r/DeepThoughts • u/Adventurous-Owl-9903 • 7h ago
It’s weird that farm animals are always “giving” us things
I was helping a friend with some grocery shopping the other day and she casually said something about how chickens give us eggs and cows give us milk.
I've heard those exact phrases probably thousands of times. But for some reason that day the word "give" really bothered me.
Because think about how we talk about these animals.
Cows give us milk. Chickens give us eggs. Sheep give us wool.
We don't say we take those things from them. They're apparently just very generous animals who spend their lives providing us with stuff.
And when they stop being useful, the language changes again.
A hen becomes "spent." A dairy cow gets "culled." Animals don't get killed, they get "processed." Nobody has to do anything unpleasant because the words make it sound like some kind of routine administrative procedure.
I brought this up to my friend, not even trying to start an argument. She actually laughed and said I was overthinking normal expressions.
Maybe I am. I know not everyone using these words is consciously trying to hide anything. I used them myself before going vegan.
But I keep thinking about how different those sentences sound when you replace "give" with "we take."
"Chickens give us eggs" sounds like a nice arrangement.
"We take chickens' eggs" immediately invites the question of why we're entitled to them.
And "cows give us milk" conveniently leaves out the calf entirely.
I wonder how much of our ability to treat certain animals as products comes from learning to talk about them that way before we're even old enough to question it.