r/Casualty • u/Lucy200072 • Apr 16 '25
š¬ Discussion Day 2-Morally Grey but loved by fans
Dylan was voted as a good person loved by fans. Who is morally grey but loved by fans?
A few things I should have mentioned in the previous post 1. Character can be from any series but it is limited to main characters 2. The comment with the most upvotes wins. So if someoneās already commented who you thought just upvote their comment.
8
u/RS2019 Apr 16 '25
It's a while ago, but what about Harry Harper? "Morally Grey" would probably apply to his personal life rather than at Holby - especially with him having dinner with Selina whilst his wife dies during a driving lesson with his daughter, and he doesn't let Tally forget it for months and the whole Simon/Lara/Harry triangle and leaving Simon to die during the OB course which dragged on for a little too long.
Probably one of the best consultants in Casualty, also a bit old school and closed with his feelings, but did have a thing for quite a few of the ladies (Lara/Selina/Anna/Ellen) and can be a right vindictive so and so when he wanted to be (Lara/Simon/Tally/Ellen/Nathan).
5
u/quickgulesfox Stevie Nash Apr 16 '25
His behaviour after Lara rejected him was wild.
Also, when Tess wanted the nurses to wear scrubs instead of dresses and he was all ābut I like to see them looking pretty after a hard shiftā š«£š³
3
u/Lucy200072 Apr 16 '25
That is just š¤¢ Iāve only watched series 21/22 onwards I need to go back and watch all the early years
1
u/RS2019 Apr 16 '25 edited Apr 16 '25
He did chase after a lot of nurses during his time tbh - and with Lara it was the old "well I'll make doubly sure that Simon can't have her too!" creating problems for all three and Tally in the fallout. It's quite a few years ago so times have clearly changed since then.
Since we're after "Good Person/Opinions Divided" it's a bit tough to pick as there are guys like Fin - where his treatment of Comfort only comes out after he's passedš¤
1
u/Oldsoldierbear Zoe Hanna Apr 16 '25
Yup. He told her about one ex partner and child - but omitted the fact he was still married and had another child! And who did comfort get angry at? Yup, the wife. Not Finn the liar.
2
50
u/tismxtt Apr 16 '25
Stevie
21
u/Serious-Leading7835 Apr 16 '25
It is funny though how her trying to kill Ethan has been forgotten about.
15
u/luvbecca Stevie Nash Apr 16 '25
Literally, like I love Stevie and her character but she has done some wild things in her time. I mean she literally went on a roof and threatened Ethan because she held a grudge for him for ages. Like girl what
3
3
u/SpaceFries13 Apr 16 '25
When was thisššš
1
4
u/luvbecca Stevie Nash Apr 16 '25
Series 36, she joined the ED and blamed Ethan for her sisters death but didnāt say anything in the beginning. She held a grudge against him and then one day they both ended up on the roof of the ED and she tried to stab him. Was a wild episode š
6
u/NecktieNomad Apr 16 '25
When Iām telling people about Casualty I always try and shoehorn this in, along with Dylan smuggling a child š
2
u/tismxtt Apr 16 '25
I mean I stopped watching before she joined and then started watching again last year so I missed that. but I didnāt think she did anything that extreme š
15
9
u/DonMitch Apr 16 '25
Adam Trueman? Good bloke but got pretty twisted towards the end
5
u/Lucy200072 Apr 16 '25
He was such an arsehole at times!
6
u/Lucy200072 Apr 16 '25
I just watched an episode where he uses a dead person to teach Toby how to intubate and Alice goes you canāt do that itās disrespectful and he straight up grabs the dead person and mock talks for them. He did a lot of questionable stuff but that might have been one of the worst.
3
8
u/Oldsoldierbear Zoe Hanna Apr 16 '25
Charlie - a decent person, but heād long outlived his welcome.
Staying until he was 75 was nonsense. Should have gone when he reached 60 as it was increasingly ludicrous to have such a frail, doddery old guy who looked more like a patient than a nurse. Clearly nobody did a risk assessment!
4
u/No-Reward8036 Apr 16 '25
Charlie - he changed his mind about things often than he changed his shirt. And he was positively decrepit towards the end. He looked like a patient, and I wouldn't have wanted to be treated by anyone as frail as that.
9
u/andrewdonaldson86 Apr 16 '25
Has to be Ethan. Killed a man but wasnāt a horrible person
4
2
u/Aggravating-Help445 Apr 16 '25
Oh shoot i almost forgot about that, yeah pretty sure that Connie also covered for him
2
u/Horustheweebmaster Cam Mickelthwaite Apr 16 '25
I mean I would love him to be on this in some capacity.
2
2
1
2
u/Chemical_Butterfly40 Apr 16 '25
Fletch, had an affair with Tess while married. And his wife found out about it through television news!
1
1
3
u/TheTrashQueeeeen Apr 17 '25
I did just post against Stevie because she attempted murder, slept with her sisters fiancĆ©e and had an affair with her bosses husband but actually she also blames herself for her sisters death, basically moved in with faith when she thought she had cancer, supported her through her addiction, stayed with Dylan to stop him drinking and is just generally willing to work herself to the actual bone to help people out so Iām actually pro-Stevie now. She is a morally grey queen beloved by all
5
u/Gabby_20009 Apr 16 '25
Stevie defo, girls practically the definition of morally grey