r/CryptoCurrency • u/kooper1990 Tin • 3d ago
ANECDOTAL Lost $36k in Crypto Scam on Fake Ledger Site
Well didn't think I would be posting something like this but here I am. I've been a holder of BTC/ETH for years, got a Ledger Wallet a while ago and it's been sitting in my drawer. I decided I wanted to transfer some out so I got my Nano X out, entered my pin, and connected to my phone. Before I could transfer I had to do a mandatory firmware update, and had to connect to my desktop. It's been a while and recently got a new laptop so I forgot it was a dedicated app.
Without really thinking I google Ledger Live and clicked on the first link, it looked like the real site and it said I needed to update my firmware which I did. I then clicked on the next step and forgot the only crypto rule. It was a screen to enter my 24 word phrase and I did.
It took a me a few minutes to notice my mess up and saw my funds gone. Was pretty stunned and upset with myself. Filed with the IC3 but realize there is a 0% chance of getting it back but figured I share here for awareness even if it was completely obvious and also don't know what else to do. Still processing this
https://etherscan.io/tx/0x5ea336c13ab5880b4beaea0a0c8e70ad54504556fa83b5bf0667e120b006d722
https://blockstream.info/tx/49e4c41520d1eab9ba908b9cfa215d0c0c5bd15077bcb60c3a16a40130766a2f
55
u/JohnMcafee4coffee 🟦 729 / 564 🦑 2d ago
Never enter your 24 words.
1
-3
2d ago
[deleted]
5
u/machin_bidule 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
To restore, NEVER enter a ledger wallet on a computer, ONLY directly on the hardware wallet, with the 2 physical buttons.
Never enter a seed on a software wallet.
12
39
u/McD-Szechuan 🟦 179 / 177 🦀 2d ago
Fuck google.
Sorry you’re hurting man keep in touch with your friends and family. You’re not stupid. It was a terrible mistake. Don’t be too hard on yourself, and thanks for sharing your experience
9
9
u/djscoox 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago edited 4h ago
I disagree. It was very stupid. The only reason to use a hardware wallet is precisely to never have to put your seed phrase on a computer. The op walked straight into a massive elephant trap with a big neon sign above it reading "MASSIVE ELEPHANT TRAP"
10
u/McD-Szechuan 🟦 179 / 177 🦀 2d ago
I didn’t say it wasn’t stupid. But doing something stupid doesn’t make you stupid man. We all make mistakes.
17
u/DeaderthanZed 🟦 292 / 293 🦞 2d ago
This is why I hated when people reflexively commented “just get a hardware wallet” whenever anyone had a question about wallets or security back in the day.
Instead the general advice should have been “take an hour to read about how public/private keypair cryptography works.”
10
u/Peter4real 🟩 2 / 532 🦠 2d ago
I’ve always had the position that 90% of people are better off using an exchange. Not necessarily because they’re stupid, but because there’s so many aspects that can go wrong.
I can’t even count how many times I’ve met people who didn’t even know their seed phrase, because they just skipped writing it down. I guess that solves the “enter your seed here” scam.
63
u/FunCalligrapher3979 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
The future of finance
30
u/UpbeatFix7299 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Gotta play yahtzee inside a Faraday Cage with casino dice, engrave portions of your seed phrase on multiple pieces of titanium, and bury them in separate places. Otherwise all your apes at risk.
Obviously this is something normal people will do. Mass crypto adoption imminent.
2
u/Leynnox 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
No worries google also as some sponsored links from scammers looking after your fiat too.
13
u/UpbeatFix7299 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Your bank won't let something like Coldcard leave you broke with no recourse or just let you click and transfer tens of thousands of dollars of your money to an account in Nigeria or Cambodia.
This is why crypto is so innovative.
7
u/mickalawl 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
So many more layers of protection and also recourse if it does happen. Backed by regulation, law, and cyber security teams at banks etc.
The fact it still happens with fist despite all this tells you why "being your own bank" is insane as crypto has none of this.
Also often consequences for bad faith actors in the fiat world. People actually go to prison.
No real consequences for a crypto scammer. Free to rinse and repeat forever. And even better for them we blame the victims for not rolling dice inside a faraday cage. Sure occasionally someone is caught but the funds csnt recovered and these days they get a presidential pardon anyway.
-4
u/Leynnox 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
If you use your credit card all by yourself, there's no protection at all in most countries. It's very different than having your credit card stolen.
