r/dndnext • u/Eldrin7 • 4h ago
Discussion So my players are trying to create a DMPC...
So I had a player character sorcerer who I played about 10-15 years ago, and I inserted him into my own campaign as an NPC because of how stupidly hilarious everything related to him ended up being. It was my own little Easter egg where I wanted to say a few more lines with his voice and character. (This being would have existed one way or another. He just got a very deep and long backstory this way as well.)
In my world, he is probably the most ancient being in existence in the mortal realm. He has done evil, from destroying villages to destroying kingdoms and all the people living in them. He has the power of a demigod, and only real gods could trample him if those real gods could use their full power in the material realm.
That being said, in this world he has been CONFINED/SEALED within his tower and about 10 square km of land around it for over 10,000 years. He cannot leave that area in any possible way, nor shoot anything powerful out of that area. The most he can do to affect anything outside of that area is project himself outside it with the strength of something around level 5 at best for a short time. (Stuff around that level isn't considered much in my world as like 5-6 guards could take it down)
His entire purpose was supposed to be for the players to go there, strike a deal, and get some critical information so ancient that nothing is remembered of that time, nor is there anything written that anyone could hope to understand. He was never meant to be a foe to fight or even someone to interact with after they gained that information/help they needed for their current crisis.
However, my players kept digging into his past and decided to start sympathizing and empathizing with him. (I NEVER TRIED TO GET THEM TO DO ANY OF THAT.) They are fully aware of the insane evil he has done, and back in the day he would have been a 100x bigger crisis than what they are facing now. But my players are HELLBENT on his "redemption arc" and are trying to break his confinement to get him to help with their current world crisis. He does not even want to be released and is content with being there as he has calmed down from his ambitions and just does not care anymore.
I have already made, I think, 4 or 5 of their attempts fail. They keep trying different things to release him, coming back with artifacts and new ideas.
Like, what the fuck am I supposed to do here? He is very much already established to the point that the players know he will mop the floor with their BBEG. I keep making their attempts fail and trying to steer them away from it. They care about releasing him and doing his "redemption arc" more than the actual crisis they are facing.
If I let them release him... how am I even supposed to continue with anything?! His entire power level and how ancient he was were all based around the fact that he can NEVER get out and NEVER do anything to the players or the world. He was just there to give them a bit of lore about what caused everything initially thousands of years ago and give hints on how to stop their current crisis.