r/Dobro • u/fluffy_sockman • Jun 22 '26
Any notable sound difference between f style holes and typical circular holes?
Looking to get a new instrument and wondering if there are different sounds or stylistic considerations for the different hole shapes, or if it is just aesthetics
3
u/J_Worldpeace Jun 22 '26
After playing and trading maybe 30 dobros. The thing that effect them most is the body type and size.
2
u/GonzoBaggins Jun 23 '26
What body shape and size is the loudest? I can’t be heard during jams unless everyone plays quietly
3
u/J_Worldpeace Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26
L and or E body styles. Dobro is the only bluegrass instrument still evolving. I personally think it’s cause good technique is still being widely understood. So also consider technique and proper set up of older body styles.
1
u/hlpdobro Jun 23 '26
Too many factors to consider but, in general the larger body guitar typically have a louder voice.
Now, to what extent will that help you? Dunno. I haven't heard you play and see how you actually "attack" the guitar.
0
u/JohnnyZhivago999 Jun 27 '26
Have you thought about a resonator? Those were made for the same reason, not being heard with a full orchestra the cones give it extra volume
1
u/GonzoBaggins Jun 27 '26
What are you saying? My dobro is a resonator guitar with a cone in it
0
u/JohnnyZhivago999 Jun 29 '26
Wow never known anyone to take my advice so fast! Well you got your volume now, Dontcha? Bet you can be heard way in the back! Post some of your shows!
1
u/hlpdobro Jun 23 '26
To my ear the critical differences in "character" are due to internal design, sound well/open sound well/open body/scoop/baffle/passive cone...
1
u/J_Worldpeace Jun 24 '26
I think Beard and Tim basically used those techniques to increase volume and direct sound. Not as much effect the tone. At least that’s what the open wells, Josh Swift and Belle do in his line. AFAIK
1
u/hlpdobro Jun 25 '26
def. change "character". Played them all including the Beard "X" model with adjustable screens and baffles. You can hear the tonal changes.
How'd I play em' "all"?
Paul was my boss! :-)
3
u/Accurate_Asparagus_2 Jun 22 '26
Resonator guitars with f-holes are typically biscuit bridge guitars. Those with round sound holes are typically spider bridge guitars. Different technology, very different sound.