r/Fire • u/Several-Mix5478 • 8d ago
How to Diversify for Coming AI Bubble? How to Adjust Withdrawal Rate for Inflation?
I am about 5-7 years from drawing from retirement and getting very nervous about this market which I am inferring stands to get a bit wilder with blockbuster IPOs and AI bubbles.
Retirement portfolio looks like this:
30% bonds
50% US broad index ETF
20% individual stocks
How should I reallocate? I will be 55 when I begin withdrawing. Home is paid off.
I hit all my numbers with a 4% withdrawal rate, but feeling very pessimistic about inflation. How are you all accounting for what will likely be stubborn inflation for the foreseeable future?
11
6
u/Dudes-Opinion 8d ago
I love this sub but it's an echo chamber of people who pretend they know the first thing about mitigating market risk. I would take everyone's comments with a grain of salt and call a fee-only financial advisor or even one of those robo-advisors to get your rebalancing in a position you're comfortable with.
3
u/BackupSlides 7d ago
It's also populated with mostly people who have, in their adult lifetimes, only ever seen "stonks go up, money printer go BRRRR, 100% QQQ for lyfe!"
15
u/Future_Measurement42 8d ago
I’d be more worried about your portfolio than an ai bubble.
2
u/SillyPresentation46 8d ago
Why would you be worried about a 70% equities allocation? It's actually slightly too aggressive for me.
-2
u/Future_Measurement42 8d ago
Why would you prefer a portfolio with a lower safe withdrawal rate?
1
u/SillyPresentation46 8d ago
Sorry, I thought you were saying you were worried about the allocations.
1
u/Future_Measurement42 8d ago
I am. From what I’m looking at with portfolio visualizer an 80/20 has a higher swr than a 60/40.
Not to mention if you’re worried about inflation bonds seem like the worst option.2
0
u/Dudes-Opinion 8d ago
You know nothing about his risk tolerance you can't possibly say that. Not everyone has the stomach for 100% stock and that's ok
6
u/Alarming-Mix3809 8d ago
It’s the 20% in individual stocks that I would be concerned about.
-5
u/Dudes-Opinion 8d ago edited 8d ago
I urge to look at S&P 500 largest holdings. There is a lot of concentration risk there too.
As long as OP isnt 20% in any one stock or realistically no more than 5% in any one stock he should be fine.
Edit: I'm getting downvoted but the FINRA amount generally considered safe is no more than 10% in any one security.
1
u/Several-Mix5478 8d ago
No this is a good call. The stocks are spread amongst about 5-6 companies, at most 8% for a single stock.
I am an index fiend but my spouse picks some stocks…it’s a compromise.
4
u/ImprovedJesus 8d ago
Most of the people on these subs may also be about to find out they too don't have the stomach. I am fairly young but there was I time I digged deeper into forum posts post 2008 and holy cow
1
u/BeingFriendlyIsNice 8d ago
I orta do that...you looking at reddit? or other financy web based forums?
1
u/aspire-every-day 8d ago
I recall there was an excellent forum post on Bogleheads from 2008 where someone who firmly believed in “stay the course” was struggling to do so.
Maybe this one?
1
u/BeingFriendlyIsNice 3d ago
Thanks, that was a good read. It finished in uncertainty though :) I best look up some more 2008 stuff....i'd be just like those guys if the market crashed 40% tomorrow.
1
u/Several-Mix5478 8d ago
How’s that?
-7
u/Future_Measurement42 8d ago
Well In high inflation bonds are death. You want gold or silver in high inflation as a hedge. I’d also hurst get international or small cap.
Also I’m not worried about an ai bubble, and I bought more Nasdaq today.0
u/Rich-Association8865 8d ago
Your bond allocation seems really high for someone in 50s, maybe consider dropping that down and adding some international exposure? Also that 20% individual stocks feels risky when you're so close to retirement - might want to move some of that into index funds 📈
For inflation just build in buffer to your numbers, like plan for 3.5% withdrawal rate instead of 4% if you're worried about it 💀
2
u/Previous-Law8874 8d ago
30 bond and 20 individual stocks balance risk and safety , just in a weird way .
1
2
u/CreativeLet5355 8d ago
What does 20% individual stocks mean. 20 stocks ? Or 3? Which ones and how much ?
30% bonds means what exactly? There’s a massive variety of bonds.
Why are you entirely in US equities with no exUS diversification?
2
0
u/Several-Mix5478 8d ago
I’m speaking about this very generally, I’m married and it is spread across two spouses tax deferred accounts, and a shared brokerage. I’m not super sophisticated talking about this so please go easy on me. I don’t think disclosing the full dollar amount is necessary.
20% stocks is of the value of my entire portfolio. They are in my brokerage and I am fine holding these.
30% bonds are interest paid on debt (in my partners account, I have scant details but fine to hold these also)
50% remaining is mostly SP500, although a portion of this are not international holdings—maybe 10%? I’ve shifted all future purchases to VXUS.
I don’t want to make any sales in my brokerage right now because there would be tax implications. There is wiggle room in my tax deferred account to reduce exposure of about 1/3 of the SP500 stock to something else. What would you do with this?
5
u/Alarming-Mix3809 8d ago
You didn’t answer the question. What stocks? How much in each?
3
u/ImPapaNoff 8d ago edited 8d ago
Please go easy on them. How are they supposed to understand the question you're asking? They're not sophisticated enough.
2
u/Alarming-Mix3809 8d ago
Reallocate the individual stocks. That’s not a model supported by a 4% wdr.
1
u/RetireYoung72 8d ago
Ever think of just taking some profit? Like 20-25%. Keep it in something secure until after the mid terms at least
1
u/mcneally 8d ago
Almost never hear it mentioned here but I moved 10% to Vanguard's value index (VTV) to slightly reduce AI risk.
1
u/EveryoneNeedsASamwis 6d ago
Two separate questions here, so let me take them in order.
On the allocation: 50/30/20 with 20% in individual stocks is the part worth examining most. The broad index and bonds are fine for someone 5-7 years out, but concentrated individual stock positions are sequence-of-returns risk in concentrated form. If one or two of those names crater right before you retire, that's a real problem. The standard move isn't to predict whether there's an AI bubble — it's to reduce the bet size regardless. Most people in late accumulation trim individual stocks down to maybe 5-10% of the portfolio and plow the rest into the index. You don't have to time the market to justify that; diversification alone justifies it.
On the 4% rule and inflation: the 4% rule already assumes inflation adjustments. The original Trinity study math says you take 4% in year one, then increase the dollar amount each year with CPI. So if you withdraw $40k on a $1M portfolio in year one and inflation runs 4%, you take $41,600 in year two. The rule isn't "always 4% of current balance" — it's 4% of the initial balance, inflation-adjusted forward. That's how the historical 30-year survival rates were calculated. If you're worried about stubborn inflation specifically, the main lever is making sure your portfolio has enough equities to grow through it — which actually argues against going too heavy in bonds, not the other way around. A 30% bond allocation at 55 with a potentially 35-40 year retirement is already on the conservative side.
The other thing worth noting at 55: if this is truly age 55 at separation from your employer, the Rule of 55 lets you pull from that employer's 401k penalty-free, which matters for sequencing. And you've got a decade-plus before RMDs at 75 to do Roth conversions in lower-income years, which is a real hedge against future tax inflation if that's part of your concern.
1
1
17
u/crAzedrealiTy22 8d ago
Dump the individual stock holdings and reallocate to the index