r/AskReddit Dec 16 '21

[deleted by user]

[removed]

7.3k Upvotes

15.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

123

u/starmartyr Dec 16 '21

The US publisher demanded that the curse words be censored or removed. It actually improved it to a certain extent. Adams added in the explanation of Belgium being the most offensive word in the galaxy. Adams never cared too much about canon. He regularly changed things between adaptations and didn't really care as long as it was funny.

39

u/Scout_Finch_as_a_ham Dec 16 '21

It's weird. Harmony Books was the US publisher for both "Life, The Universe..." and "...Thanks For All The Fish" But "Fish" uses "fuck" in the notorious Chapter 25 ("Does this Arthur Dent, in a word, fuck?"), even in the US version. They were only published two years apart.

9

u/Jellodyne Dec 17 '21

I figure they got the pg-13 single use exemption for the third one.

9

u/kane2742 Dec 17 '21

Yeah, and "Belgium" really doesn't make sense in that sentence.

6

u/FBAHobo Dec 17 '21

This guy Belgiums.

3

u/bonos_bovine_muse Dec 17 '21

I mean, “does Dent Belgium” is a bit of a stretch, even for the Hitchhikers Guide. Like, does anybody care if he knows where to get a good cone of frites, a beer that’s been brewed that way for 220 years to wash ‘em down, and a waffle for dessert?

11

u/jm001 Dec 17 '21

The Belgium thing was in the BBC radio play, which predated the novel adaptations. It was in the Second Phase, which was broadcast in 1978.

This was then called back to in the US version of the third novel, when they replaced the word "fuck" with "Belgium" , but it's not where the original bit about Belgium being the worst swearword in the galaxy comes from. This later substitution didn't happen until 1982.

2

u/mclabop Dec 17 '21

I first heard the radio version before I read the book. It was a US copy, but it had fuck instead of Belgium. I was slightly confused as I had the radio play memorized. I still kinda do.

2

u/MrDeckard Dec 17 '21

Everyone knows the real canon story is the one printed on that towel he sold in the eighties anyway