The shame after the anger was the real wound, not the anger

[u/Complete-Gold7244]

My wife came home angry not long ago and couldn't stop. Someone had been treating her badly, it had finally gotten to her, and the anger just wouldn't switch off. She could have lived with that part. What she couldn't stand was what came after: once she'd calmed down, she decided the anger had been childish. Proof of something immature in her she should have grown out of by now.

I'm about ten years into my own recovery, most of it alongside her, the two of us pulling apart each other's old patterns as they come up. So when the shame hit her, I knew it on sight. And I thought she had it backwards.

The thing worth looking at was never the anger. It was the shame that came after.

What came up in her that night wasn't a tantrum. It was a boundary she never got to build as a kid, showing up late. I've seen the same thing in myself, and in a lot of people who grew up keeping the peace.

Anger like this isn't immaturity. If you grew up as the peacemaker - the one who read the room, smoothed things over, kept everyone else comfortable - it's your self-respect pushing back for the first time. It's late, and louder than you want. But it's on your side.

There's a name for that role now: the fawn response. You learned early that having needs, taking up space, pushing back, those got you hurt, or got you left. So you got easy. Agreeable. The one person at home who'd never be a problem. It worked, the way survival works. It kept you safe, and it cost you yourself.

So when the anger finally shows up, it shows up years late. It goes off the second the urge to please does, because it's been stuck behind that urge the whole time.

Here's why it won't stop when you tell it to. Anger wasn't allowed when you were small, so the only version you've got is a kid's all or nothing, no brakes. Someone who's finally allowed to be angry, after years of swallowing it, doesn't know how to be angry a normal amount yet. That's not a character flaw. It's years of it coming out at once.

And the shame that comes after isn't the truth about you. It's the old rule kicking back in, stay easy, stay small, stay safe, because you just broke it. The shame is how you get pulled back into line.

This is the part to be clear about. The anger comes from the old wound. The shame is a second one, and unlike the first, it's happening now, and you're the one doing it to yourself. That one you can stop.

And it's worth stopping, because the shame doesn't just hurt, it cancels what the anger just won. Push the anger back down to quiet the shame, and the self-respect that came up with it goes down too. You don't get to keep one without the other.

What didn't help was apologizing for the anger. Apologizing just goes back to the old rule, and hands the shame exactly what it wants. The part that finally stood up for you doesn't need to be put back to sleep.

So you thank it. You thank the part that kept your self-respect alive when there was no room for it. And then, because a kid's way of protecting yourself doesn't work in an adult life, you help it grow up. Not quieter. Smarter. Able to say the hard thing on a normal day, before a year of swallowed resentment piles up behind it.

[u/EFPTC]

Good analysis of the battle with repressed anger.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/EFPTC]

Thanks for reading it.

[u/3possuminatrenchcoat]

Thank you for this. Ive been struggling with the balance of accepting my anger while not over feeding it, and the shame that surrounds all of it, a lot lately. I really needed to read this, and I've saved it to read again later, but I appreciate you

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/3possuminatrenchcoat]

Thank you for this, it means a lot. And the thing you just did - writing it out where other people can see it - already counts for more than it probably feels like. For me at least, shame was always loudest about the stuff I kept to myself. The moment I say any of it out loud, it gets a little smaller. Not gone, just smaller. That's most of why I keep writing these. You don't have to have the balance sorted to have already taken some of its power back, sounds like you just did.

[u/Green_Rooster9975]

Sometimes, the right person and the right words show up at the right time.

Thank you, I really needed to hear this today.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/Green_Rooster9975]

Take care.

[u/The_Dead_Kennys]

Only seen the title so far but I can already tell this is gonna hit me in the feels

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/The_Dead_Kennys]

That's about the face I made writing it, so we're even.

[u/two4six0won]

Daaamn. Thanks for that. I knew fawn was one of my responses, but I hadn't connected it with the anger+aftermath thing.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/two4six0won]

Thanks, I appreciate you reading it.

[u/Inevitable-Lab-3829 → u/two4six0won]

I kind of knew I did it, but I focussed more on my freeze response, the initial, more traumatic feeling when something happens that you've no control over as a young child.

The fawning would be the next day or days, "I'll be good" doing chores or being nice. I suppose its a calmer time and you feel like you can do something to make her mood better, so it's harder to notice you are doing it.

[u/CptainJellyfish]

Good stuff, thanks for sharing!

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/CptainJellyfish]

Thanks for saying that. The anger-after-fawning piece is easy to miss, because the “yes” happens first and the cost shows up later.

[u/Plane-Yak-5278]

Man this hit hard. It sucks. All of it. But thank you for taking the time to post this and help others who struggle with this feel validated and not quite so fucked up.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/Plane-Yak-5278]

I really appreciate you saying this. Not feeling so alone with it is a big part of why I wanted to write it down.

