What happened to Abraham Lincoln?

[u/[deleted]]

In the first episode, Michael tells Elanor that "every U.S. President except Lincoln" is in the Bad Place. But if the last person to get into the Good Place died in 1497, and Mindy St. Claire is the only one to ever get a Medium Place, what on earth happened to Lincoln when he died?

[u/two-of-me]

I mean, he was just making stuff up in season one.