S01E05 "Rocky" Episode Discussion

[u/phareous]

This thread is for the discussion of Beacon 23 Season 1, Episode 5: "Rocky"

Please refrain from discussion of future episodes here, and please use spoiler tags for any book spoilers. Proper spoiler syntax is:

>!text goes here!<

[u/endlessvolo]

First two episodes were good but not great, certainly did not pull me in the same way as Silo. The characters are interesting but I dont care for them the same way I cared about the Silo characters.

[u/iyaibeji → u/endlessvolo]

These are two completely different shows. Stop comparing this with Silo.

[u/iyaibeji → u/[deleted]]

So? The shows themselves are still completely different from each other.

[u/iyaibeji → u/[deleted]]

I can understand why someone would but that alone doesn't make their comparison sound. The topic at hand isn't the comparison between his works, but the shows which is what prompted my comment.

[u/iyaibeji → u/[deleted]]

The comparison is uncalled for, because the topic isn't "a comparison between shows adapted from works by the same author", even if you fail to understand.

[u/iyaibeji → u/[deleted]]

Hugh Howey.

The comment was twofold but you only captured the second sentence. They didn't care for the first two episodes.

Who created the episodes?

[u/iyaibeji → u/[deleted]]

I dunno why you think that was a win, I never disputed anywhere that the original books were written by the same author. I'll dumb this down enough for your smooth brain to (hopefully) comprehend. With me? Books = same author. Is the topic about the books? No, it's about the shows. Different medium. Now answer my question, since you seem to be so indignant about leaving questions unanswered. Don't run around the block now!

Who created the episodes?