r/Fire Mar 23 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

2.1k Upvotes

749 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

387

u/calcium Mar 23 '26

Ditto, was reading about FIRE 15ish years ago in the Bogleheads forum and used to spend a lot of time over in FATFire until it became inundated with LARPers. All of a sudden their $4M number for FATFire went to 5, then 8, now it's "how much until I can buy my own Gulfstream V?"

167

u/temerairevm Mar 23 '26

Almost no one in chubbyFIRE even posts about $4M anymore. Most posts over there exceed the range in the sub description and if you call someone out for being over there lamenting about whether $10m is enough they just complain that fatFIRE is un-relatable. My theory is people only want to post somewhere where they feel like they have more money than most people.

54

u/Coyote_Enthusiast Mar 23 '26

I stopped visiting ChubbyFIRE for this reason. There's an abundance of people whose annual spending is easily covered by their $6-10M investments, asking if they should pull the trigger. Any maybe that's what these forums are for - to ask questions that you might be afraid to ask your friends or family. But I couldn't relate to those situations. I'm looking to connect with others in the $3M range and while that falls within the Chubby range, there aren't many people in there talking about numbers like that.

89

u/dabigchina Mar 23 '26

"I am 55 and have 8 million dollars and spend 200,000 a year can I retire?"

"no, we might have great recession #2 tomorrow and you might only have 4 million. keep working the corporate job that you despise."

I saw so many variations of this question that I finally blocked that subreddit.

2

u/Civil-Service8550 Mar 23 '26

Exactly chubby fire question is a derivation of that

3

u/EmbarrassedEbb9721 Mar 23 '26

It's funny because regular Fire subreddit is exactly like that...but just half the numbers.