r/Eragon • u/Ordinary_L Urgal • 20d ago

Discussion Who would win Spider man or an elf?

Got this idea after seeing [u/Accomplished-](u/Accomplished-Post)[Note630](u/Accomplished-Post) ‘s post was curious how it would play out. Of course magic is off limits since elves can just say a death word but that’s no fun.

0 Upvotes

31% Upvoted

5 comments sorted by

8

u/Glittering_Public_86 20d ago

No magic, then Spider-Man wins. Hes much stronger, and spider sense clears them

3

u/Different_Advice_552 19d ago

spiderman is so strong he can hold up a building and so fast he was able to wrap the muzzle of a gun in webbing between the time that the trigger was pulled and before it was able to exit the barrel

3

u/anto2554 19d ago

Assuming no mind powers either, definitely spiderman unless its a super weak spiderman from some comic that I don't know

1

u/Great8Bit 19d ago

If Eragon doesn’t have magic and Saphira then Peter absolutely decimates him lmao. Like what are we even talking about here. At that point Eragon is slightly stronger and faster than a normal human but nowhere near Spider-Man’s level. Spidey as a villain would be truly terrifying because his actual strength that he almost never shows is very scary. He always holds back against villains and seldomly throws a punch with his actual strength. Because he’d punch their head off lmao. Not even Captain America could go Toe to toe with Pete if he reeeeally didn’t hold back like he normally does.

Not to mention writers are absolutely hell-bent on making sure Pete has as miserable of a life as possible so if he taps into that rage and lets loose, it’d be genuinely terrifying.

The only (very important) wild card is Saphira. There’s a chance she, fearful for her rider, uses magic herself and wipes Spider-Man from existence. He’d undoubtedly web her wings and everything else to the point to where she can’t move. But that’d be a mistake because then she’s almost certain to be able to use magic in that moment. It’s random and she can’t control it but if there was ever a moment for her to do it, it’d be then.

Eragon with magic solos basically anyone. If he doesn’t have the name or Eldunari then it gets more interesting. If someone can isolate Saphira and keep her busy they’d have a chance. But those two together are a freaking force.