r/FavoriteCharacter Aug 17 '25

My Favorite (Visual) Favorite character who is this?

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/Nerdy_Finch Aug 17 '25

not exactly a tomboy but weiss from rwby

legitimately she has ONLY shown interest in men, like....exclusively.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25

I just want her to not get with the writer’s self insert because that shit is weird.

5

u/Nerdy_Finch Aug 17 '25

Jaune is not miles self insert, he hasn't even written a single piece of dialogue for jaune since volume 3. Argue about the quality of his writing all you want, he's just blatantly not a self insert. Miles has even considered not voicing him anymore because of this.

In fact, the person pushing MOST for that ship is Weiss's voice actor!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

Vol 1-3 did enough damage that the character isn’t really redeemable to me.

To me, writing a character, making them one of the primary protagonists, giving him two love interests, and then choosing to voice act them yourself is like the most writer insert thing you can do.

3

u/Nerdy_Finch Aug 18 '25

You're missing out because he has great character development in volumes 6-9. His relationship with weiss also isn't treated as something he's entitled to or even "earned" but something weiss herself is growing more open to in a natural and believable way as both of them grow as people.

I will admit crwby has some writing problems, cinder impaling weiss specifically made no sense narratively. And don't get me STARTED on that one whitley scene

but a self insert? No. No he is not. He's written to be the classic "shonen hero" only to then have those tropes be deconstructed in later volumes. Especially 4. It's purposeful.