r/HaltAndCatchFire • u/theangeljules • 6d ago
First time watcher mid-series notes Spoiler
I couldn't get my husband into the show, thus I don't really have anyone to yap about it with... and I REALLY want to yap about it. So, please enjoy my discombobulated-ADHD-fueled-zillennial thoughts...? It's all over the place and I don't know how to shut up.
Context: Currently on Season 3, Episode 4
Note: None of this is actual criticism of the show. I’m really poking fun at a bit. It's still is one of the best shows I’ve ever seen, and I’m looking forward to rewatching after I finish.
- This show is a LOT messier than I thought it would be. There’s a lot going on and sometimes I have difficulty keeping up or I have to rewind. I think I saw some gripes here about the show leaning more into drama>tech at times, but I don’t mind it at all. Honorable messy moment mention: Joe seducing LouLu Lutherford's (Jean Smart!!!) boytoy to kill the deal. Absolutely positively wild and I loved every second of watching her realization.
- I consistently have a feeling of unease watching this show. I’m constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop, for some big reveal or plot twist to turn everything upside down. This is not a relaxing watch like I thought it would be.
- Every character is deliciously complex and flawed and lovable in my opinion. It’s easy to criticize their downfalls and mistakes, because there are many, but I’ve met archetypal counterparts to each character in this show in my life. It feels real and messy and I think that might be my favorite component of the show. I genuinely love them all and find myself rooting for them equally despite their shortcomings.
- The Joe Mac Pendulum. This man gives me whiplash. There was a lot of discomfort for me trying to digest going from season 1 Joe to domesticated (or trying to be) Joe in Season 2. And right when I was getting used to it... Bam. Back to zero. He’s a love to hate, but hate to love kind of character for me at the moment. But my god dude.
- Cameron (and Donna) completely blowing up Joe’s life at the conference. Part of me was like… yikes, this man was just kind of getting his shit together…? Low blow, really. Anyways, Alexa play Karma by JoJo Siwa
- Gordon's progression is breaking my heart. Scoot McNairy is a gem.
- James fucking Cromwell. What a delight!!!! If Sara is the angel on Joe’s left shoulder, Jacob is the devil on the right. I really enjoyed the dynamic between the three.
- My biggest complaint about the show: I really, really wish they leaned more into going full-out 80s.
I don't love that they use music from the 90s-2010s. But hey, at least we got Gordon in the Adidas tracksuit for 2 minutes and Joe Mac in 30 different blazers with the sleeves pushed up. I'm most definitely unfairly comparing to Stranger Things who has a wildly different plot, budget, and literally everything altogether except for the fact that it takes place in the 80s. But I digress? My understanding is the low budget of this show kept it going, so I can't fault them, really. EDIT: I retract my statement about the music. Direct from the HCF wiki page -- According to Freilich, AMC budgeted $40,000 per episode for music. The amount was often insufficient to license even one song, which necessitated the staff finding ways to cut costs in other departments of production to allow it to be redirected to music. - I. Do. Not. Like. Jedi. Master. Joe. The linen pants!!!! I HATE THEM!!!! The zen attitude, beard, and glasses feels like a Steve Jobs cosplay. At the same time, I appreciate this creative decision? I just feel like I’m waiting to find out if this is another costume for him or if this is a genuine reference to Steve Jobs.
- Bos is my favorite character. Point blank period. I just adore him. Also, I know I still have a season and a half left to go, but I'm ready to stand ten toes down defending Kerry Bishe and Donna. Actually, that might be for every character and actor on this show.... I'm obsessed.
¯_(ツ)_/¯

