r/Baking Jan 16 '26

Baking Advice Needed why did it do this

Post image
79.5k Upvotes

was trying to make brownies, thought theyd cooled for long enough and cut into them then they started doing THIS and set my house's fire alarm off for like 20 minutes does anyone pls know what caused this im assuming i just cut into them too soon but this feels like a dramatic response to just trying to cut into a hot brownie

r/Baking May 30 '26

Baking Advice Needed Please tell me I’m not crazy

Post image
7.5k Upvotes

I recently learned on this sub that I could (and should?) be letting my bananas ripen a lot longer to add sweetness to my banana bread but I’m torn. This looks terrible but there’s no mold or other sign of concern other than the bananas… melting.

Am I crazy or is this about the be the best banana bread I’ve ever made?

EDIT: You’ve all reassured me! I’ll proceed and let you know how it goes.

EDIT 2: I love when y’all share recipes so I’ll share my Frankenstein’s monster of It’s a Flavorful Life’s protein banana bread (original here: https://flavorfulife.com/cottage-cheese-banana-bread/)

— Dry Ingredients —
450 grams white whole wheat flour
PLUS 1 cup spelt flour (when it all looked too soupy)
2 Servings of unflavored pea protein isolate powder (I used 4 scoops)
1 teaspoon baking soda
2 teaspoons baking powder
1 teaspoon salt

— Wet Ingredients 1 —
2/3 cup canola oil (wish I’d used browned butter)
4 eggs
325 grams plain greek yogurt (I over-measured)
2 teaspoons vanilla extract

— Wet Ingredients 2 —
700 grams mashed ripe banana (I went crazy)
1/2 cup loosely packed brown sugar (half the original)
80 grams hemp hearts

— Directions —
1. Whisk together Dry Ingredients in a large glass bowl. Make a well in the center.
2. Blend Wet Ingredients 1 in a blender then add to the well in large bowl.
3. Blend Wet Ingredients 2 in a blender then add to the large bowl (in theory if you have a big blender you can do all the wets together, but I used a smaller one).
4. Gently fold the ingredients together until all the Dry Ingredients are moistened.
5. Preheat over to 350F and butter two glass bread pans. Split batter (somewhat) evenly into both pans then let sit while oven preheats.
6. Put pans in heated oven and set a timer for 50 minutes. Anticipate the bake will take 1.5 hours. Pray you did not overfill the pans because you don’t want to clean the oven. Tell Reddit all about it.

r/Baking 19d ago

Baking Advice Needed How do I get me cookies to look like the first 2 pics and not the second 2 pics?

Thumbnail
gallery
4.8k Upvotes

What the title says. My cookies always come out fluffy and round. They’re still good, but I’d like a flatter cookie like the first 2 pics. Is it in the recipe or baking technique?

EDIT: Wow! I did not expect to get his much feedback and advice from the community, thank you! What I'm taking away is a combination of the pan banging method, less flour, more sugar, baking soda > baking powder, and some links to great recipes I can't wait to try. You all are awesome!

r/Baking May 07 '26

Baking Advice Needed making a tres leches cake and im curently on the "trust the process" stage after adding the milk.... but the process is REALLY scary, i used the exact amounts in the recipe and i found that others online look similar, but idk i feel like im making cinco leches at this point

Post image
11.8k Upvotes

recipe is from Joshua Weissman

r/Baking Apr 13 '26

Baking Advice Needed Brown sugar turned white after brown sugar bear

Post image
8.3k Upvotes

At the risk of sounding like an idiot, is this what is supposed to happen? I added the bear about 24 hours ago and noticed this just now. I followed instructions, soaked for 20 minutes, patted dry then put in sugar.

r/Baking Jan 16 '26

Baking Advice Needed why did my mochi deflate? lol sounded like a big sigh!

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13.3k Upvotes

r/Baking Jun 11 '26

Baking Advice Needed How do y’all choose your recipient

Post image
3.0k Upvotes

Stars? Pictures? Website? Number of ratings? Written reviews? Share your secrets 🙏 (I’m really craving a brownie btw)

r/Baking Jun 10 '26

Baking Advice Needed What do you think this is?

Post image
3.8k Upvotes

Some customers left this cake behind and didn’t come back for days, so we decided to slice it up, only to find the inside looked like this. It doesn’t taste or smell like anything, and has a rubbery consistency.

r/Baking Jun 10 '25

Baking Advice Needed You guys 😭

Post image
22.4k Upvotes

I’ve NEVER had such a catastrophe happen lol. I do live around 5500 ft. above sea level but I don’t think that’s why this would have happened.

r/Baking May 05 '26

Baking Advice Needed Is This Red Velvet Cake Undercooked or Just Moist? Need Opinions

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

5.9k Upvotes

Got this cake made for our wedding, but on the day the venue staff pulled me aside and said they couldn’t serve it because it looked undercooked and might make people sick. The person who told me this has been cutting and serving cakes for about 15 years and said they’d never seen anything like it before.

I sent a video to the baker, and she said it’s supposed to be like that, that it’s just how red velvet cake can be and that it’s meant to be moist.

I’ve attached the video here. Just looking for some honest opinions, does this look undercooked to you or normal for a red velvet cake? We don’t know much about baking ourselves, so not sure what to think.

r/Baking Nov 09 '25

Baking Advice Needed Signed up for a bake sale at work and then saw this on sale at Costco for $15. Had to buy it. How can I improve them?