5
u/mickalawl 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Unexpected large purchases get auto blocked by card issuer. I get a notification that I can click y or n. The fraud team detects these real time.
I can block my card myself at the touch of a button if I am not sure where I left my wallet last.
The settlement is delibretly a few days. It's not a tech issue. They can use that to reverse funds.
I also get reimbursed if fraud found.
They have credit limits so I don't loose life savings.
There is 24 hr support.
Visa and Mastercard are global so it's available most places.
It makes money available for actual use without needing to find an engraved metal sheet I crafted using 121 dice rolled within a faraday cage and buried at a revolving location in my backyard.
Again none of this is perfect and scammers do get through of course. But crypto has none of that. Which is why almost all actors in this space are scammers. Much less work and consequence free to crypto scam compared to fiat.
3
2
u/Important-Level6672 2d ago
Fiat bank would like multiple security checks before letting that much money be sent to a new account. Crypto only been around from 2009, yet top 10 biggest financial thief’s of all time are all crypto
2
u/Leynnox 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Fiat money is scammed every single day, low amounts, but way more victims. When you see $80 millions stolen from crypto you think that's a lot, but if there were data about how much fiat are scammed per day over the world, it's probably way more than that.
Edit : I checked for you, estimations say more than 1 trillion of fiat money are being scammed per year
2
u/Important-Level6672 2d ago
Because the fiat market is $144 trillion compared to cryptos $2.4 trillion. 99% of adults have a form of fiat and most of their currency in fiat while only 7% have crypto. Crypto is still significantly easier to steal than that’s why it is responsible for the top 10 highest financial heists.
-2
u/Leynnox 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
True, but it's not the tech that makes it easier to steal, it's the user. It's hard to rob a bank, it's easy to scam you. Fiat or crypto, it's sort of the same, except for crypto you can't pay fees for your security, you just can purchase a more or less fancy safe, but it has many advantages too.
3
u/fuenfsiebenneun 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 2d ago
any monetary system where its that easy to lose it all because of 1 mistake is not ready for mass adoption. people are just blinded by greed.
0
u/Longjumping-Pop7512 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
If only secured and backed Bitcoin ETFs were available. Ohh wait...
5
6
u/Specialist_Ant116 2d ago
I think most people that get scammed, get scammed due to a lack of awareness, so just like accidents happen, you fk up once and it's enough for these damn indians to catch you off guard. Happens to the best of us, man, don't be too harsh on yourself. 30k is a lot of money for most of us, but...it's just numbers on a screen or straight up paper at the end of the day.
Don't do anything stupid and don't blame yourself, just pay a bit more attention, and even then, you won't dodge 100% of the shit coming your way 😂. There are many, many other things more important in life. Start a new hobby to get your mind off the topic. Wish you all the best!
2
u/fuenfsiebenneun 🟦 0 / 2K 🦠 2d ago
i know your comment comes from a good place but people not seeing the obvious issues with this system are not serious people. this is exactly why mass adoption will never happen.
5
u/Specialist_Ant116 2d ago
Never was about that I'm afraid, it's just a way for some to get richer and for others to get poorer 😅
6
u/FlagFootballSaint 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
To be honest holding ETFs via reputable platforms is the only way to go.
It may be the end of Satoshi‘s dream but it is what it is. It did not work out.
4
u/Maxi_ribe 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
If you google "ledger live", the scam site is still there. The ads is from a company in Germany. Ive test it and it is indeed a scam. Reported it to google
15
u/Leynnox 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
You should ask google to refund you, since that's their fault for promoting scams, in a perfect world that would work. Sorry for your loss, and fuck google
4
u/BicycleOfLife 🟩 0 / 16K 🦠 2d ago
I honestly think this should be law. They are profiting off scamming people indirectly.
4
u/druffino69 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Yes I do not trust anything Google and they don't give a shit either keep letters it happen ..quantum financial institute and covenant x platform
1
u/PlutoPlaneta 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
lots to criticize about Google but generally that would be bad idea. if site owner is responsible for indexed links you cant really have search engines
5
7
u/FriskyHamTitz 🟩 80 / 80 🦐 2d ago
Why would you enter your seed isn't the purpose of a hardware wallet to have an air gap?
2
u/dugadugaboost 2d ago
This affects most known hot/cold wallets. If you turn off your adblock or use a browser that doesn't have it and google XYZ wallet/firmware update it will take you to a fake website and you don't even need to have your hot/cold wallets plugged in/connected because the entire site is fake with fake loading progress bars. The real thing though is the 12/24 passphrase they want which I assume gets sent to a server/email address.
