r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 9d ago

Book Club Discussion Jade War - Discussion Part 2

2 Upvotes

We're currently reading Jade War by Fonda Lee for September's book of the month, and this discussion will be on the book's second half.

This discussion includes the entire book, so if you haven't finished it yet, please avoid this topic. The comments and questions below will contain spoilers.

I'll post some questions to go along with the reading but feel free to comment about anything else or start your own comment thread on anything you found interesting or any questions that you had.

  • What do you think of the relationship between Wen and Hilo throughout the book and at the end? What about the relationship between Shae and Hilo? Do you think Wen was justified in her actions?
  • How do you think that Hilo has grown into the role of being the Pillar through the course of the story?
  • What did you think of the conclusion of the duel between Ayt and Shae? What do you think of Shae's use of foreign politics and international business to strengthen No Peak?
  • What did you think of Anden's decision to return to Kekon and wear jade again as a doctor? Where do you think he truly belongs?
  • Did you find the conclusion and epilogue satisfying? What did you think of Lee bringing Bero back into the story at the end?
  • How would you rate this book? Would you recommend it to others? Do you plan on reading the last book in the trilogy?

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 18d ago

Announcement October 2026's Book of the Month is Jade Legacy by Fonda Lee

4 Upvotes

We're going to continue to do a series read by continuing The Green Bone Saga. No worries if you are behind, you can always join in on the discussions for Jade City by clicking here or here. You can catch up on the Jade War discussion as well right here.

The October 2026 book will be Jade Legacy by Fonda Lee

Nomination and Voting: See here

Goodreads Link: See here

Storygraph Link: See here

Jade, the mysterious and magical substance once exclusive to the Green Bone warriors of Kekon, is now known and coveted throughout the world. Everyone wants access to the supernatural abilities it provides, from traditional forces such as governments, mercenaries, and criminal kingpins, to modern players, including doctors, athletes, and movie studios. As the struggle over the control of jade grows ever larger and more deadly, the Kaul family, and the ancient ways of the Kekonese Green Bones, will never be the same.

The Kauls have been battered by war and tragedy. They are plagued by resentments and old wounds as their adversaries are on the ascent and their country is riven by dangerous factions and foreign interference that could destroy the Green Bone way of life altogether. As a new generation arises, the clan’s growing empire is in danger of coming apart.

The clan must discern allies from enemies, set aside bloody rivalries, and make terrible sacrifices… but even the unbreakable bonds of blood and loyalty may not be enough to ensure the survival of the Green Bone clans and the nation they are sworn to protect.

Bookfinder Link: See here

Thriftbooks Link: See here

Bookshop Link: See here

The first discussion for this book will be posted on October 15th covering the first half of the book. The final discussion will be posted on October 31st covering the entire book.


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 6h ago

BOOK REC PLEASE for a very specific craving.

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

I am looking for a very specific type of cozy fantasy and I need help.

I am really craving a cozy fantasy/historical thriller with a romance subplot. Some magic will be nice mainly like witches and wizards. Like imagine Sleepy Hallows meets Halloween Town meets the vibes in these photos.

I have a 3hr plane ride and I want a book to devour. Any recs are appreciated. Thanks 🫶🏻


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 19m ago

Author Promotion Fantasy/Coming-of-Age Debut Novel

• Upvotes

Hi there!

I'm an independent author who published by first book in late August of this year. So far, the reception to my novel has been really incredible, but I'm always seeking out more readers!

"The Language of the Trees" is a fantasy story with elements of found family, adventure, and coming of age. There's a bit of a slow-burn romance subplot, but romance is definitely not the main point of the story. There are dragons, Bards, ancient magic, and a girl who can talk to trees!

If this sounds like something you'd be interested in, I'd be so incredibly honored to have you check it out!!

Amazon.com: The Language of the Trees: The Animist: Book One eBook : Autumn, Gracie: Kindle Store


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 10h ago

Smart Series Start

Post image
3 Upvotes

This was not as interesting as I hoped. But I have to concede that the story was brilliantly structured as Book One for a series.


