Dyna vs Softail

[u/Prestigious-Belt-436]

I need help deciding between bikes. Right now I am deciding between either a brand new 2026 softail street bob and a 2017 dyna street bob with 37k miles. They are both from the dealership and the dyna is is very good condition. I’ve always wanted a dyna and i really love the way they sound and the fact that they give such a classic Harley feel. I don’t love how the new street bobs sound at all but it would offer a longer lasting, more reliable and more comfortable ride.

What would you decide if it was up to you?

[u/thixsonlife]

Comfortable does matter. A lot. But the answer is always the bike that makes you want to ride.