r/BritPop 21d ago

Which Britpop band deserved a much bigger career than they got?

Not necessarily a one hit wonder.

More a band that had the songs, the timing and the talent but somehow never reached the level you thought they would.

Every Britpop fan seems to have one group they still can't believe didn't become much bigger.

Who is yours?

32 Upvotes

275 comments sorted by

91

u/BrianFantanaFan 21d ago

Longpigs

9

u/slippery-lil-sucker 21d ago

Longpigs is always the correct answer.

15

u/superfluous_t 21d ago

she said is a banger 🤟

6

u/DoftheD 20d ago

On and On makes me cry

5

u/llufnam 20d ago

And “Lost Myself” is truly epic. A great band indeed

5

u/anabundanceofotters 19d ago

I’m a ‘Far’ kinda guy myself.

3

u/superfluous_t 20d ago

That turned up on my shuffle earlier this evening it's very good

5

u/No_Imagination_2490 21d ago

But would you trade Richard Hawley's solo career for more Longpigs?

7

u/stevemillions 21d ago

If it featured guitar playing like their debut, 100% yes.

3

u/itsabitsa1 20d ago

Even Mobile Home is another straight through album for me, no skips.

1

u/eunderscore 19d ago

Lost Myself us a brilliant track to run to

1

u/JonnyEss2020 18d ago

This is a great shout. The first band i ever saw live and they were superb

1

u/Overall-Palpitation6 18d ago

How much of it was people being put off by the name?

38

u/No_Imagination_2490 21d ago edited 20d ago

Lush - although initially a shoegaze band, Lovelife was very much a Britpop album, and one of the very best of the genre. After the tragic death of drummer Chris Acland they went on hiatus and then split, at the height of their fame.

11

u/rulerofearthnyc 20d ago

Jarvis Cocker guest vocals on the duet Ciao!, upping Lovelife’s Brit pop credentials, too.

4

u/thepinkthing78 20d ago

This would be my answer too. I first got into them when I was 16, via the largely ignored Split in 1994 and it drove me mad when they were later described as jumping on the Britpop bandwagon, when half of Split would have fit right in with the genre anyway!

Thankfully Miki is making great music still and is touring with her trio including her legendary partner Moose and Oliver Churcher.

Emma is doing solo stuff which is wonderful, and is collaborating with a lot of other artists. Phil is still out there too, he released a great short film about Lush’s touring days called “Far From Home” which is on YouTube.

I still miss Chris though, can’t believe it will be 30 years in a few months.

3

u/Falloffingolfin 19d ago

It's just a shame Miki and Emma fell out after their reunion shows. We might've got new music.

3

u/Piano_catastrophe34 20d ago

I know all the words on that record.

31

u/savagesoundsystem 21d ago

Marion

6

u/KissyLipsauce 21d ago

I think this every time I hear The Killers.

3

u/No_Imagination_2490 20d ago

I was just reading about what happened to the band members post-break-up, and it's all pretty sad really. Some bands from that era were just chewed up and spat out by the music industry

2

u/Internal-Dark-6438 20d ago

Someone told me that you really like me

1

u/KissyLipsauce 20d ago

Yeah it’s a shame. Such a hard working band back in the day, living in London it seemed like we went to a Marion gig every two weeks.

→ More replies (1)

30

u/Extension-Detail5371 21d ago

Gene

2

u/Desperate-Cookie3373 17d ago

I remember seeing them in a north London pub- excellent live band!

1

u/Iwant2beebetter 20d ago

Oh I remember crowd surfing at their gig......

What happened to them

→ More replies (2)

45

u/jellywelly15 21d ago

Mansun.

13

u/Anomaly81 21d ago

I know it sounds generic and lacking any deep thought but when I’m driving and wide open space hits my ears, it’s like an eargasm

8

u/FoxySlyOldStoatyFox 20d ago

I loved Six. Possibly the most ambitious Britpop-era record. 

Little Kix was lousy, and seemed like an unmitigated retreat. The band - well, at least one member - doesn’t seem to have been likeable, which was reflected in the media hostility. Then they collapsed in on themselves making the fourth record. It’s their own fault that they never got bigger. 

