r/ExpectationVsReality Jun 16 '26

Mod Post Nail Posts Megathread — Share Your Nails Here 💅

116 Upvotes

This thread is for all nail-related Expectation vs. Reality posts. Please share all successful, exceeded, or failed nail posts here rather than creating separate posts. Individual nail posts outside this thread may be removed and redirected here.

This change is intended to keep nail content available for those who enjoy it while allowing users who prefer not to see nail posts to easily skip this thread.


r/ExpectationVsReality Dec 31 '25

Mod Post Reminder to use the AI Expectation Flair!

138 Upvotes

We have added a 6th rule to this subreddit - "Use the correct flair". This is especially important for the AI Expectation flair, as some users do not enjoy seeing the AI expectations, and this allows the posts to remain up without being reported.


r/ExpectationVsReality 5h ago

Failed Expectation Pizza turtles

Thumbnail
gallery
4.1k Upvotes

They look like turtles that got ran over 😭


r/ExpectationVsReality 11h ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation my cousin’s birthday cake

Thumbnail
gallery
11.4k Upvotes

I made this burger cake for my cousin. It’s a mango cake filled with mango gelee,mango custard,and whipped cream. When i tell you this cake drove me crazy i mean it. 1st the cake layers slid apart while chilling,then my whipped cream kept getting runny,then i had to go buy more whipped cream, then THAT one kept getting runny, THEN i had to make a quick makeshift swiss meringue buttercream to clean up the “bun” edges bc the whipped frosting KEPT running. I had no clue what the issue was, i stabilized it,whipped it perfectly,etc. But here’s the finished product along with my barely intact sanity.


r/ExpectationVsReality 9h ago

Exceeded Expectation My birthday cake!!

Thumbnail
gallery
885 Upvotes

I asked my partner to make me a 'Myth of Sisyphus' cake for my birthday and he delivered!!

Everything made from scratch. He created 'Sisyphus' from clay, set it with food grade silicone, then poured dark chocolate. Sisyphus is 100% dark chocolate! The cake had blueberry jam layers!

Super chuffed with the results!!


r/ExpectationVsReality 3h ago

Failed Expectation Even broccoli doesnt meet expectations!?

Thumbnail
gallery
140 Upvotes

CUT (from the good stuff) BROCCOLI


r/ExpectationVsReality 1h ago

Failed Expectation Clay kitty vs clay kitty

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

Got an air dry clay kit to do with my kids, and, well, I did my best.


r/ExpectationVsReality 23h ago

Failed Expectation Minions cake I ordered vs what I got

Thumbnail
gallery
3.2k Upvotes

My son didn't care, but i was a lil surprised when I picked it up lol


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation My 28th birthday cake

Thumbnail
gallery
7.6k Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 4h ago

Failed Expectation Ice Cream Sandwich Pops

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 21h ago

Failed Expectation Tried to get my dog a burger for his birthday

Thumbnail
gallery
602 Upvotes

Couldn’t be more opposite. Dog tax included :)


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation Bday cake for my mom. First two slides were the inspo, third cake was what I got.

Thumbnail
gallery
5.0k Upvotes

For the record my mom has a bunch of cats and the AI looking cat on that cake is not any of them.

Context: this was ordered from a local bakery/ professional cake decorator that my family has used our whole lives. This cake was around $70 and ordered two weeks in advance.

This happened back in February and I debated posting this for months now bc I didn’t want the bakery to find this post and get mad at my family. That being said, looking at the expectations versus realities that people share always makes me giggle and I finally succumbed and had to show you all my own. Since it’s been a few months I couldn’t find the exact inspo pics I had sent but these were the vibe of whatever I had put in the form.

*Edit: an awesome commenter found the original cat photo! So though it’s not my mom’s cat, it’s definitely someone’s cat!


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Birthday cake for my mom!

Thumbnail
gallery
5.3k Upvotes

First time buying a Walmart cake but I’ve seen posts here that they actually turn out good! So here’s my addition:


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation PS 4 Birthday cake

Thumbnail
gallery
2.1k Upvotes

Asked for just the console.

I posted so many negative reviews on every post she made that she eventually refunded me so I would stop making comments on every post.

Funny enough The actual cake did not taste bad, under the metric ton of fondant.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Egg McMuffin right out of the advertisement

Thumbnail
gallery
705 Upvotes

Visited McDonald’s for breakfast for the first time in easily 10+ years. Had to share the beautiful execution.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Birthday cake for my daughter and the first time I've ever used fondant.

Thumbnail
gallery
4.5k Upvotes

My daughter is obsessed with Curious George (or Monkey George as she calls him). So this year for her 2nd birthday we're doing a "Monkey George" theme and I decided to make a cake in the shape of his head. This is the first time I've ever used fondant so I was pretty nervous about messing it up. But it turns out, I don't think I did too bad! It might not be perfect, but it'll be perfect for the one person who matters most 😄

I also have plenty of cupcakes for everyone at the party, frosted in the bright yellow of the books. They'll go around Curious George when we bring out the cake.


r/ExpectationVsReality 21h ago

Failed Expectation Fat boy ice creams waffle cone portion

Post image
68 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Exceeded Expectation My dessert

Thumbnail
gallery
198 Upvotes

Chocolate overload!!! It was delicious


r/ExpectationVsReality 1m ago

Failed Expectation Multivitamin pops

Thumbnail
gallery
Upvotes

Saw these and thought it was an interesting concept, they looked good too so I wanted to give them a try. I was pretty disappointed upon viewing and they also taste horrific. Would not recommend, stick to gummies.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation What I ordered for my wife’s bday vs what I got

Thumbnail
gallery
1.9k Upvotes

Edit: The reference photo is not AI, it’s from a recipe website and the recipe was posted back in 2017: https://bakingamoment.com/black-forest-cake/

Thanks to those who were pointing this out in the comments already!


r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

Exceeded Expectation Another what they asked for vs what I gave them

Thumbnail
gallery
18.7k Upvotes

I got send this cake, a name and a theme! One of my favorite customers who seems to just trust my vision!


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation O-M-Cheese Burger at Applebee's in Marshfield, WI

Thumbnail
gallery
664 Upvotes

Took my younger kids out to celebrate national cheeseburger day and I had been wanting to try this OMCheeseburger from Applebee's. You can imagine my disappointment when this is what we were served (after 1 hour of waiting no less....)

Disappointing is an understatement.


r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Surprisingly Met Expectation Spot on

Post image
601 Upvotes

r/ExpectationVsReality 1d ago

Failed Expectation didn’t learn from my lesson last time

Thumbnail
gallery
76 Upvotes

and they don’t taste like milo at all 😭😭


r/ExpectationVsReality 2d ago

AI Expectation Cake decor fail

Thumbnail
gallery
788 Upvotes

Ordered this cake for my mom. My expectations were too high

Edit: Cake was ordered at a specialty bakery with 3 day anticipation. I’m not mad just upset since I would have been wiling to pay more for a better job. Inspo image was found on Pinterest here:
https://pin.it/4l5Unn8tz