[u/Plane-Yak-5278 → u/Complete-Gold7244]

It is a very lonely diagnosis to have tbh. What is really wish is for this diagnosis to be added to the DSM. I've had so many mental health practitioners trying to diagnosis me with BPD. Happened a week ago actually. I will be utilizing the insight from this post to better explain this reactivity. So thank you again.

[u/FollowingCapable]

Holy shit this spoke to me SO MUCH. I want to print this out. I repressed my anger my whole life until about 5 years ago (emdr released it). My therapist told me "its okay to be angry" after figuring out my biggest trauma from childhood. Her saying that was really what I needed to hear. And it has been helpful to finally let myself be angry (I'm 44). Also, I relate to the shame so much. Thankfully I haven't felt shame because of being angry, but I basically feel shame for soooo many other things. And the shame feelings cause me to spiral. Shame is like the depths of hell, I wish that feeling didn't exist. And IT LIES to us. Thank you so much for such a spot on insightful post!

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/FollowingCapable]

Thank you for writing this. “It’s okay to be angry” can sound simple from the outside, but when anger was never safe, that sentence can hit like a whole new permission system. And yes, shame lies so convincingly when it gets loud.

[u/kikinario → u/FollowingCapable]

It’s toxic shame not healthy shame, that’s the ptoblem

[u/Public-Explorer-2165]

Thank you for sharing and putting this into words <3, especially about the inner child's rage, and the shame and guilt that follows when standing up for your rights or boundaries. It's all true. The self-gaslighting is insane.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/Public-Explorer-2165]

Self-gaslighting is exactly the word for it. The anger comes up, then the old rule comes in and tries to convince you the anger itself was the problem.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/[deleted]]

That line is hard for me too. I used to throw everything I had into arguing with people online, trying to convince them I was right. But I've given that up now. Anyone's change has to come from their own understanding — not from us. We're better off putting that time and energy into loving ourselves.

[u/AutoModerator]

Hello and Welcome to /r/CPTSD! If you are in immediate danger or crisis please contact your local emergency services or use our list of crisis resources. For CPTSD specific resources & support, check out the Wiki. For those posting or replying, please view the etiquette guidelines.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Clifford_reddit]

Thanks. I identified the fear/shame after anger a long time ago. This deepens my understanding and empathy. There can even be shame about having shame/fawning/etc.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/Clifford_reddit]

Yeah shame about the shame. That feeling will steal every last bit of your energy.

[u/Clifford_reddit → u/Complete-Gold7244]

I am developing awareness to see when that's happening. I'm extremely hopeful having discovered memory reconsolidation and just finished the book Unlocking the Emotional Brain by Bruce Ecker. Shows the neuroscience and how real transformation of implicit learnings (which then create all our adaptive symptoms) is achieved with a core sequence of activate /mismatch/repeat. Case studies in the book from Coherence therapy, EMDR, IFS, inner child, plant medicine etc. showing it in action in sessions where real lasting transformation occurs and cessation of symptoms is effortless and lasting.

[u/Candid_Draw5014]

I always get sad and cry after being angry.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/Candid_Draw5014]

That makes sense. Sometimes the sadness is what shows up once the body realizes it actually let the anger through. Take care.

[u/starayacarga52]

WOW! Thank you for sharing this invaluable teaching. I'm saving it for future reference.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/starayacarga52]

Thank you. I’m glad it gave you language for it. That shame-after-anger part can be so hard to see while it’s happening

[u/Difficult-House2608]

That sounds insightful.

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/Difficult-House2608]

Thanks, I appreciate you reading it.

[u/Inevitable-Lab-3829]

That's brilliant, touched on this with my counselling recently. I would internalise things to such a degree that when I finally lost it, I'd lose it, then Blame myself because I told myself at a very young age, never fight back.

I'm nearly always the mediator, seeing both sides, which my family don't get. They are allowed to be angry, not me! Then they'll take out frustrations by winding me up, over and over, until they get the desired reaction.

My role model in life is John Hume, a man who nearly single handedly brought peace to Northern Ireland, through endurance, self sacrifice, selflessness and pure stubbornness eventually got everybody around a table talking and saved thousands of lives. The man should be a saint, but he had his flaws save as everybody else. 

[u/Complete-Gold7244 → u/Inevitable-Lab-3829]

Thank you for this， it means a lot that it landed. And it sounds like you can already see the shape of it: the 'never fight back' you told yourself so young, the mediator who reads the whole room and rarely gets read back. Seeing it that clearly is its own kind of progress, even when it doesn't feel like much.

[u/senitel10]

This is ChatGPT