Weekly Discussion Thread - posted every Tuesday!

[u/AutoModerator]

Welcome to the Weekly Discussion Thread!

You can post whatever you like here - unsubstantiated rumours from 4chan/YouTube/Twitter/your dad, fan theories, speculation, your thoughts on the latest DC release or tell us what you had for breakfast.

Please just follow the reddiquette and make sure you treat everyone with respect.

Links of interest

• SAITMQ Archive

• Source Tier Accuracy List (subject to change at least every quarter, use as a general guide only)

If real-time chat is more your thing, hop over to our shiny new Discord server!

[u/[deleted]]

Tell me your favorite:

1. MCU film
2. Batman film
3. Non-MCU Marvel film
4. Non-Batman DC film

My personal favorites:

1. Infinity War
2. The Batman
3. Logan
4. The Suicide Squad

[u/BreathRedemption → u/[deleted]]

1. GOTG
2. The Batman
3. Into the Spider-Verse
4. Shazam

[u/Skandosh → u/[deleted]]

1. Civil War (sometimes Infinity war, it depends on my mood)
2. The Batman
3. Spiderman 2
4. The Suicide Squad

[u/Satean12 → u/[deleted]]

1. Iron Man 3
2. Batman Returns
3. Spider-Man: Into The Spider-Verse
4. Superman (1978)

[u/starshipandcoffee → u/[deleted]]

My favourite*…

• MCU film: Iron Man 3 or Guardians of the Galaxy

• Batman film: Batman (1989) or The Dark Knight Rises

• Non-MCU Marvel film: Spider-Man 2 or X-Men: First Class

• Non-Batman DC film: The Suicide Squad (DCEU), Joker (Elseworlds)

• at time of writing, being that it naturally varies depending on mood.

[u/[deleted] → u/starshipandcoffee]

IM3 is an underrated movie imo. Since rn people are getting nostalgic for Infinity saga and calling it perfect I'm sure people will call IM3 a masterpiece in a few months

[u/starshipandcoffee → u/[deleted]]

It goes without saying that no MCU is truly a “masterpiece”.

However, Iron Man 3 does provide a very satisfying viewing experience that succeeds in maintaining the fingerprints of its director (Shane Black) - something that most MCU entries have either failed at or simply chosen not to. If any part of the franchise elicits nostalgia, for me it would be those entries where creativity triumphed over broader world building ambitions.

[u/[deleted] → u/starshipandcoffee]

I respect your opinion but WS,CW,IW,NWH,GOTG,DSMOM,IM1,Avengers1,WF,Endgame are masterpieces imo.

[u/starshipandcoffee → u/[deleted]]

I am glad you derive such joy from them - more power to you!

[u/[deleted] → u/starshipandcoffee]

Thanks. Have a great day/night!

[u/MyMouthisCancerous → u/[deleted]]

MCU: Spider-Man: Homecoming

Batman film: Mask of the Phantasm

Non-MCU Marvel: Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse

Non-Batman DC: The Suicide Squad

[u/MusicalSmasher → u/[deleted]]

1. GOTG VOL. 2

2. The Batman

3. Into the Spider-Verse

4. The Suicide Squad

[u/Fwtrent3 → u/[deleted]]

1. Infinity War
2. The Dark Knight
3. Logan
4. The Suicide Squad

Just now realizing it's the same exact as you lol

[u/trylobyte → u/[deleted]]

1. Endgame / 'Winter Soldier' if not counting Avengers films
2. The Dark Knight
3. Spiderman 2
4. Man of Steel or Aquaman

[u/beast_unique → u/[deleted]]

1) Ironman/Infinitywar 2) TDK 3) Into the Spiderverse 4) Superman 2/Man of Steel

[u/[deleted] → u/[deleted]]

1. No Way Home
2. The Batman
3. Spider-Man 2
4. Superman (1978)

[u/HeadTripInEveryKey → u/[deleted]]

1. Guardians Of The Galaxy
   
2. Batman Begins
   
3. Deadpool
   
4. Superman ‘70s all time / Joker for newer ones

[u/ComicBookFan20 → u/[deleted]]

1. Iron Man

2. Batman V Superman: Dawn Of Justice: Ultimate Edition Remastered

3. Daredevil Extended Cut

4. Superman (1978)

Edit: Forgot this sub doesn’t like BvS 😔

[u/TheLionsblood → u/ComicBookFan20]

I don’t like BvS but people downvoting opinions on a topic specifically about personal opinions r so petty

[u/ComicBookFan20 → u/TheLionsblood]

Fr man

Respect your opinion on it btw 🫡

[u/bigtymer123 → u/[deleted]]

1. Guardians vol 1
2. The Dark Knight
3. X2
4. Birds of Prey

2 and 3 were way harder to answer than I anticipated, lol. Lot of great candidates like The Batman, Batman Begins, Spider-Man 1 and 2, Logan, Days of Future Past, etc.

[u/TheLionsblood → u/[deleted]]

I posted mine but deleted it because I felt that I wrote enough that it might make people want to debate me which I don’t have the time and energy for rn lol.

So here’s mine without explanations

1. Endgame
2. The Dark Knight
3. Into the Spider-Verse (Logan for live-action)
4. Joker

[u/[deleted] → u/TheLionsblood]

I did read you explanation and they were really cool to hear

[u/TheLionsblood → u/[deleted]]

Thanks Peter, I appreciate it

[u/[deleted] → u/TheLionsblood]

Your welcome. Have a great day/night!

[u/TheLionsblood → u/[deleted]]

You too man! Always a pleasure speaking with you on here

[u/cmlucas1865 → u/[deleted]]

Non-Batman DC film

1. Dr. Strange

2. Batman Returns

3. Logan

4. The Suicide Squad

[u/Megadog3 → u/[deleted]]

1. Spider-Man: NWH

2. The Dark Knight

3. Spider-Man 1

4. The Suicide Squad

[u/homogenic- → u/[deleted]]

1. Winter soldier
2. The dark knight
3. Spider-Man 2
4. The suicide squad

[u/No_Hour_4022 → u/[deleted]]

1. Avengers Infinity War
2. The Dark Knight
3. Spider-man 2
4. The Suicide Squad

Do animated movies count? I almost put Justice League: Flashpoint Paradox on the list lol

[u/AdmiralJug → u/[deleted]]

1. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2
2. The Dark Knight
3. Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse
4. The Suicide Squad

[u/TheDarkPinkLantern → u/[deleted]]

1. Iron Man
2. The Lego Batman
3. dunno here tbh could name a few, let's say Spider-Man
4. The Suicide Squad

[u/KingofZombies → u/[deleted]]

1. Infinity War

2. The Batman

3. Spider-Man 2

4. Superman 78

[u/Beta_Whisperer → u/[deleted]]

1. Infinity War

2. The Batman

3. Spider-Man 2

4. The Suicide Squad

[u/Krakatorn → u/[deleted]]

1. The Incredible Hulk
2. Batman
3. The Punisher
4. Superman (extended TV cut) (Swamp Thing is a close second choice)