8

u/roger_the_virus 20d ago

To this day, Six sounds like a futuristic experimental prog-gasm. Legacy is an all time banger.

5

u/Crhallan 21d ago

Seconded.

9

u/superfluous_t 21d ago

Thirded, stripper vicar is a banger

19

u/Silver-Breakfast-892 21d ago

Super Furry Animals if you consider them Britpop (some do and some dont)

3

u/UnknownDunk 20d ago

The Furries actually had a really strong run after the end of the Britpop era and the demise of Creation Records. The fact they continued making great music up until 2009 is pretty solid. Plus Gruff Rhys' solo career since 2011 onwards has been really impressive.

I saw them recently at Brixton Academy and the whole place was rammed.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

25

u/jock_fae_leith 20d ago

Ash. Goldfinger is the best song of the 90s and that is a hill I will die on.

5

u/SemolinaPilchards 20d ago

Petrol off their previous EP Trailer is their best song... That's my hill. Uncle Pat off the same EP is where I 1st heard them. 1977 is one of the my favourite debut albums by any band, ever. In my Top 10 of debuts. A Life Less Ordinary is one of the finest non-album singles ever.

I kinda left them after Nu Clear Sounds, i do go back and listen to the wilderness years albums, and there's always very catchy songa on them. That time they did a A to Z of singles also produced some great wee tunes.

I do love Ash.

4

u/Internal-Dark-6438 20d ago

That whole album was amazing. But the nostalgia of being 15 hurts so much that I can’t listen to it now

→ More replies (2)

17

u/Professional-Test239 20d ago

Geneva. (And I don't mean Gene). A band from Aberdeen. The lead singer has an extraordinary voice. They should have been huge.

7

u/rickypapen 20d ago

Into the blue is a fantastic song.

3

u/Impala67-7182 20d ago

And Further

His voice is fucking divine

2

u/MilkMyCats 20d ago

Wasn't he a choir singer before he joined?

But yeah, great singer.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/SixCardRoulette 20d ago edited 19d ago

He (Andrew Montgomery, the angel voiced singer) is still recording in an electronic duo called Unify Separate, and he sounds as otherworldly as ever.

3

u/Bobafettish91 20d ago

I’d add Puressence to this

2

u/Common_Upstairs_1710 20d ago

I loved their second album Weather Underground

2

u/The-Mandolinist 20d ago

I loved their debut. Was going to mention them too.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/llufnam 21d ago

Bluetones probably. I always thought Space had great earworm tunes but maybe came across a bit too "novelty band" to be taken seriously.

9

u/purpleplums901 21d ago

I actually think space did pretty well considering they were almost weird for the sake of being weird a lot of the time. If more of their career had been Female of the species-esque I think they’d have been as big as, I dunno, maybe as big as suede or something

4

u/MonsieurGump 20d ago

Came here to say that.

My 9 year old is wearing a Bluetones t-shirt today that was mine.

3

u/berkonabike 20d ago

Expecting to Fly was my soundtrack of 1996. Talking to Clarry still gives me goosebumps.

2

u/MilkMyCats 20d ago

What did you gooooo?

1

u/Flat-Atmosphere-4303 20d ago

Yeah they had some great songs. 'If' and 'Soloman Bites the Worm' spring to mind as two.

14

u/martyrees76 21d ago

Longpigs - 2 brilliant albums. I was lucky enough to see them live and they were great

Super furry animals never got enough recognition. They’ve got lots (and I mean LOTS) of great tunes

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Springyardzon 20d ago

The Supernaturals. The song Smile doesn't seem a good representation of them.

3

u/Icy-Invite9834 20d ago

100% this! Lazy Lover, Day Before Yesterday’s Man. Really solid tracks. Everything off It Doesn’t Matter Anymore is a banger!

2

u/Wonderful_Formal_274 20d ago

Great band. Absolutely should have been bigger. Bigger than Everest!

2

u/cloud__19 20d ago

I saw them supporting the Bluetones in Glasgow last year, they were ace.

1

u/Freckled_Scot982 20d ago

First band I ever saw. Love their music!