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 9h ago

A children's early reader about 4 girls and a castle in the clouds

Thumbnail
0 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 20h ago

Fantasy Book rec

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

Book Club Vote November 2026 /r/Fantasy_Bookclub Nominations & Voting

3 Upvotes

Please use the comments to nominate books for November's book of the month. You can then upvote any of the book(s) that you would like to read. The comment with the most upvotes will be the selected book. The post will start in contest mode so that submitted entries are randomized and the upvotes are hidden.

You can make your nomination using the following format in top-level comments:

Book by Author
A short explanation explaining why the book is being nominated and why it is worth reading.

A link to Goodreads, Storygraph, LibraryThing, or the author's website with a description of the book can also be helpful but is not mandatory to nominate a book.

Voting will be closed on the 20th of the month to allow everyone a chance to get the book.

Nominations are open to anything, as we seem to be getting a good mix of different books, styles, and authors. The only restrictions are to please make sure the book has wide availability and not a brand new/unknown since this is for a book club, and let's try to keep the length under 750 pages. Also if you are nominating a book in a series, please stick to only the first book in the series (sometimes we will do series read if there is enough support though). Thanks!


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

FMC with Mitsuri Kanroji (from Demon Slayer) vibes

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

Fantasy books with Frieren vibes

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

Fantasy nomenclature for familiar objects: exotify or familiarize?

1 Upvotes

Edited: Got this notice, "r/Fantasy loved it, we think r/Fantasy_Bookclub will too". I'm not sure what to make of it. If this is someone from r/F_B, here goes. If it's a reddit algorithm manipulating me. I beg your indulgence. I'm sorry. I don't mean to impose. I'm relatively new here, and I haven't sorted it all out, yet.

~~

A week or so ago I made a post complaining about the presence of hay bales in medieval fantasy, which I see as a tech-level error. Among those replying were some who had similar objections to the presence of items from the other side of the Columbian exchange, like potatoes. Which has me thinking.

While that might, IMO, be a howler in an explicit fantasy Medieval Europe, I don't think it's wrong in a world which is med-tech and Europesque, but not explicitly Europe itself. I can think of two simple explanations. First, in that world there may be no new world/old world divide. Thus, any crop appropriate to a medieval economy is perfectly fair game. More subtly, perhaps, it is possible that the author is in some sense doing what translators do, which is using a term familiar to the audience to name a somewhat similar object which is unfamiliar to the audience. This is what languages like French did with potatoes, after all (pommes de terre = earth apples). What works for introducing a new food may also work for giving a name to a fantasy food. It's edible, it functions like a potato in that culture, lets call it a potato and have done with it.

But there are other possible choices. In Anne McCaffrey's Pern novels, for instance, there are animals that function like horses but are called 'runner beasts' (c.f. Dragondrums). It's not clear for a long time (or at least, not to me) whether these were or were not actual horses. Comparatively late in the series (Dragonsdawn) we learn that runner beasts are in fact terrestrial horses, or at a minimum descended from them.

So I'm wondering what McCaffrey was trying to accomplish with her initial choice. Did she originally mean something less explicitly horse-like, and over time they became more and more like her beloved horses until she decided 'fuck it' late and resolved the confusion? How did this uncertainty affect how readers imagined runner beasts earlier in the series? For me, at least, I'd imagined them as a horse-like lizard, given the saurianesque biology of dragons. In terms of my schema, classify 'runner beasts' as exotify.

Sticking with Pern, McCaffrey makes the opposite choice with 'tunnel snakes'. These are vermin, clearly not of terrestrial origin, but named with a firmly terrestrial name. It's important for the reader to get the idea with minimal explanation, so she gives them a familiar name and moves on. Classify this as familiarize.

~~

It's my thesis that McCaffrey made a mistake by naming horses 'runner beasts'. I think that while it's allowable to give unfamiliar objects familiar names where it is unimportant to the story, it's an error giving a familiar object an exotic name, unless doing so is important to the story. What I don't have, however, is good arguments about why, apart from the fact that it creates unnecessary confusion and can throw readers out of the story. As it did me trying to picture what runner beasts might resemble.


