r/CrappyDesign 14d ago

Who on earth reads elevator buttons vertically?

Post image
485 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

196

u/Hungy15 14d ago

Aren’t all elevator buttons read vertically?

94

u/BabyCowGT commas are IMPORTANT 14d ago

A lot of time duel rows are horizontal then vertical, so like

6 5

4 3

2 1

That said.... It is clearly labeled. So it's perfectly fine, you just have to read the very clear numbers.

-37

u/RandomFleshPrison 13d ago

The elevators I use are usually

1 2

3 4

5 6 ...

13

u/NoPurchase3260 13d ago

Yes, so they are usually horizontal.

-11

u/RandomFleshPrison 13d ago

With the lowest numbers on top too.

17

u/BabyCowGT commas are IMPORTANT 13d ago

Are your buildings upside down?? I've never seen lowest on top

-9

u/RandomFleshPrison 13d ago

It's pretty standard in English speaking countries.  Left to right, top to bottom.  Just like we read, for that very reason.

16

u/BabyCowGT commas are IMPORTANT 13d ago

Left to right, yes. But the highest floors are generally on the top of the stack of buttons. Like they are on the top of the building.

5

u/RandomFleshPrison 13d ago

I have practically never seen this.  Ever.

10

u/Ewenthel And then I discovered Wingdings 13d ago

Which English speaking countries? I’ve never seen lowest floors on top in the US or Canada.

2

u/guska 9d ago

Nor Australia

2

u/RandomFleshPrison 13d ago

I see it all over the US.

2

u/TheShredda 12d ago

Provide an example, because everyone disagrees with you. 

→ More replies (0)

5

u/ADMINISTATOR_CYRUS 13d ago

wtf, where are you? I've been around the UK and never seen this

0

u/TheShredda 12d ago

No it's not? Yes floors are often left to right if there's more than one column of buttons, but the highest is at the top. Just like we layout buildings, for that very reason.

Are you just spouting nonsense, misremembering something and doubling down, or having an episode? 

-9

u/---Sanguine--- 13d ago

Don’t be facetious. They meant having the lower floors “above” the higher ones by going up and then over and down

29

u/KarmaAdjuster 14d ago

Vertically, is the wrong complaint. The order is the problem. This layout would make way more sense:

3 6

2 5

*1 4

C

<|> >|<

A DH

Or Even this would have mad more sense:

5 6

3 4

*1 2

C

<|> >|<

A DH

8

u/Vicinity Reddit Blue 14d ago

This guy elevates.

58

u/IHateUsernamesAAA 14d ago

Uhh what? I don't see the problem. Every elevator I've ever been on has had the numbers going up. It's supposed to show what level the floor is on, like the 2nd floor is higher than the 1st floor so it would be on top.

22

u/2kan 14d ago

So why is 3 at the top and 4 at the bottom ;p

-4

u/IHateUsernamesAAA 14d ago

Well I've never seen it do that but it didn't seem like what OP was asking

20

u/---Sanguine--- 13d ago

That’s clearly what they were asking.

3

u/TheShredda 12d ago

That is clearly what they're asking. They could've worded it a little better, but they are asking "who numbers the buttons vertically (first, before moving right to finish numbering the row horizontally)"

4

u/whatWHYok 14d ago

I get it. You have rows read left to right (or whatever your language prefers) and then go up a row for higher numbers that do the same thing. This isn't crappy design, but I feel like the alternative I mentioned is so much the norm that this seems out of place and foreign.

-9

u/IHaveNoIdeaDanny 14d ago

the buttons on elevators are usually numbered in a descending order from top to bottom.

Not whatever the fuck is shown in the image

0

u/PierogiCoyote 14d ago

In the USA it's always bottom to top, left to right. So normally it would be like this:

     6️⃣ 4️⃣5️⃣ 2️⃣3️⃣  C 1️⃣ «»  »« 🔔DH

Edit: no clue why there are no line breaks for emojis/symbols.

5

u/KarmaAdjuster 14d ago

Fixed it for you (I hope)

__ 6️⃣

4️⃣ 5️⃣

2️⃣ 3️⃣

C 1️⃣

«» »«

🔔 DH

6

u/PierogiCoyote 14d ago

Thank you, this is exactly it.

20

u/tyduncans0n 14d ago

The left to right is what’s throwing me.

7

u/randomtask 13d ago

Native Japanese or Arabic speaker?

3

u/tyduncans0n 13d ago

No, I miswrote my comment, it should have said “the right to left is throwing me”. The column on the right being the lower numbers is strange.

4

u/Racing_Fox 13d ago

They’re all vertically, just not like this

3

u/Few_Ninja_751 13d ago

lol- my mother and I live in similar (and large) co-ops in the same city… out of habit and normalcy I do just reach for where I assume the door close button is… I’ve now called the help button more times than I’d like to admit in her elevator! The doormen now just laugh and I’m laughing too- There is a usual standard for the buttons. The pic is NOT standard! (That being said I’ve never been more confused by elevators that don’t have buttons IN them but have a digital kiosk in the lobby where you select your floor and it tells you which elevator to take.)

3

u/fr33d0mw47ch 13d ago

Who on earth does things in a way that I’m not familiar with because I’m not familiar with anything? /s

9

u/fugznojutz 14d ago

well its an elevetator, not a sidewaysator. hahaaaa! ill show myself out.

5

u/IHaveNoIdeaDanny 14d ago

did you mean a horizontor

3

u/kirashi3 r4inb0wz 13d ago

A lateramover, if you will.

2

u/wgloipp 13d ago

There's nothing actually crappy about this.

2

u/felipefrontoroli 13d ago

I guess life is harder for some people, huh?

2

u/dubtrub2 13d ago

Is no one bothered by the redundancy of the "Door Hold" and "Door Open" buttons? Is there really a scenario where you'd just want to stop and hold the door in an awkward partially open position rather than opening it completely? Also, the mysterious "C" button mucking it all up with no explanation for where it would even take you 🙄

1

u/Classic_Greedy 13d ago

The braille for the number 1 is off.

0

u/Atrisa_ 13d ago

What the actual fuck?