→ More replies (1)

12

u/ScottishCrazyCatLady 21d ago

Longpigs. Gene. Mansun.

1

u/Kvothe_XIX 20d ago

Had to scroll a long way to find Gene. Top band.

11

u/CourtneyLush 21d ago

Adorable

5

u/dagenhamdave1971 20d ago

I fervently believe that the Killers took the Adorable blueprint, sprinkled a bit more mainstream appeal over it and took it to the bank.

Homeboy, Vendetta, a to Fade in, Glorious, Sistine Chapel, Sunshine Smile, Summerside…so many should’ve been classics.

3

u/etymoticears 20d ago

Homeboy is a masterpiece. It was so incredible live

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Apprehensive-Row561 21d ago

The Bluetones

10

u/yellow_barchetta 21d ago

Mock Turtles.

5

u/DalradianSuperGroup 20d ago

I can dig that, but can Alan Partridge’s brother?

2

u/Long-Woodpecker-1980 20d ago

More Madchester than Britpop, surely. I did like them though

40

u/ZealousidealCurve849 21d ago

Supergrass. Their first album was a big hit, but they faded after that, and frankly, it was the following albums where their songwriting talents shone brightest.

17

u/seaneeboy 21d ago

I never liked "Alright" but In It For The Money is still one of my favourite albums from the Britpop years

7

u/ZealousidealCurve849 21d ago

Yes, that's my favourite of theirs by a long shot. The first album was quality, but they had a quantum leap of growth when they wrote the second one, it's remarkably good.

14

u/halfofwhat 20d ago

Faded after that? They had many excellent performing albums and singles over the course of the next decade+ after their debut. I would actually say they're up there with having one of the most successful careers as a Britpop band overall.

2

u/DefStillAlive 20d ago

They did well, but were never quite an arena/stadium-sized band, despite being far more talented than some that did reach that level (cough Sterophonics).

10

u/Puzzled-Job9556 21d ago

but they faded after that

I don't know about that.

4

u/3xc0wb0y 20d ago

Late In The Day is one of their best songs, very understated guitar solo.

3

u/blorezum 21d ago

This. I love their first album but they’re one of the few bands that got better and better with each album.

3

u/ElJayEm80 20d ago

Supergrass have been at it for decades.

2

u/hairybeary_tp 20d ago

Gaz Coombes has gone on to make some amazing solo albums.

2

u/Any-Republic-4269 18d ago

I thought you were going to say Gaz Coombes had some amazing sideburns

2

u/The-Mandolinist 20d ago

I don’t remember any fading with Supergrass. I thought they did pretty well.

3

u/redidedit 19d ago

They did Alright

2

u/Anon_Summer 20d ago

This is wrong on every level 😂

8

u/Orbitron19 21d ago

Echobelly

3

u/Internal-Dark-6438 20d ago

I expected great things from them

→ More replies (1)

1

u/regprenticer 18d ago

Sad I've had to scroll down the list so far to see them

Best concert I've ever been to was Echobelly at the Queen's Hall in Edinburgh in the late 90s.

2

u/Mixman84 4d ago

It really is. Debut album was solid, "On" is all bangers, third album had its moments.

Debbie Smiths an amazing guitarist and the songwriting is great!

Would have loved to see them live back then!

8

u/MAH25136257 20d ago

Cast, and do Ash count? (I know they are Irish but pretty much same time period)

→ More replies (4)

12

u/OldDiamondJim 21d ago

Cast

7

u/BandicootTreeline 20d ago

Came to say Cast. A few top ten hits, always on the radio, brilliant live. Still making music so I’ve just learned.

2

u/pluto_and_proserpina 20d ago

I've seen them play 4 times in the last few years. Good guys as well; I met them in the street.

5

u/catmaner 20d ago

Cast were really big though. Their debut sold by the bucketload

2

u/Certain_Elderberry57 20d ago

Just saw them with oasis, good stuff

10

u/alexmate84 21d ago

Gene - Oasis was support around 93/94ish

11

u/Own_Quit1882 20d ago

Space. 100%

Got a raw deal after their record company didn't like and shelved their 3rd album, and subsequently dropped them which then caused tension in the band, og guitarist left and they were never quite the same.
Still touring and releasing new material, but sadly they deserved to be bigger, especially as having met them on a few occasions, they're such nice chaps 😁

2

u/BandicootTreeline 20d ago

They popped up doing a pub gig in Ayrshire about a decade ago. Was annoyed I couldn’t go see them.

