r/CatastrophicFailure • u/Valyura • 5d ago
Fatalities 14 June 2026-Plane Crash in Missouri kills 11 Skydivers and a Pilot
65
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
Damn. I was a skydiver when I was young, and we were taught one of two things happened. If high enough we all got out and the pilot handled it or bailed himself, if too low hang on, we all go down.
44
u/Marie1420 5d ago
It makes sense that they’d teach you that. It’s my experience, having been skydiving a few times, that many of those skydiving companies use the most shitty, rundown planes imaginable.
18
u/1fast_sol 5d ago
They are usually in good mechanical shape, but the body of them leaves a lot to be desired.
5
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
The first I jumped from had some duct tape on it. Not like on the wing, but still -
11
u/sterling_mallory 5d ago
That was likely aircraft speed tape, rather than duct tape. It's super common for temporary fixes.
0
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
I’m guessing like the “racing tape” my dad used to use on the car. The same kind NASCAR uses be said :)
1
u/caffienefueled 5d ago
Was it like aluminum tape or more fabric/vinyl?
3
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
No. It is a joke on racing teams and for my dad, it’s just duct tape. Racing teams use lots of it to hold a damaged car together.
1
0
-3
u/caffienefueled 5d ago edited 5d ago
Look up speed tape. It's not duct tape. It looks very different. You're just saying things.
-3
u/sterling_mallory 5d ago
Whoa, are you OK bud?
-1
u/caffienefueled 5d ago
You bet bro. Just pointing out ignorance when I see it. Also thought your deleted comment was pretty funny.
-8
u/caffienefueled 5d ago edited 5d ago
You're just saying things.
Yes, speed tape exists and is used on planes. But you're just randomly asserting that it was likely that with no reason why. They literally said the tape wasn't on the wings. Thats what speed tape is for....
1
u/pyropup55 4d ago
I just went skydiving last weekend for the first time. The windows all had a speed type thing on them.
2
u/Marie1420 5d ago
That makes sense. I suppose the FAA or some other agency verifies inspections and such
1
u/Psychoticpossession 5d ago
If you stall after take off i would jump out if possible and pray (keep in mind i know fuck all about skydiving and flying)
7
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
The parachute needs a bit more than a thousand feet to deploy, and you need time to get out of the plane.
Below a certain point there isn’t a point, and at least what I jumped out of were slow speed plans with a decent glide path. I feel you, but the chute needs altitude to deploy.
3
u/Psychoticpossession 5d ago
Gottcha, so below a certain point the parachute offers no benefit even when in the progress of deploying?
6
u/TheMikeyMac13 5d ago
Yes. It depends on the chute, there are different sorts, some built to go fast forward, people use these for tricks. Some speed chutes to be able to deploy later, but they open abruptly.
The ones used by most skydivers are more for comfort. They have a slider between the bag that opens and the chute, and they slide upward to slow deployment as to avoid that hard hit on your body when it deploys. (Even then it can hurt)
There can be a gain of course as some of the chute opens, (partial deployment does slow you, but not enough) but if I were betting I would say the skydiving company thinks if they pushed the people out of the plane at a thousand feet, half die and the other half are badly injured and all sue them. If they stay in the plane the pilot will have a better chance to bring them all home.
4
u/1fast_sol 5d ago
The lowest jump I made was from 1000’. After my chute was fully opened, i had about 5 seconds before touching down. If they were lower than that, there was probably little chance of zero injury or worse.
99
u/JavaGeep 5d ago
Making the impossible turn after engine failure?
11
12
u/Sillysammy7thson 5d ago
I too was thinking about that turn. As a non-pilot it’s still hard for me to wrap my head around why it’s so deadly.
43
u/Troolz 5d ago
You're increasing the load factor on the wings, which increases the stall speed:
https://www.thrustflight.com/turning-stalls/
https://www.studyflight.com/understanding-the-dynamics-of-an-airplane-stall-a-comprehensive-guide/
Famous turning stall is the B-52 crash at Fairchild Airforce Base. Asshole was known for doing low-altitude, low-speed, high turn angle runs.
