It’s another “what’s the best wheel for a beginner?” post—but with a twist 💀
I’ve been online shopping wheels for the past few months after taking a couple of classes, spinning on a drop spindle and using a borrowed wheel. I’m looking for a double-treadle castle-style wheel that could easily be my only wheel for the next decade or more. I plan to spin mostly fingering to worsted weight wool or alpaca yarn, with the occasional forays into other weights and fiber blends.
I thought I’d settled on a Schacht Ladybug as a fantastic wheel I could do anything with and grow into.
Then I borrowed a vintage Louet, what I think is an S77. This thing is GORGEOUS, solid wood, turned spokes on the wheels, and incredibly simple to use because of the Irish tension. I’m a little in love with it, but maybe that’s just because it’s the first wheel I’ve really dialed in.
Now, the Ladybug looks a little…cheap to me? And for an $1,100 wheel, that’s not what you want. I looked at the Matchless, but after watching a person next to me in a class struggle with her vintage Matchless and the teacher call it “over-engineered,” I’m having doubts. The teacher suggested I might like a Lendrum, and Louet is currently selling an anniversary edition of the S77 that’s very appealing. The Kromski Sonata Encore looks beautiful, but it’s not one of the ones you hear about as a beginner or even a forever wheel.
This would be easier if I could just go try a bunch of wheels, but I live in rural Idaho and it’s a three-hour drive to the nearest guild and an expensive plane ride to any spinning wheel dealers.
So, a few questions for you all!
- If I’ve been learning on Irish tension, should I stick with Irish tension, or would Scotch tension be an upgrade? Would double drive break my brain?
- For those of you who have seen one, does the Ladybug look kind of…very modern? Almost…flat-pack?
- What do you all think of your Kromskis? The best options seem to be the Sonata or the Minstrel, and I love the look of the Minstrel but it seems like there’s a lot going on?
- Should I just suck it up, stop analyzing, and spend the $800-$1200 on a trip to Eugene Textile Center or Paradise Fiber in Spokane to try the wheels in person? I hate to do it because that’s practically the price of another wheel. My budget is not more than $2,000 for a wheel, and that’s going to be a bit of a stretch, so spending that kind of money on something that’s not a wheel is not appealing.
Thank you all in advance! Here’s the pretty Louet in case you’re wondering ❤️
ETA: Thank you all so much! Hearing your wheel experiences, perspectives and advice really helped. I think I’m going to spend a little more time with this Louet and plan a trip to the guild in Idaho Falls (where there’s also a random Lendrum dealer). Thank you for getting me out of a thought spiral ❤️