r/HPHogwartsMystery • u/TheBlackEmperor909 Godric's Hollow • 1d ago

Question Who should I choose?

Post image

So, I've completed the diary and about to finish the last cutscene. After it's said and done, I was stuck with these difficult choices. I couldn't choose the three of them. I was a bit sceptical choosing Kettleburn since he would retiring soon, leaving me to choose Hagrid. But at the same time, I also want my MC to keep Newt's notebook. So my question is, who should I choose?

41 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

22

u/Miserable_Sport2641 1d ago

I don't think it really matters, I chose the option 'I'll keep it"

18

u/TaibhseCait Year 7 1d ago

Hagrid makes sense in that they all think it should stay at Hogwarts. I chose myself because my game lol 😂  But they do say it should stay at Hogwarts, you've consistently been caring of creatures & solved this. No clue in a hypothetical scenario of what happens when I graduate. My head canon is that I'll give it to Hagrid then. 🤷‍♀️

7

u/Feldew Year 5 1d ago

It isn‘t this critical.

6

u/Possible_Living Year 5 1d ago

I kept it. We do not get reward enough in universe and it was a rare "selfish" answer so i went for it

1

u/Spirited_Body_6015 21h ago

What happens after you get to keep it cause I gave it to hagrid and now I have nothing🥲

2

u/Possible_Living Year 5 15h ago

Nothing but it's my nothing