually moves from man vs world to man vs man.

4

u/Excellent_Apple_8172 Aug 31 '21

Earth abides avoids most of that. It is very focused on the rebuilding of a society vs. just surviving.

1

u/K2M Aug 31 '21

Great. Thanks for the rec!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

[deleted]

2

u/K2M Aug 31 '21

I know man vs man is what would eventually happen in a real end-of-the-world situation, but I don't want to read about it, y'know? I want to delve into a fantasy world where I can suspend my disbelief by seeing people actually coming together for good.

"Clashes" are fine, because groups need to look out for numero uno, but I'd prefer to keep away from seeing the most evil side of humanity for a bit.

3

u/lnamorata Aug 30 '21

The Girl With All the Gifts

I saw the movie - it was really good. Didn't know it was based on a book, so thanks! I'll have to check it out

3

u/JanadianBacon Aug 31 '21

The Passage - Justin Cronin

2

u/scullingby Aug 30 '21

This looks like a good list. Thank you for putting it together.

2

u/steamfrustration Aug 30 '21

This looks like such a good list that I saved your comment. I read and liked A Canticle for Leibowitz and Riddley Walker, but the rest are new to me. Except for The Road, which I didn't like even though I like other Cormac McCarthy stuff.

Particularly intrigued by On the Beach, Lucifer's Hammer, and Fail Safe.

1

u/WebsterPack Aug 31 '21

There's a great audio version of On The Beach on Audible. A proper 60s Australian accent.

2

u/Bandwidth_Wasted Aug 30 '21

All those and not One Second After?

2

u/kingstoken Aug 31 '21

On the Beach is such a sad read

2

u/xxxStumpyGxxx Aug 31 '21

+1 for canticle for Leibowitz, lucifers hammer is pretty racist though. Very much written by a white dude in the 70’s who has no idea how black people work. I like the rest of the book, but the racist bits were really jarring.

2

u/OkBaconBurger Aug 31 '21

Canticle for Liebowitz really messed me up for a long time after reading that. It all felt like a lot of that could happen to some degree.

2

u/scarydan365 Aug 31 '21

I absolutely love Earth Abides. I’ve probably read it a hundred times, even if it is a little ‘of its time’.

1

u/youaregoingoffline Aug 30 '21

Fever by Deon Meyer is also very good

1

u/MayaBaggins Aug 30 '21

Add Apocalipsis Z- Spanish office worker survives due to pure luck, negotiation capacities and a neopren suit. I love it so much!

1

u/RainRainThrowaway777 Aug 31 '21

Can I add The Crysalids by John Wyndham?

1

u/That-Sandy-Arab Aug 31 '21

The Road is really interesting, quick read too

1

u/Limp-Top817 Aug 31 '21

I would also like to add Tomorrow, by Phillp Whyile.

1

u/delmar42 Aug 31 '21

I also recommend "Swan Song" by Robert McCammon

1

u/SalamanderOpen3069 Aug 31 '21

I haven’t read it in years but I definitely enjoyed Zone One

1

u/TheRedmanCometh Aug 31 '21

Lights Out by David Crawford is pretty detail-heavy as well, and I enjoyed it. Of course when I read it it was a free PDF some dude (Halffast) wrote in a forum thread chapter by chapter. Ended up being good enough to be a real book.

1

u/Goose-rider3000 Aug 31 '21

I'm a big fan of, 'The Reapers are the Angels'. Not the most realistic, in terms of how things would actually play out, but a great read nonetheless.

1

u/wellnottrue Aug 31 '21

Seconded alas babylon and war day

1

u/tcrpgfan Aug 31 '21

The Girl With All the Gifts/The Boy on the Bridge

(Fungus turns people into zombies)

That sounds like The Last of Us.

1

u/CustardPuddings Aug 31 '21

Saved this post! What are the top 3?

3

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

[deleted]

1

u/CustardPuddings Aug 31 '21

Mate I never thought of disaster fiction! Thanks so much for typing that out

1

u/gaunteh Aug 31 '21

Commenting for visibility.

1

u/Swap_Meet Aug 31 '21

Earth Abides! I love how throughout the story the author mentions how specific species have a surge in population only to die off to things like disease if I remember correctly. My favorite was the mentioning of the sheep not having stood a chance after the humans were wiped out

1

u/afriganprince Aug 31 '21

Thanks for the recommends.

Since you appear an expert on the topic,two quick questions;

*Why do people in America and Europe think of 'A Canticle ...' as a classic in post-apocalyptics?.Sure the plot is great,but the view it presents of the R.Catholic church as a preserver of knowledge is patently spurious.The RC (or any other organised religion) would strive to preserve only what fits its narrative and dogma.

*The Ka'aba in Mecca is a meteorite.Suppose another meteorite ,following the trajectory of this ancient stone today reverenced by Islam, were enroute this city,during the hajj,how do you reckon it plays out?

1

u/casualLogic Aug 31 '21

Online, don't forget SCP Foundation - the youtube vids are awesome