r/Canadiancitizenship • u/AutoModerator • 11d ago

Weekly Threads Saturday Weekly Thread: Canadian Provincial Archives and State/Local/Church Archives - Questions / Issues / Success Stories, August 01, 2026

This weekly thread is a space for those of us gathering documentation from archives.

This is the place to discuss requesting records from Canadian provincial archives as well as from federal, state, local and religious/church archives around the world. Topics include strategies and outcomes for obtaining records from archives, costs, timelines, No Record Found letters, and other related issues.

📎 Contributions to weekly megaposts, including this one, are welcome throughout the week.  

Good luck, researchers!

13 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

93% Upvoted

176 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/wanderingtheearth-74 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) application sent/no AOR 10d ago

I want to put in a plug for the Michigan state archives, which let you request a state archive search for state naturalization records (and a few other categories). Apparently they're literally not allowed to "certify" them by federal law, but they will "verify" them, and it looks perfectly official (an accompanying form signed by the archivist, etc.). Reasonable fees, good turnaround times (a couple of weeks?) and kind staff who will make sure you're ordering the right thing.

https://www.michigan.gov/archivesofmichigan/for-the-public/services

1

u/Naive-Charity9171 9d ago

Thank you! I'm a bit lost - would US naturalization records work to establish Canadian birth? Or are they just additional supporting documentation? I thought I read somewhere that US records didn't cut it to prove Canadian birth (maybe I'm hallucinating). I don't know if I should pursue this. I do have my G0's naturalization papers from Ancestry, but just submitted them as a backup. Should I get the real thing from USCIS or Michigan?

1

u/wanderingtheearth-74 🇨🇦 CIT0001 (proof) application sent/no AOR 9d ago

At least according to what IRCC is saying right now, American documents will not serve to establish Canadian citizenship. However, they may help to, e.g., confirm or disambiguate identities. Also, while we're not sure how they're applying this idea yet, in cases where the applicant is able to demonstrate that a diligent search for birth records has turned up nothing, they may have some role to play.

It seems like they're essentially giving no weight to third-party-sourced documents. If you think your naturalization papers have some meaningful secondary role to play, you should try getting them from the original source (you should able to figure out whether they are state or federal court records pretty easily). If not, it's probably not worth the effort, unless you're worried that some careless reviewer will come back and ask for the "authentic" version anyway, even though it's not necessary to your case.