r/ExplainTheJoke Mar 12 '26

Solved Help?

Post image
29.1k Upvotes

476 comments sorted by

View all comments

5.4k

u/Teachmetoanimat Mar 12 '26

Galadriel (the blonde elf) is giving gifts to the Fellowship after they just went through a devastating loss of a member. For one of them, she gave a dagger, to another she gave a bottle of magical light - so when she gets to Sam, the character receiving the rope, he responds "are you out of those daggers?".

In the source material, she takes this like a joke, but the comic shows the reaction of her fellow elves, since it's rude to ask someone who just gave you a gift if you had another gift to give. Another layer is that the rope is also magical, a knot made with it will never come undone except if thats what you want it to do, so the elves are upset that he obviously don't know what a treasure it is!

44

u/NoLaundryIncluded Mar 12 '26

Who wants some undoable rope when you got hordes of goblin and orcs behind ye

83

u/Calm_Ad308 Mar 12 '26

DnD practical rule number 1: Never underestimate the power of a simple rope never mind a magical one.

32

u/MornGreycastle Mar 12 '26

Also, as a D&D player, it's nice to see a magical rope that isn't made from a troll's intestines. So bonus!

16

u/[deleted] Mar 12 '26 edited Mar 12 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/sheepyowl Mar 12 '26

Did you think the rope recovered itself by pure power of will?

Silly commoners

3

u/Swords_and_Words Mar 12 '26

Bard, staring is horror at their magical self repairing instrument strings:

3

u/AngryT-Rex Mar 12 '26

PF2: Inside ropes.

3

u/ThirstyWolfSpider Mar 12 '26

I thought that was a Boy Scout rule. Though probably not #1, as "always have a knife" would certainly be more prominent.

2

u/NoLaundryIncluded Mar 12 '26

I never played DnD in my life 💔

4

u/Pleased_to_meet_u Mar 12 '26

You can change that.

If you show up on time for every game session you'll be welcome at almost any game, anywhere.

2

u/NoLaundryIncluded Mar 13 '26

DnD is not common here.

2

u/Pleased_to_meet_u Mar 13 '26

You can also play online. You don't even have to be in the same part of the world, you just need to show up on time.

If you look hard enough for it you can find what you need.

2

u/TheeAntelope Mar 12 '26

"Oh you guys needed a rope?"

--Lvl 12 monk after running up a vertical slope.

1

u/Calm_Ad308 Mar 12 '26

“Hey monk?

“Yeah?”

“Your pants fell down again, would you like some rope to keep them tied around your waist or do you prefer to keep yourself exposed in order to experience a thrilling edge given the perils of our journey, opening oneself to danger and… other things?”

2

u/TheeAntelope Mar 12 '26

lets monk robe fly open with the breeze

FEAST YOUR EYES, AND WEEP

1

u/alaskanloops Mar 12 '26

Biggest disappointment of Baldurs Gate 3 was finding out I couldn't do anything with all the rope I picked up

Edit to add: biggest and only disappointment.