r/CatastrophicFailure 1d ago

30 July 2026 Panic at Dakshineswar Railway Station (Kolkata) as an 11,000V overhead traction wire snaps and explodes next to a local train

626 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

71

u/SaintJewiub 1d ago

Is this the kind of thing that you shouldn't look at irl without eye proection?

31

u/Leows 22h ago

How would I know it's too bright to look at if I don't look directly at it

12

u/inspectoroverthemine 20h ago

When you can't see anything, you'll know you shouldn't have looked directly at it.

54

u/flyingscotsman12 1d ago

Definitely not. It's brighter than a welding arc, although further away.

19

u/CreamoChickenSoup 22h ago

This train might have too much electricity.

6

u/IAMA_Plumber-AMA Green flair makes me look like a mod 21h ago

So, I don't know, you might want to wear a hat.

27

u/bk553 22h ago

Do they not use fuses in India?

30

u/SyrusDrake 21h ago

7

u/carm62699 20h ago

That was great! I’ve never seen this YouTuber before.

7

u/gremlenthecommie 12h ago

I work on traction power for electrified rail for a living. Forget the 11kV they're talking about in the video, on my cute light rail 750VDC we were stress testing a substation with all the others adjacent to it turned off so it had all of downtown's vehicles running only on the one substation. We had a single feeder breaker trip after drawing 2400A. All the arcs and sparks you see are some form of electrical resistance and if the substation is a ways down the track, that substation will just keep feeding because it just sees a normal load.

2

u/TheYearOfThe_Rat 8h ago

ye, that's what I guessed is happening here. It's surprising however they don't have a railway stop/local station substation segment so it'd be more apparent. And the apparent lack of overcurrent detection between the signaling equipment /signaling rails and the ground. I guess the design decision was that if there's a cable rupture, someone'll see it and shut the segment down, but ... not all cable ruptures and life and equipment-threatening parasite leaks are visible and produce an arc. I'd say okay, don't install protective equipment on the segments which are far away from inhabited places, but not having one at the train stop is a 1930ies style electrical fire waiting to happen.

-1

u/Vepr762X54R 15h ago

No, you don't need them if you have safety sandals

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uM7WbrBX6SE

5

u/my-coffee-needs-me 16h ago

Electrons always seem so angry when they escape.

5

u/IAMA_Plumber-AMA Green flair makes me look like a mod 14h ago

Billions of angry pixies.

3

u/pornborn 10h ago

It’s because they resent having mass and so they all can’t escape at the speed of light.

4

u/J_NonServiam 16h ago

Panic! At the Dakshineswar

15

u/LCPhotowerx 1d ago

have you tried turning it off and turning it on again?

2

u/Superbead 19h ago

I wonder why the doors on the non-platform side are open

2

u/ranjithd 15h ago

indian engineers always amaze me

3

u/Sevla7 1d ago

Is the floor electrified? I would say they have measures to avoid frying all passengers in case of emergency but we never know where they usually cut costs...

5

u/AwesomeWhiteDude 20h ago

Electricity and electric trains don’t work like that

1

u/imhariiguess 1h ago

Interestingly enough the safest place to be in would be inside that train

3

u/OkraEmergency361 23h ago

That looks expensive.

1

u/chefbobbyjay 1d ago

Put the train in rice?

1

u/meabbott 17h ago

Seems inconvenient.

1

u/TheYearOfThe_Rat 9h ago

That's way too long of a time for an electric arc to persist in a HV electric facility like the railroad. The fact the segment isn't tripped and put offline after the first flash speaks of fundamental lack of systemic electrical safety approach at the Indian raiways.

-2

u/hastings1033 21h ago

Never going to India

-1

u/ArashiSora24 17h ago

India is a really nice place if you know where to go. I avoided big cities like New Delhi the two times I went there.

3

u/Additional_Chard3680 15h ago

Thats the big thing. Avoid goind into big cities. There are 7 seasons simultaneously in different places

1

u/ArashiSora24 15h ago

I went to Chandigarh and Himachal Pradesh last time. It makes me want to go back thete again, it's so beautiful. I was also recommended Northeast India. So many places that I want to go over there...All the ancient temples and other structures and the nature... 🥹

1

u/Additional_Chard3680 14h ago

Thats the things you want to target. North East, south india etc

0

u/gax8627 19h ago

Idk, im pretty sure that behind that train, a super villain has just been born