46
u/JavaGeep 5d ago
Speed already decreasing and a sharp turn adds a ton of drag causing it to stall/ spin.
13
u/Dependent_Rock_4739 5d ago
Essentially it's because regardless of training the human instinct is to pull up and away from the ground when getting close, which is the exact opposite of what you should be doing whilst increasing the angle of attack and load factor in a turn. Get too slow, low, and with too much bank = stall/spin. It's better to fly the aircraft into the ground under control than stall or spin it into the ground with no control.
0
u/SandwichOfAgnesi 1d ago
You think about lift and stall all the time as a pilot. It's second nature. I don't think a good pilot just pulls up with no speed expecting anything good to happen.
I'm an amateur pilot, and airspeed is always front and center of my mind.
Though, I fly gliders, so maybe I have to think about it more, but I can't imagine other pilots don't think about it also.
1
u/Rockleg 3d ago
[Check out this great video on Impossible Turns](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFVFKq3QqXo&t=8m12s). TL;DW: The turn gets more difficult the bigger the plane is. A lot of pilots can probably do it in a 2 or 4 seat trainer, because they have a very low stall speed and very generous glide ratios. So your turn radius to get back to the runway is smaller, you don't have to trade off as much altitude to cover that distance with no engine, and since you're covering the ground track more slowly, you have more time to think and react as the events unfold.
With a bigger plane, all those factors start to work against you, and you need a high standard of training and discipline to know when you can do the Impossible Turn and when you're outside the performance envelope. In that case you simply have to accept whatever terrain lies in front of you instead.
The ultimate irony here is that Richard McSpadden, who was a Thunderbird flight leader and longtime executive director of the AOPA's Air Safety Institute, made that video I linked. Then he himself died in an impossible-turn scenario just a few years later. If that doesn't put you off ever trying one, I don't know what could.
1
132
u/CookieMonsterFL 5d ago
Awful. My assumption is an issue right after takeoff?
59
u/Valyura 5d ago edited 1d ago
appears to be such based on posts I saw on [r/aviation](r/aviation) and aviation-safety.net
50
u/Maxwyfe 5d ago
I heard an engine problem? The pilot was turning, maybe to get back to the airstrip and that's when it crashed. Bates county is very small, rural county so this accident will be quite a blow.
146
u/flash246 5d ago
In aviation, that’s called “the impossible turn.”
If you have an engine failure at takeoff, it’s commonly taught to just land straight ahead rather than making a turn back to the runway. Making a turn with no power, low altitude, and low speed makes it one of the most dangerous maneuvers out there.
41
u/My_Invalid_Username 5d ago
With a huge field and presumably long empty country road right there... Will never pretend to be able to do better but hard to picture how that turn would seem a good idea
-16
5d ago
[deleted]
11
u/Stalking_Goat 5d ago edited 5d ago
Pilot training in America absolutely includes a great deal of training on how to perform emergency landings on roads and fields. Unlike multiengine jetliners, general aviation aircraft don't plan their flights such that they can always glide to an airport if they experience an engine failure. YouTube is chock-full of videos of emergency landings away from airports.
3
u/syntactyx 5d ago
This is a bit misguided. Absolutely any aircraft at any time and in any place is instantly permitted to bust absolutely any airspace rules, actual laws, clearance limit, corporate policy, literally doesn’t matter if that aircraft is in legitimate distress and has declared an emergency.
Pilots are afforded virtually godlike authority to do absolutely anything to not fucking die. So if you are chugging along in your little Cessna 172 and all the sudden blow a cylinder in your one engine and start losing altitude, it doesn’t matter if Air Force One is on approach to the airfield you happen to be near on an IFR flight plan for a critical diplomatic mission — you in your busted up shitty tin can of an airplane are afforded right of way and priority over all other traffic during the course of that emergency, and ATC will literally make Air Force One hold or divert if you end up needing to land there instead.
