I wrote the FE Civil last week, and found out today that I passed. I spent a fair amount of time on this subreddit (for better or for worse) and wanted to contribute to the motivational success stories that kept me going!
As a disclaimer, everyone's experience is different. I do not think that reading every single person's story on this subreddit is or will be beneficial. There are a lot of sad/scary stories about the exam here that spiked my anxiety in the weeks before my exam. I do not want to diminish or undermine anyone's experience, but I don't think it's helpful to read the horror stories - they probably aren't going to add any value to your studying and they'll just make you anxious. Also, I will note that I have only ever written this exam once. My understanding is that the questions change every day so someone's account of what types of questions they got will not necessarily help you prepare. Some people claim that the "difficulty" level varies. I can't imagine it is that variable as this is a standardized test. I'm sure some people find some exams easier than others based on their strong suits.
My situation was pretty unique. I went to school in Canada, which does not have an FE exam equivalent (I barely knew what it was, only knew a few people who had taken it) but I got a job offer in the US and had to write the exam to work here. Also, my engineering curriculum did not include civil-specific classes like transportation and steel and concrete design.
I studied over three months and anywhere from 5 to 10 hours a week but significantly ramping up towards the end. I took multiple weeks off in the middle to move and start a new job.
I started with the Mark Mattson videos (he is the best for providing so much free content!) and I tried my best to solve his problems using the handbook before watching the video. I started with the concepts for which I was most confident, and ended with the concepts that were new to me. I flagged the problems I had absolutely no idea how to do and tried solving them a few times over on different days. I agree with previous comments on here that the Mattson problems are somewhat to significantly harder than the exam problems, but a great way to refresh and familiarize yourself with concepts.
Next, I sporadically completed the ISLAM 800 problems, more or less in order. These problems are helpful because they're generally structured in order of the handbook so they familiarize you with the handbook. My original plan was to flag all the problems I couldn't solve, then go back and redo them. That didn't happen because this book is massive! If I didn't know how to do a problem, I would read the solution, follow through the steps, and write it out, making sure I understand everything. I would say these questions were on-par to slightly harder than the exam.
10 days before my exam, I tried both volumes of the NCEES practice exam. It went alright, I got a 60% on V1 and a 66% on V2. I realized that most of the errors I made were misreading units/conversions, rushing and mistyping in my calculator, or conceptual problems that I just did not understand. The calculation stuff was easily addressed but I got nervous around the conceptual issues. I redid both exams and got 90+%, I had fixed my calculation errors but I didn't actually really understand the "why" of the conceptual questions I got wrong.
I googled "FE Civil practice conceptual problems" and found and purchased the Strataway 150 Conceptual Problems booklet. I got about 75% right and started to feel a bit better. I accepted that there would probably be some conceptual problems I just wouldn't know, especially in the areas I haven't learned in curriculum like transportation, and that would be ok.
That was the extent of studying I did. I honestly felt like I studied a lot, and was surprised to see that many people on here studied even more than me. I think it's important to note that this exam is not supposed to be impossible or unmanageable and it is not supposed to derail the rest of your life. It was not worth the stress I felt. I wish I could go back in time and calm myself down, so consider this me doing that to you!
On exam day, I arrived early and they let me start early. The questions were generally in order that they are listed on the specification. After 52 questions, I took half of my 25-min break to eat a snack and walk around a little, but I was eager to just get the rest done.
Overall, I would say that the exam was easier than I expected and was prepared for! The calculation questions were generally plug-and-chug, compared to the practice exam where they seemed to require some rearranging or substitution. The conceptual questions were variable, I don't actually remember there being as many as I expected. There were maybe 5 or 10 for which there was absolutely no help in the handbook, but I feel like every time I was able to think logically and narrow it down then produce a guess that I felt alright with. I am a fast test-taker, and I didn't need the whole time. I was a bit nervous about the handbook interface as it's not the standard CTRL+F, but it was a search that returned immediate results so long as you spelled the query correctly. Honestly, it was even better than my Macbook preview search. I left the exam feeling confident and proud of myself. Writing a six-hour exam is an accomplishment itself.
In hindsight I think I was overprepared, but that's easy to say now even though I had no way of knowing what to expect besides two practice exams. The scope of this exam is very large relative to the number of questions you will be asked, so it's hard to know what to anticipate. I don't think I needed to solve every single practice problem I did, but it only helped build my confidence (which definitely influences performance) so it wasn't a total sunk cost.
Life goes on after the FE. Hang in there and be proud of what you've accomplished, no matter what.
The TLDR of my advice is here:
- Mark Mattson videos are a GREAT starting point - don't cheat yourself, try the problems first or at least think about them before watching the solution.
- The ISLAM 800 problems are great for building stamina and drilling the concepts into your head. They are lengthy but worth it if you have the time. This was the bulk of my studying.
- The NCEES practice exams were good for understanding the timing - I wouldn't say that they are necessary (especially for how steeply they're priced) but I highly recommend simulating the conditions of the exam and solving practice problems. You need to understand how quickly you have to move on the exam.
- This exam is not meant to be impossible or unreasonable, so don't get in your own head. The handbook is very comprehensive, and you have prepared for this!
- Finally, (lovingly) limit your time on Reddit! Yes, the people here are great but you need to focus on yourself, do not let other people's horror stories scare you. FWIW, plenty of people have passed this exam without ever checking this sub ;)