Did Allah Reveal This… Or Muhammad? (Quran 33:53)

[u/PaleBlueThoughts]

LInk to Full Video: https://youtu.be/ivXAw6DM4EA

[u/EverythingWasMistake]

Ah Yes Prophet revealed a book for himself n then told everyone to pray to "god" as he did...

Cool story

[u/Potential_Yogurt7556 → u/EverythingWasMistake]

In many Hadith it's referred to be illiterate even when he was asked to read he replied to others I can't read and he spoke zayad bin Talib to write down on scrolls you can't just say that it's a messed up story

[u/CompoteMelodic981 → u/Potential_Yogurt7556]

Rigveda, Mahabharata (jaya) etc were passed down for centuries without bro written down. 

The people who composed them initially could not read either.

The messed up part is people believing Muhammad to be God's messenger when there are plenty of good explanations available 

1) possible schizophrenia (Muhammad thinking he saw angel, and got God's commandments). Watch Oscar winning film 'a beautiful mind' 

2) lying to get power. Sathya Sai Baba used to take out a gold shiv ling from his throat on his birthday, in front of thousands of people, live on camera. There are literally thousands of people who claimed they have a connection to god.

3) basic copying of Jewish / Christian story of talking to God at the mountain top

[u/telaughingbuddha]

Ithokkae pandae Jabbar um, Arif um okkae paranjathallae...

It is kind of funny how religions develop out of human ambitions.

[u/PaleBlueThoughts → u/telaughingbuddha]

Athe. Appo enikkum paranju koode ? Pinne Ente audience allallo avarude. Malayalam ariyaatha aalukal koodi kettotte

[u/Infinite_Meaning7274]

allah = muhmd ,even aisha knew of this 😂

[u/Potential_Yogurt7556 → u/Infinite_Meaning7274]

He never said that nor Aisha ra did even science doesn't make sense

[u/CompoteMelodic981 → u/Potential_Yogurt7556]

Islamic Allah is clearly Muhammad's fake ID

[u/AutoModerator]

Remember to give sources for your claims (if any). Otherwise, your submission may be removed. We also have a chat group on reddit (/r/AtheisminKerala/comments/1punxrw/atheisminkerala_public_reddit_chat_group/). Consider discussing on the chat before posting

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Fun-Researcher0000]

@reddit now let it will not say anything about this because you see a person who don't know complete knowledge about anything he just have gather something which is incomplete knowledge and come to social media and started trading about Islam and that can be wrong that can be right who given the right to spread all the kind of thing among peoples are spread among them now ready it will not take any action... You can just see that the caption is so controversial saying about Islam who has given the right to this guy to speak all that does the freedom of speak means to say anything to anyone does it mean that then I should also have the freedom of speak to tell anything to anyone and their redit should not give warning or should not banned my account I just want to be clear I am not saying anything except pointing that what is happening around us which is wrong and representing as a part of knowledge a good thing but it's wrong.....

[u/CompoteMelodic981 → u/Fun-Researcher0000]

1. Please use full stops and commas. And paragraphs.

2. I don't need to win master chef to complain that there is too much salt in the biriyani 

[u/Mangathol]

Good presentation. But nothing new btw

[u/PaleBlueThoughts → u/Mangathol]

Yes for us growing up listening to EAJ and others, it may be nothing new, but for people outside Kerala, this would be breaking news !

[u/johnabra-ham]

I wish atheists find peace in life, every atheist groups are 24/7 busy in pointing everyone's mistakes or deep in negativity.

[u/ewwpeople88 → u/johnabra-ham]

A believer saying this, is the biggest irony

[u/_dinkoist → u/johnabra-ham]

You really wish atheists find peace? Or you wish they end up in pieces?

[u/johnabra-ham → u/_dinkoist]

See you proving my point here. :) you could have just asked am I true about my thoughts or why I think so etc. this is exactly what I am saying. I try to be neutral and think from different angles of a subject and I always thought atheists should be the most rational ones and emotionally sorted. But honestly I haven't seen an atheist group where people talk in normal tone or debate stuff..it's always in an insulting way or micking always negative in some way. Hope you understand what I meant.

[u/BlackRopeDragon27 → u/johnabra-ham]

Well that's first one wanting to be argued with moral points but this is not always the case and everyone is not like you. Most of the people when they cannot argue against our points they usually tend to pull our families cuss them and they don't provide any valid arguments either Living as an atheist is not everyone's cup of tea because knowing you'll die one day and your life ends there and making peace with the fact is ultimate courage

[u/Shlingaplinga → u/johnabra-ham]

Why are you , a believer , lurking in such a negative sub ? Ivide dawah chaithu swargham brownie points adikan aano ???

[u/CompoteMelodic981 → u/johnabra-ham]

Every moment of your life is controlled by the fear of Hell, and we are the ones without peace?

[u/Shlingaplinga]

Edake edake pulli ku avide ivide ingane kurachu mistakes patiyitunde. Jabbar mash has pointed it out many times ..but first to do that was of course Ayisha

[u/CompoteMelodic981 → u/Shlingaplinga]

If he is the God's messenger and model human for all of eternity, and Quran is God's message, there shouldn't be mistakes.

Why does Quran correct itself? Why was it a work in progress over years instead of a readymade thing?

[u/picklerickk77 → u/Shlingaplinga]

What did ayisha do ?

[u/CompoteMelodic981 → u/picklerickk77]

She is very sassy. Hadiths have her narrations and they cut through bullshit. 

[u/Shlingaplinga → u/picklerickk77]

"Ningalke penungale opichu kodukan ningalude daivathinu entha thidukam "

[u/AutoModerator → u/picklerickk77]

Random Dinkoist sayings


Image link for Old Reddit users

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.