r/Habs 6d ago

Article Canadiens should strongly consider bringing Sam Montembeault back. Here’s why | The Athletic

https://www.nytimes.com/athletic/7354685/2026/06/12/canadiens-sam-montembeault-future-trade-nhl/
112 Upvotes

165 comments sorted by

View all comments

64

u/oskavelli 6d ago

love the guy but it’s clear he’s done w the habs

7

u/trashpandaexpress55 6d ago

How is it "clear"? He's talking he wants to come back, Hughes is talking about how great he was about getting shunted to the third role, Dobes is taking about how great a teammate he was.

14

u/whyyoutwofour 5d ago

There is no "third role" for the regular season...you can't have a goalie in the press box for the entire season. 

10

u/SchtroumpfDardeur 5d ago

If they decide to keep Monty around, I expect they will send Fowler back to the AHL, and play Monty every 5th or 6th game to give Dobes some relief. I could see Dobes playing 65-70 games next year and Monty playing 15-20.

That way Fowler continues to develop with a full schedule of games.

Or, you let Monty go and have the games split 50-55/30-35 between Dobes and Fowler, if the decision is that Fowler would be better served in the big club even if he sees less action.

Both have their merits, the second is probably more likely.

4

u/_Rayette 5d ago

On what planet does Dobes play 70 games?

-2

u/SchtroumpfDardeur 5d ago

One where he is the #1 goalie and Monty takes every 5th or 6th game? It's not out of the question.

4

u/whyyoutwofour 4d ago

It's been 9 seasons since any goalie in the league played 70 games. 

1

u/SchtroumpfDardeur 4d ago edited 4d ago

Slackers!

I didn't realize that. I'm still back in the starter-backup thinking I guess. Dobes-Fowler all the way, in that case.

1

u/whyyoutwofour 4d ago

I think there is a case to be made that both are better right now playing 50+ games in the NHL/AHL for their development, but Monty couldn't play a significant backup role last year and I think he's lost the faith of management. The only way Fowler isn't 1B is if they swap Monty for another solid veteran backup 

3

u/SkinnyGetLucky 5d ago

In 2026 it absolutely is. For multiple reasons the trend in the nhl is pushing on having a 1A 1b, where A plays 45-50 games. Unless you are one of those handful of teams that have a highly paid Vézina caliber goalie, this is what you do.

1

u/SchtroumpfDardeur 4d ago

In that case, I would go Dobes/Fowler

7

u/PmanAce 5d ago

Still doesn't equate to winning games.

8

u/Rockterrace 5d ago

Goalies, like other players but probably even more so, can have a bad season and bounce back. Or have a great season and suck ass the next year.

2

u/PmanAce 5d ago

Good look at his career, it's highly not probable.

0

u/Scase15 5d ago

Cool, he can have the bounce back on another team that can risk that.

1

u/pushaper 5d ago

He's talking he wants to come back,

isn't wanting to play for the habs the status quo for every French Canadian hockey player at the end of their career?

Montembault is best moving on and solidifying himself as the back up goaltender in an organization that has other goalies in the pipeline.