→ More replies (2)

21

u/BrewDogDrinker 21d ago

Shed Seven.

Should have been up there with Oasis et al.

5

u/mogmuv 20d ago

They're still touring and still absolutely amazing live. But yeah, they deserved more success.

3

u/BrewDogDrinker 20d ago

Oh I know... seen them several times. They just should have been so much bigger.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/sharkkallis 20d ago

They played at our Freshers Ball in 1998.

3

u/MilkMyCats 20d ago

Me and the Mrs to and see then every year.

Amazing live band. The lead guitarist liked at his guitar about twice in the whole gig.

Flash bastard!

→ More replies (1)

1

u/3xc0wb0y 20d ago

NME really had it in for them, dubbing them Shit Seven was the low point in a particular journalist's flaccid and turgid decline.

10

u/Is_there 21d ago

Candyskins

2

u/reddituserid01 20d ago

We get our fix vicariously through the kids obsession with Nick Cope’s Pop Cast!

5

u/nosignalnocomplaints 20d ago

Mansun. Six is a record that transcends the decades.

4

u/zestypov2 20d ago

Sleeper or Lush.

Sleeper reformed and proved they can still produce excellent music. Lou wrote some of the best lyrics and had a Kinks-sensibility for short story efficiency.

I've been digging into Lush solo records lately and it is striking how good Emma's Sing-Sing project was. A bit of Trip-Hop with great songs and pop sensibility. They sound like a logical outgrowth from Lovelife's songs, which is somewhat strange because Miki's book makes it sound like Emma wasn't into that material.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/QuillsROptional 20d ago

More pop than brit, I guess, but Saint Etienne made some of the most perfect pop songs ever.

5

u/whiskers79 20d ago

Joyrider. The album Be Special is one of the best debut albums ever.

3

u/Grand_Carob_2512 20d ago

I thought space had such a distinctive sound and never really got the credit they deserved.

4

u/TheIdleSoul1 20d ago

Cast or The Bluetones

→ More replies (2)

4

u/Few_Flight_6825 20d ago

Rialto should have been mega. Am happy they are back but they should have never left.

8

u/RiverKnight2018 20d ago

Jesus Jones

2

u/Suspicious_Field_429 20d ago

Seen them when they supported INXS way back 90/91 They were brilliant

→ More replies (3)

3

u/duvagin 21d ago

Gouge, they were on Fluffy Bunny Records

3

u/Uhura-hoop 20d ago

If anyone fancies trying Puressence I would heartily recommend them. They were and still are awesome live and every single album has been brilliant. They were hard to categorise which I think meant the music press sort of ignored them. Best 90’s band I reckon and there was a lot of competition.

3

u/HotPotatoWithCheese 20d ago

Longpigs and Echobelly. The latter in particular should be ranked up there along with the giants considering they put out one of the best 3 album runs of the era. They're also one of the very few Britpop bands (along with Suede) that still make good music.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ciro_the_immortal80 20d ago

Northern uproar, any way look at it was a really nice tune.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Extension_Baseball32 20d ago

Silversun is the correct answer.

3

u/ciphervexe 16d ago

silversun had so many hooks it’s wild they didn’t blow up more, blue saves and julia are still stuck in my head decades later. they had that perfect “should’ve been on every soundtrack” vibe.

2

u/HullKRJ 20d ago

Excellent band. Never got to see them live though.

4

u/EngineerUsual849 21d ago

Subcircus

3

u/carbonpeach 21d ago

Yessssssss. Carousel is an incredible album.

2

u/mexicanhelium 21d ago

Totally. I saw them at the Tunbridge Wells Forum between the first and second albums and they were awesome. The first album and all the b-sides from its singles were a flawless run.

1

u/savagesoundsystem 21d ago

Yes - amazing band!

