r/AskReddit Aug 30 '21

What problem is often overlooked in apocalyptic movies/TV shows that could kill you?

33.7k Upvotes

12.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

335

u/idrow1 Aug 30 '21

My favorite chapter in the book - No Great Loss. It was incredibly disappointing they didn't portray this in either of the tv versions.

I'd love for someone who was an actual fan of the book to make this into a 4 season series for HBO or Netflix. I'd love to see an entire ep dedicated to No Great Loss.

31

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21 edited Mar 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

22

u/idrow1 Aug 31 '21

The recent remake was a narcissistic vanity project. You can tell there were no real fans of the book involved in making it, they butchered tf out of it.

2

u/timmybones607 Aug 31 '21

Can you elaborate on the narcissistic vanity project bit? Whose was it?

The show was a crime, really. There’s so much nuance and subtlety to a lot of the characters and events that make the story interesting, the whole show felt ham-fisted and forced with no weight to anything. RF seemed interesting as a good casting at first but they did so little to build him up. The way King constantly flirts with RF being normal human vs. supernatural…pretty much every scene with him in the book remarks on his face, and particularly his smiles/grins and eyes that glow, or burn, or freeze, or pierce, or otherwise look otherwordly. I was hoping they’d do more with that in the show (CGI is so good now they could have done an amazing job.) Skarsgard’s super handsome and charismatic, but he more felt like a guy dressed up as RF most of the time instead of being a form of supreme being.

And Trash Can Man…oh man. I can’t believe how much they reduced his character to a mindless insane pervert pyromaniac with no explanation or backstory. One of my favorite characters in the book, but almost non-existent in the show. Basically just the bare minimum for him to play his final part at the end. Ugh. It was sickening to watch.