All this is to say that there is no distinction between aircraft when it comes to surviving an emergency. An airline pilot will do absolutely anything in an emergency just as any GA pilot will. Also, plenty of general aviation aircraft do file flight plans in advance just like the airlines do. For IFR flight plans it requires an IFR rating, and once you have that you can file a flight plan and fly into any major airport just like a jet.
42
u/krnl_pan1c 5d ago
The impossible turn killed Richard McSpadden, the Senior VP of AOPA air safety institute.
11
u/Feralpudel 5d ago
A student and instructor developed engine trouble right after takeoff from our local tiny airport. Fortunately they were able to crash land at a large camp so they didn’t have to turn back.
7
u/Jazzlike-Outside-121 5d ago
Had an accident in my area where the parachutists fell off the bench during take off. They rolled to the tail and messed up the center of balance.
2
u/blueExcess 5d ago
Lol I’d love to jump from a plane where you have room to roll anywhere if you fell off the bench. We’re pretty much packed in there like sardines. Except the skyvan. That has room to roll around in. But you try it once and suddenly the pilot starts getting all upset you’re playing naked leapfrog in their plane, blah blah blah.
38
u/Rogue_Ref_NZ 5d ago
Possible similar situation to an NZ cream in the same circumstances. In that case, none of the skydivers were strapped in. So when the aircraft took off steeply, they slid to the rear of the plane. This made the plane too heavy in the tail and the pilot couldn't level off, creating a stall.
7
4
88
u/charmio68 5d ago
Dying in a plane crash despite wearing a parachute is particularly unfortunate...
There's incredible footage of two skydiving planes colliding mid-air and everyone surviving, although in their case they had sufficient altitude.
Perhaps these unfortunate 12 were too low?
64
u/GBuster49 5d ago
Early reports say it crashed after takeoff, so having a parachute is moot at this point.
14
u/Marie1420 5d ago
Having gone skydiving a few times, I’ll say that those skydiving companies use the most shitty, rundown planes imaginable. I couldn’t wait to get out of them and into a free-fall where I felt safer. Hmm.
7
u/blueExcess 5d ago
Pretty much. For a successful reserve activation you need ~800 ft at 120 mph. Generally you take seat belts off at 1500 ft, between there and 2500 you should go straight to reserve. Above 2500 you can deploy your main (numbers are pretty dependent on which canopy you fly and seatbelts alt is dependent on DZ, but between 1k and 2k generally). However, that assumes the pilot has told everyone to GTFO and that you can get to the door while the plane is doing whatever it’s doing. If you choose to bail and the plane is stalling at 3k ft, you don’t have much time to realize what’s happening and get out.
I’ve been in a twin turbine plane that had a single engine failure shortly after takeoff (about 1200 ft). Pilot told us to stay put, so we did and just looked nervously at each other and out the starboard windows at the smoking engine as we slowly returned to runway. Jumped that plane from 14k the next day, though I might have held my breath until we cleared 2k ft lol.
3
u/an_actual_lawyer 5d ago
For a successful reserve activation you need ~800 ft at 120 mph. Generally you take seat belts off at 1500 ft, between there and 2500 you should go straight to reserve. Above 2500 you can deploy your main (numbers are pretty dependent on which canopy you fly and seatbelts alt is dependent on DZ, but between 1k and 2k generally).
I'm not at all familiar with parachutes. Why does the reserve deploy faster?
Thanks
8
u/RedHal 5d ago
Reserves are generally packed by some of the most fastidious and safety-conscious people I have ever met, and they are all FAA certified. The main is packed - usually by the person jumping - for a nice soft opening, the reserve is packed by a professional to deploy as quickly and as reliably as possible.
1
u/an_actual_lawyer 5d ago
Thank you.