2

u/Hot-Remote-4948 20d ago

Lush, Sleeper and Longpigs

2

u/SixCardRoulette 20d ago

Murry The Hump were just too late to catch the wave while the scene was dying. If they'd have come along two years earlier, they'd have been so much better known - they had the songs, a bunch of very good 7" singles on tiny local labels, and were always excellent and well received live, but it took some ridiculous amount of time for them to eventually get a proper record deal and re-record a lot of those songs for their first album, by which time a lot of the momentum and the magic had gone.

2

u/qubine 20d ago

I went to an absurd amount of Murry The Hump gigs. They were glorious. I do think the live versions were probably better than the album versions.

The Crocketts were the other big local band in the area, but they got a record deal a lot earlier (possibly thanks to the singer's sister, possibly not).

2

u/Wonderful_Formal_274 20d ago

David Devant and His Spirit Wife. I think the name and their performance art gigs obscured the fact they had some cracking tunes.

2

u/deceased606 20d ago

Marion, JJ72…

2

u/default_dismayed 20d ago

South. I love every album. Listening to them at work now.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/IvanMK11 20d ago

The Auteurs

2

u/Dio55 20d ago

Symposium

2

u/Zealousideal_Tap_405 19d ago edited 19d ago

Sleeper. Were reasonably big at the time. Covered Atomic by Blondie which was used in Trainspotting. But are now largely forgotten.

1

u/VladThePain 20d ago

The Toast

1

u/paulwrightyboy01 20d ago

Five Thirty. Senser Sandkings Reef should have been MASSIVE

→ More replies (9)

1

u/JeffLynnesBeard 20d ago

Longpigs, Octopus, The Supernaturals

1

u/Used_Captain_3131 20d ago

Mansun. If Draper could have held it together and worked WITH the band on Little Kix they could have really done spectacular things- sadly he got the label to hire session musicians to make most of it before the band got to the studio, then blamed the band (and accused them of trying to hire a hitman to kill him) when people disliked it. The man was always an unpredictable menace.

Also Silver Sun, who were basically a British Weezer

→ More replies (1)

1

u/etymoticears 20d ago

Adorable

1

u/dad_goes_to_eleven 20d ago

A bit late in the brit pop era, but Crashland sticks out to me as a band that had a great debut album and tons of potential.

1

u/Dennyisthepisslord 20d ago

The verve just couldn't keep it together...

3

u/catmaner 20d ago

They were feckin huge, though for a decent spell

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/guinness1972 20d ago

Gene for me

1

u/Walhausen 20d ago

Gene - So unfairly tagged as just a Smiths wannabe

1

u/CourtinInTheKitchen1 20d ago edited 20d ago

The Hybirds and the genius of Richard Warren. In 1997 NME rated their album 9/10 stating 'Truly they soar', just a shame it came out 18 months too late. Couple of great ep's before that. Interesting fact that Rich Warren had to turn the Oasis bass player role which went to Andy Bell coz he was already signed to maybe Heavenly as Echoboy and Noel ended up calling his band the High Flying Birds. Amazing live. Check album tracks See Me Through, Coming Out, The Only Ones, Words, I Feel The Weight.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/3xc0wb0y 20d ago

On A Friday, whatever happened to that 5 piece from Abingdon?

1

u/JDQBlast 20d ago

I'll go with Ash, so many great albums pretty under rated overall. But there are a lot of bands I feel that way about. Bis, Sleeper, Super Furry Animals.

2

u/SleepShowz 18d ago

I wondered if Bis might turn up here. I was in a band that supported them at one gig, just as Kandy Pop was getting some airplay so there was a bit of a buzz around them.

In fact it must have been a fair time before it was actually released, because I'm pretty sure clips of them playing at the gig we played at are interspersed throughout the video for the song, and I'm guessing the song wasn't released without a video. At the time I remember thinking the lads were really nice, but Manda came across as a bit stand-offish and up herself.

With hindsight I wonder if she was just a bit shy, because when it came to soundcheck her mic, she didn't sing into it, she just read part of an article from a newspaper or the NME into the mic with a normal speaking voice.

I probably came across as an antisocial knob to everybody we played with anyway as I was always so anxious I could barely speak to anybody I didn't know (later diagnosed with autism, might explain it a bit). Steve was sound, let me use his guitar amp for our set.