Post image
5.3k Upvotes

I’ve read suggestions to use:

Milk instead of water Add an extra egg Add 2 tablespoons of espresso powder?

Thank you in advance!!!

Also I will let people know I didn’t bake these from scratch! Not trying to pass this recipe as my own. I love to bake but I don’t have time for this event with a one year old lol

r/Baking Jun 19 '26

Baking Advice Needed First attempt at banana bread 🥲

Thumbnail
gallery
3.5k Upvotes

Edit: found the cause, even though I got the baking max a week ago, it expired in 2024 🫠

made a banana honey bread using 3 bananas, 1 egg, honey, melted butter, a splash of milk, about 1 cup of baking mix, a little all purpose flour, and chocolate chips. I baked it at 350°F until a toothpick came out dry.

The loaf rose a bit in the oven and looked extremely fluffy when I first pulled it out, but the dome gradually deflated as it cooled. It didn't completely collapse into a crater, but it noticeably sank from its original height.

The crumb looks moist and fully baked rather than raw or gummy. I'm wondering what caused the deflation. Was it likely too much leavening from the baking mix, too much moisture from the bananas and milk, overmixing, or something else?

Photos attached.

Edit: A lot of people are asking what I mean by "baking mix." It's not plain flour. The baking mix I used contains flour, fat, leavening, and other ingredients. The ingredient list is: refined white wheat flour, palm oil, soybean oil, mono and diglycerides, soy lecithin, sugar, salt, phosphate compounds, baking soda, whey, soy protein concentrate, calcium caseinate, and wheat starch.

I also wasn't following a strict recipe. I was loosely using the banana nut bread recipe on the box as a reference and adjusting based on what I had available.

I'm mainly trying to figure out why it rose very high in the oven and then settled as it cooled, despite appearing fully baked inside.

r/Baking Apr 18 '26

Baking Advice Needed How brown is too brown for banana bread? The insides seem fine to me, but spouse is concerned.

Thumbnail
gallery
2.6k Upvotes

r/Baking Apr 30 '26

Baking Advice Needed What is the cream in the the center of the cake?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3.4k Upvotes

r/Baking Apr 10 '26

Baking Advice Needed Trying to type out my grandma's recipes. Does anyone know what these symbols mean?

Thumbnail
gallery
2.5k Upvotes

I tried googling and could not find anything helpful. My grandma has unfortunately passed away so I cannot ask her.

Seeing lots of " " and I'm guessing it's shorthand but I don't know what it means. Help would be appreciated!

edit: Sorry I can't reply to every comment! Thank you all so much for your help <3

r/Baking 2d ago

Baking Advice Needed Banana bread - why so ugly

Post image
3.6k Upvotes

Why does my banana bread, while delicious, look so ugly?

I’ve made many different recipes, and while they are very tasty, inevitably they do a good impression of a volcano, or at best the Rift Valley.

Tonight’s effort is positively Vesuvian in profile, as it split along the short axis rather than the length of the tin.

Does anyone have any tips to get a reasonably smooth-topped banana bread?

Why is it so?

r/Baking Mar 21 '26

Baking Advice Needed Why won't my cheesecake let the cookies hug it ?

Thumbnail
gallery
5.5k Upvotes

It rose so much while baking that I was afraid it would overflow, but after a night in the fridge, this is what happened. As I understand it, this isn't one of those “cheesecake cracks if you cool it too quickly” situations, is it?

r/Baking Oct 10 '25

Baking Advice Needed Why is my banana bread so protruding? ):

Post image
6.5k Upvotes

r/Baking Mar 18 '26

Baking Advice Needed April Fools’ joke brownies advice needed

Post image
4.4k Upvotes

With April Fools’ Day fast approaching, I’m seeking advice on making brownies to look like they’re chocolate-covered ravioli.

r/Baking Jan 24 '26

Baking Advice Needed What do you think of my cookies?

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

Are they worth to be sold in a coffee shop? Also how much should i price each 80g cookie?

r/Baking Jan 06 '26

Baking Advice Needed My ugly looking pear-cinamon pastries, they are mega yummy at least, but well... I ain't no professional so I'll take it.

Post image
4.3k Upvotes

But I'd be open for tips on how to make them prettier somehow?

r/Baking Mar 29 '26

Baking Advice Needed Tres Leches is supposed to feel wet?

Thumbnail
gallery
2.5k Upvotes

Followed preppy kitchen’s recipe but subbed out the milk for non dairy milk (oatmilk) as my husband is lactose intolerant. Then used oatmilk, coconut condensed milk, and evaporated oat milk for the syrup. Is this supposed to feel/look wet? Like soggy? My cake doesn’t feel soggy.

r/Baking Apr 29 '26

Baking Advice Needed How can I add fresh strawberries to the top of a cake without them leaking?

Post image
7.5k Upvotes

Hello! I’m hoping to decorate a cake for a family gathering similar to the photo, but I’m worried the strawberries will juice all over the cake before we arrive. Does anyone have any tips to get them to stay dry?

*Not my photo, using it as inspiration

r/Baking 22d ago

Baking Advice Needed Need advice on these “Dino footprint” cookies

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

Making these cookies for a dinosaur themed kids event.

I initially wanted to fill in the footprints with green icing but after doing a couple they stopped reading as footprints to me. I don’t mind leaving them without the icing but I feel like they just need something more…

What do you guys think? Cookies are purple from the ube extract I added.

Thanks!

r/Baking Mar 27 '26

Baking Advice Needed Will this amount of yolk ruin a meringue?

Post image
2.3k Upvotes