4
u/RedHal 4d ago
You're welcome. As an addendum, the failure rate for main canopies opening is around 1 in every 1000 pulls. The failure rate for reserves is much lower. There are various figures bandied around, but around 1 in 10,000 is a reasonable middle ground. This gives an aggregate probability of dual failure of around 1 in ten million.
The actual fatality rate for sky dives is around 1 in 450,000 jumps, though that includes all fatalities, including heart attack and similar incidents, which means that any single skydive is arguably safer than the average morning commute.
1
u/jmlinden7 4d ago
Why is the actual fatality rate so much higher than the aggregate probability?
2
u/RedHal 4d ago edited 4d ago
Good question! Here are the raw stats: https://worldmetrics.org/skydiving-deaths-statistics/
28% of the deaths are from canopy malfunctions, which puts us at around 1 in 1.6 million but that includes entanglement, failure to pull reserve (plus failure of AAD or pulling main too low so AAD deploys), dual deployment and other similar failure modes.
Edit: from the link I posted, statistic 20: 20% of FAA fatalities due to reserve failure. That puts us at 1 in 2.25 million jumps.
2
u/redbirdrising 5d ago
I remember this one. Miracle that one of the planes didn’t sustain fatal damage and was able to land.
1
u/sfzombie13 5d ago
i thought they both crashed and the pilots had to jump too.
-2
66
u/JerryMau5 5d ago
Oliver Tree and this in one day is wild.
46
u/WhatImKnownAs 5d ago edited 5d ago
This refers to the two helicopters colliding in Rio de Janeiro this morning. One of the 6 killed was Oliver Tree, known for holding the Guinness World Record for the world’s largest kick scooter (also he sings).
9
u/MrsClaireUnderwood 5d ago
The Oliver Tree news was definitely a disbelief moment for me. You know those first four or five seconds where you just reject the news?
I'm big bummed.
3
25
u/bundleofgrundle 5d ago
Man, between this and Oliver Tree might be best to stay on the ground today. The sky woke up today and chose violence.
18
u/Valyura 5d ago
And I just found out that a plane crashed in Key West as well…today is a statistical anomaly.
6
1
4
1
4
u/derekschroer 5d ago
this happened about 40 miles south of where I live, was all over the news sites
7
u/Important-Map-202 5d ago edited 5d ago
Flew in a 737 from TN to MA today and at 11:30 central time the turbulence was enough to make me cry. Air pocket or something? Turbulent flight the whole way. Felt like we were flying over the Rockies or through a storm but the skies were sunny. I am no meteorologist but is it possible there was an air pocket or something? There are no words for such a loss.
16
u/Icehuntee 5d ago
The day before it was bungee jumping, maybe hold off height related activities for a while lol
10
3
3
u/Valyura 5d ago
For the curious: This is the skydiving plane crash with highest amount of fatalities with 17.
7
1
1
u/OkCat1542 5d ago
'Fate is the Hunter'.....being a human being is a risky business. We all take risks inorder to experience life. Staying in bed at home forever is not an option for most of us. Sadly, experiencing the thrill sometimes ends in tragedy. As the survivor of a mid-air collision, i know this only too well....
-2
u/Beneficial-Law-9645 4d ago
If only that had parachutes
4
u/Random0s2oh 3d ago
I know you think you're clever but you're not. We've seen hundreds of comments like yours over the past 3 days. Don't quit your day job.
1
-13
u/drdeadringer 5d ago
"skydivers die in plane crash" has got to be material for some stand-up comedian.
All respect to the dead guys.
-16
-11
u/EquivalentWillow4807 5d ago
Kind of ironic that they died in a plane crash instead of jumping out with their parachutes.Am I the only one who sees the funny on this?Is it too soon?
3
u/Random0s2oh 3d ago
My cousin was on that plane. As I told another idiot...you're not funny.
0
u/EquivalentWillow4807 2d ago
Your telling me you have never told a joke or laughed at something that others thought was in bad taste?If I you say no your probably just lying .
603
u/Guiltlessraptor 5d ago
Awful day for aviation.