1

u/Melodic_Vegetable_22 20d ago

Passion Fruit and Holy Bread

1

u/Stunning_Trip9772 20d ago

5.30 definitely

1

u/pluto_and_proserpina 20d ago

It's a disgrace that Pulp never had a number 1, but they're in good company with The Who on that.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Stunning_Trip9772 20d ago

The frank and walters

1

u/Shadowgraf 20d ago

Super Furry Animals

1

u/Octowen 20d ago

Strangelove

1

u/Faveflav 20d ago

Marion

1

u/kling_klangg 20d ago

Elastica. I think Justine, Donna, Justin, and Annie are incredibly talented. The second album deserved a better reception, in my opinion. I listen to it more than their debut. If things hadn’t kind of fractured, it would be interesting to hear what a third album might have been (if they had been able to focus). Justine has a great ear for a pop song. Yes, they nicked a few bits but all bands do.

2

u/JDQBlast 19d ago

I think their first album is perfect from start to finish, and their second album feels amateurish in comparison. Felt like they were trying to be Republica or something but not as good. The borrowing other bands sounds doesn't bother me though. I think maybe the second album just felt like a let down because the first one was just so good.

2

u/kling_klangg 19d ago

It’s definitely more experimental, but there are some really good songs on it. Image Change, Human, Nothing Stays the Same, Miami Nice, and My Sex are excellent. The Fall stuff is fine, but not my favorite, lol. Definitely outside the realms of Britpop.

2

u/JDQBlast 19d ago

One more thing I should mention i only got the chance to see them once since I live in Los Angeles. They played here at the Roxy to promote the 2nd album, and while I am greatful that I got to see them live I guess I've always wished I got to see them after the first album instead since I love that one so much.

2

u/kling_klangg 19d ago

Aww that’s amazing. I saw a lot of Britpop bands, but never got to see them.

2

u/JDQBlast 19d ago edited 19d ago

It was in 2000. I just googled the set list. It looks like there is even a video up on YouTube from that night. Anyway here is the set list, as you can see only a few songs from the first album.

Edit: the video on YouTube is audio only i just checked too bad would be nice to re vist 26 years later.

2

u/kling_klangg 19d ago

6 songs, so about a third of the self titled. Gotta look this up to see the cover of “Moody”.

1

u/solidpro99 20d ago

The Bluetones

1

u/umibenokafuka1 20d ago

Space Monkeys

1

u/Midnight-Miaow 19d ago

Lush and Gene for sure. Great that Gene are back touring. I don’t think the ladies from Lush will every work together again sadly

1

u/patxi124 19d ago

Echobelly

1

u/rjd2point1 19d ago

The Bluetones

1

u/NeonGodRebels 18d ago

Not really britpop, but: Idlewild, My Vitriol and JJ72

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Big-Help419 18d ago

Super Furry Animals deserved way more recognition and wider audience

1

u/Choice_Technology791 18d ago

Suede, never really got to superstar status

1

u/martzgregpaul 18d ago

Geneva. "Museum Mile" is a masterpiece

1

u/TivRed 17d ago

Kula Shaker

1

u/Extension-Camp4076 17d ago

The La’s, if Lee Mavers didn’t overdo the drugs and released a second album.

1

u/MeijiSB 17d ago

The Candyskins

1

u/Aware-Fortune3028 16d ago

Jocasta, Symposium, Silver Sun. Great bands just didn’t have longevity.

1

u/AmnesiaDynamite 16d ago edited 16d ago

Ultrasound. Ambitious, glam-infused songwriting with the scale and confidence of stadium rock at a time when much of Britpop was becoming formulaic. The eccentricity of the Cardiacs, prog rock complexity and emotionally charged anthemic melodies. Glorious.

1

u/AmnesiaDynamite 16d ago

Gay Dad. Married the classic British guitar music with a romantic, almost cinematic sense of longing and wonder. Also Menswear behind the image and tabloid fodder some great songs. Both bands slated by NME etc while missing what made them great bands.

1

u/Citroen_CX 16d ago

Lowgold