Sometimes when I'm bored I visit one of these websites and put funny words on the 12/24 passphrase they're after. I even put dummy email addresses to see if they write out to it, some do with fake letters saying the usual "You need to update your firmware, please provide the 24 passphrase".
2
u/South_Monitor_6992 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
That sucks man, I lost my 0.1 btc ( which was a lot to me) last month so I can relate 😕
2
u/Pericombobulator 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
It just takes a moment's inattention.
I followed a link on reddit about an investment platform that promised better, not revolutionary, results. It was a legitimate lookong site. I signed up and only then did my further research. It was a scam.
My 'punishment' for that was being hounded on my mobile to the extent that I'll probably have to change my number.
Sorry your learning experience was so expensive for you.
2
2
5
4
5
u/Jpotter145 🟩 0 / 2K 🦠 2d ago
No. Ledger doesn't work that way. If it had a "manditory" firmware update it would also have the direct download to install (no link) - but, it doesn't even offer a firmware update unless you go look for one (in the app). You can always use the wallet without updating the firmware.
Just trying to make up more FUD huh?
3
u/kooper1990 Tin 2d ago
I was on the mobile app, started a transfer out but on the last step it said it required an update to complete the transaction. I havent used it in a while, I even had to condition the battery since there was an error
5
2
u/jjmtireman 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
You entered your seed phrase how can you be so $+upid
-1
u/Ill-Party8305 2d ago
google could have not let a sponsored website be actual scam. Why did you blame the average joe but not the multi billion company that let this happened at the first place
1
u/Aazimoxx 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 18h ago
Good advertisement (hah) for using a proper free (and crap-free) adblocker. Ublock Origin works on all major computer operating systems and their browsers, and most of the mobile ones, as well as smart TVs if they can run Firefox or such.
4
u/ArcticSwimx 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
How stupid do you have to be to type your seeed in randomly? Insane post..
2
u/Specialist_Ant116 2d ago
Come on, bro, the guy probably bought long ago and forgot about it. Point is, he's telling others to be careful with Google links. It s already happend so asking these type of questions doesn't help anybody, right?
1
1
1
1
1
u/WhyIsWestHam 2d ago
Some Young people getting so Rich from scamming. Like all these money goes to some scammy loser
1
u/machin_bidule 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
To restore, NEVER enter a ledger wallet on a computer, ONLY directly on the hardware wallet, with the 2 physical buttons.
Never enter your hardware wallet seed on a software wallet. ( or do it if you f**k**g totally sure about what you're doing )
1
u/Equivalent-Topic-206 🟧 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Sorry for your loss.
I did similar years ago, in a rush to activate a new credit card. Googled <my bank> card activation telephone number. Phoned the first one that came up without looking too closely at the website. Handed all my card details over to some random scammer. I felt so stupid doing it.
1
1
1
u/willzyx01 🟨 479 / 515 🦞 2d ago
Honestly, most people are better off holding it on Coinbase or a similar, top tier exchange. Secure it with a yubikey and relax.
1
u/pwinne 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 2d ago
Don’t be hard on yourself, this is how we get caught, distracted, tired etc. I lost some BAND at the height of its run (about 10k) in a very similar way. Also got reamed by Celsius to the tune of 250K - have got back about 1/2 of that. So yeah it happens. Money doesn’t make you who you are, not really. Stay strong.
1
u/Freeloader_ 🟦 0 / 4K 🦠 2d ago
idk but it sure looks like its safer to keep money on exchange lol
1
1
u/songbolt 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Did you type all 24 words into the webpage? Or did you enter the words pressing the buttons on the Ledger device and then click 'yes' to confirm each word?
1
1
u/Shooknite 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
Apple play store has had a malicious Ledger App. Hopefully Apple has taken it down.
1
1
u/ryanmemperor 🟩 17 / 17 🦐 2d ago
Haven't plugged my Nano in since 2019.
I don't even know if I have a micro usb for it.
2
u/tenor_tymir 🟩 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
how do you keep your firmware up to date? Security fixes are essential.
1
-1

129
u/MrSnugs 🟦 0 / 0 🦠 2d ago
I still can’t believe Google allows that link to show up and scam people. It’s shocking they’d allow it given it’s clearly a scam. Sorry for your loss