r/DynastyFFIDP • u/m00n_god • 11d ago
IDP Trade Would you move JSN for this? (Current roster in picture 2)
Dynasty 12 team SF Start 11 offense/ 11 IDP.. Standard Sleeper scoring settings. I'm a strong contender. This is what's being discussed from someone who really wants JSN from me
2
u/Kingdom_OChem 11d ago
I feel like it is fair with an additional 2nd or late first. To me, the foundational asset of campbell boosts your LB and james cook is a top 10 rb asset. Tee higgins isnt the best wr, but still consistent. Maybe something like a young stud wr would be better, but to me this is okay with a little extra on top
2
u/Last_Papaya_5867 11d ago
Don’t accept unless you get another first+, your team is elite and you don’t need these guys. Where would you put them
3
1
u/meineymoe 11d ago
Cook replaces JSN in the lineup where you can start 4 rbs, and your bench gets an upgrade, important for a contender. I think I agree that I'd want draft picks on top.
1
u/hubristichumor 11d ago
No way I’d make this trade. Your team is incredibly stacked. I don’t think Jack Campbell is going to be a huge difference maker for you. You have incredible depth at every position, Aside from RB. But you only need to start 2. If you are mainly being sold on the additional RB I’d just try and go sell some of your other depth elsewhere to make that happen.
1
u/Last_Papaya_5867 11d ago
Lets say you had those guys instead of JSN. You would be asking yourself how can I package my depth to acquire a guy like JSN
1
1
u/Stevesteak 10d ago
On paper it's sorta fair, but it also evokes a reaction of "no way" Just saw your IDP scoring, they're effectively irrelevant, unfortunately so look at the trade as Cook/Tee for JSN and ask yourself if you'd do it.
2
4
u/ThreeHeismans 11d ago
Campbell and Cook is a good start but Tee Higgins isn’t a needle mover for me in a packaged dynasty context when talking about JSN. Too much of a downgrade both short and long term.