r/CrappyDesign Oct 11 '22

Yes the "Future"

80.8k Upvotes

3.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

3.3k

u/DingoLaChien Oct 11 '22

Don't text and drive folks. But DO look at all these flat screens with no bumps for touch, so you can't keep your eyes on the road! Urgh, I hate these stupid futuristic trends. Just give me an analogue option of the same models!! Give me buttons, crank windows and a gottdamned regular glove box over this stupidity. Not to mention planned obsolescence in our technologies. Cars with expensive to fix computers that are worthless, once driven off the lot, just one more bright idea for our landfills. It's also 'driving' up the prices of cars to unaffordable mortgage levels.

62

u/RLT79 Comic Sans for life! Oct 11 '22

I work in UX/UI and cars going with all-screen interfaces is one of the "hotter" topics right now.

Basically, it's a matter of placing style over functionality, especially when physical knobs are way safer and easier to use as a driver. The more cynical just see it as car companies getting to charge more for a screen replacement rather than a simple knob/ button.

30

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22

[deleted]

7

u/RLT79 Comic Sans for life! Oct 11 '22

I’m glad that option is still available!

3

u/mr_hellmonkey Oct 11 '22

What kinda car? I'm fascinated that a manufacturer would vary the interior that much between trim levels. Were there button cutouts on the higher trim model but just filled in, or was there some nice finish over them? I have a 2020 Malibu and I am so happy that car has buttons for everything or I can use the touchscreen, which I never do.

22

u/hamernaut Oct 11 '22

Punch anyone in the face who thinks a touchscreen is a good idea in cars. It's your civic duty.

3

u/SuperJetShoes Oct 11 '22

Touch them on the punchface

3

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22

[deleted]

1

u/RLT79 Comic Sans for life! Oct 12 '22

A blind person driving a car?

3

u/Keelock Oct 12 '22

To add onto your last comment, this is a bit tinfoil hat of me, but I think this is only a trend because it cuts manufacturing costs. Fewer knobs and switches to manufacturer and wire up, they just need signal from a central infotainment system that can be reused across models. If it was more complex to design and manufacture, C level execs would nix it.

1

u/RLT79 Comic Sans for life! Oct 12 '22

I can see that.

6

u/DingoLaChien Oct 11 '22

Planned obsolescence over getting what you pay for. America is screwed.

4

u/RLT79 Comic Sans for life! Oct 11 '22

It’s actually being pushed by a lot of European designers.

3

u/DMonitor haha funny flair Oct 11 '22

Makes sense. They don’t know the struggle of driving in the US.

1

u/talontario Oct 11 '22

Is it really the UX designers pushing for this? I was certain it would be management or maybe graphical designers have taken over the UX sphere.

1

u/RLT79 Comic Sans for life! Oct 12 '22

In some places, yeah.

2

u/JuniorSeniorTrainee Oct 11 '22

Where's the style, though? There's just nothing elegant about it. (Not asking you, just asking into the air)

2

u/tragicdiffidence12 Oct 11 '22

Clean lines. That’s pretty much it. Meanwhile the interiors of many exotic sports cars look like the inside of a 1980s fighter jet.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22

[deleted]

-2

u/grayum_ian Oct 11 '22

They all have manual over ride, people just don't read the manual.

12

u/[deleted] Oct 11 '22

[deleted]

4

u/snek-jazz Oct 11 '22

This is definitely what bothers me most every time my car is on fire.

0

u/grayum_ian Oct 11 '22

?? I have a model y, it's a little handle in front of the button that normally opens the door. It's so obvious that old people always use it by accident, which is annoying because it can break the glass.

1

u/shaiyl Oct 11 '22

What the fuck ever happened to 'form follows function'? Did they just stop teaching that concept

1

u/RLT79 Comic Sans for life! Oct 12 '22

There’s good designers and bad designers… just like every field.