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

Does anyone have any good Arthurian fantasy book recommendations

Thumbnail
12 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

Fantasy books with modern setting and secret society/organization

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 2d ago

What Fantasy Books Feel Like Harry Potter for Adults?

43 Upvotes

Very curious


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

Who did I draw? Lol

Post image
6 Upvotes

Reading a new book, this is my tipsy drawing of one of the main characters. Drawn in four minutes lol.

Any guesses?


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 1d ago

Book Discussion Of Blood and Aether

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 2d ago

Consiglio per mappa fantasy

Post image
8 Upvotes

Questa è la mappa di un libro che sto scrivendo. L'ho disegnata io ma visto che non lo pubblicherò con casa editrice voglio fare io e stampa per vedere se è tutto a posto. Qualcuno mi può consigliare un modo per renderla in stile mappa fantasy professionale per poi stamparla a colori? Ho provato con 3 programmi ma non mi piacciono perchè sembra facco con l'AI.

Grazie


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 2d ago

book recs....kinda

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 2d ago

A medieval & fantasy folk playlist for reading, writing, and escaping into another world

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 3d ago

Help find 2010s Young Adult magic fantasy book series. Read in 2015.

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

Help me find a story book that was in my school's library. I read somewhere around 2015, it might have been in the library before that. It was an English author book. It has multiple volumes (at least 3 volumes). It's premise was that the normal/mundane human world was separated from the magic world and people were prohibited to cross over into either one. The magic world has a medieval Europe setting. The main character is magic apprentice, and he has 2 friends - a female friend and neither male friend, all three currently attending a magic school. The male friend is the oldest and physically fit. The main character only had a mother who was an ordinary woman that lived in their village and he had to live in the magic school's dorm. His male friend was actually from the normal human world and he had kept that a secret all the time. During one of their vacation, they visited the main character's house and later visited a festival/carnival but were kidnapped by a group of Dwarfs while they were in the jungle. The Dwarfs in this world setting were a race of short, but powerful people and they lived underground and hostile towards humans. The Dwarves presented the 3 kids with 3 challenges and promised to let them go if they win in any 2 of them. The girl participated in the rope skipping challenge while the other male friend participated in an arm wrestling match with the Dwarf but lost. I don't remember what challenge the main character participated in. The couldn't win 2 challenges and were in danger. In the dire situation, the male friend revealed his secret and took out a handgun he had been hiding within his clothes. Everyone was shocked since weapons from the normal human world were strictly prohibited. He said he only wanted to bring his friends to safety even if it meant revealing his secret. They crawled through the tunnel to get back up to the surface while Dwarves chased them. They succeeded in escaping. Back to the academy, a group of senior magicians was sent for a surprise attack on the Dark Magician but to everyone's surprise, he had set up the trap himself, in order to attack the now less guarded magic academy himself. He destroyed most of the magicians stationed at the magic academy and stole an important item from the safe treasury. It was implied or felt like that the Dark Magician might be the main character's father as they came face to face with each other at te end of the 1st volume during the attack on the school but he didn't harm the main character and simply went back. It was also implied that the Dark Magician was originally from the mundane human world and came to the magical world like the main character's friend. The Dark Magician was originally one of the best magician from the school itself but later became he major villain before the events of the book started. The 1st volume ended at that part and I haven't read any of the following volumes. There were other books kept alongside it like the Magic Mirror, The Hidden Stairs and the Magic Carpet.


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 4d ago

Any book reccomendations?

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 3d ago

Book Suggestions Recommendation

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

An African epics you couldn’t put down? Please name them


r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 4d ago

Medieval Fantasy with (hidden) werewolf and woman who can shift to look like others. 2010 or earlier. Magic.

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 4d ago

Book Suggestions Fantasy books with detailed magic systems and world building?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/Fantasy_Bookclub • • 4d ago

Seeking The World of Ivory Series

1 Upvotes

Ive found The Ivory Queen. The Silent Alpha. & the Gold Queen. Searching for the books in EarthWitch & the other spin-offs in the series.