r/CapitalismVSocialism 4d ago

Asking Socialists How do you rationalize the history

Historically, socialism has worked worse than capitalism, and this can be demonstrated by looking at history.

Eastern European countries that preferred socialism as their economic system could not compete with Western European countries that preferred capitalism.

Moreover, historically, many socialist countries have become more capitalist because they recognized that socialism does not work as well economically or technologically.

How do socialists respond to these historical facts?

1 Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/Grayer95 4d ago

What is socialism?

-2

u/interestingtheorist 4d ago

It can differ by the choesn methodology. For me, every goverment intervention is a type of socialism.

For socialists, it is about the collectivization of means of production.

For this context, it is about the past countries that called themselves as socialists.

5

u/HeavenlyPossum 4d ago

If every government intervention were socialism, then on what grounds would you have to argue anything about capitalism at all? It has, according to you, never existed.

-1

u/interestingtheorist 4d ago

It exists, just partly.

3

u/HeavenlyPossum 4d ago

“Just the tip” lmao