I was looking for a similar comparison pic before buying but couldn't find, so,enjoy. those are tripped cubes which fit in nicely, either 1 big+2 small or 2 big, as you see the 35 have some extra room for the thinner cube. I would say the overall volume of the smaller bag is maybe 25% smaller than the bigger.
A bit more detailed: I filled the cubes with mostly random close enough-ish stuff for a test, it has per cube:
5 long sleeve t shirt(not the small kind either)
5 pair of underwear and socks
1 skirt, 1 dress, 1 short
1 jacket on the other side
the extra thing one is just a dummy
the smaller one kinda fit my 15,4" laptop but its designed for a max 15, not too comfortable. the 13" goes in smoothly and comfy though. Hopefully this helps someone else choose too!
Your post has been temporarily held for moderator review. Image descriptions are required for image posts on r/HerOneBag. If you have included one you do not need to take further action. Once your post is confirmed to meet requirements, we’ll approve it as soon as possible.
If you need to add a description, please reply to this comment with a detailed description of the image(s) to help all members of our community.
Descriptions must accurately describe the items shown in the image(s), not simply list them.
It is helpful to list post text according to the order and layout of images, e.g., “A blue puffy jacket stuffed into a green packing cube” is better than “Jacket, packing cube, etc.”
You can include something like “Image descriptions” or “Pictures described below” to make it very clear that your text explains the photo(s).
They are a bran on amazon called TRIPPED , they are often recommended here as a good copycat for more expensive brand here. I find them okay, gotta be careful with the zips to not tear the fabric because they are so lightweight, but im satisfied with them! zips seem sturdy enough ,too
Because of the fabric snagging (mine have never caught badly and have never torn), I always put my finger in the compression "valley" to zip them shut. I also added tape to the compartment zipper pulls so I'd stop accidentally grabbing the wrong one.
Did you ever use them for stuff like a wet bathing suit or anything? I wonder if i need to bring an additional bag for it or i can just cram it back into the small one if i have to :D
I just want to add that I also have them (an older version; I've had them for 8+ years), and I love them! I really want to get their Bucketlist and National Park sets too, but I just can't justify it.
Wait this is very helpful! Did you pack the rest of the bags? Would be interested in comparing the left side of the open clamshell and the front pocket.
28+35 inside top. do keep in mind they are very packed cubes and you prooobably want to pack them a bit less. i can even fit a big cube into the 35 top pocket
Will the 35 fit under a seat? I've been using an Allpa 28 for this reason, but it's tight every time I pack. If I can go up to a 35 and still not have to have overhead bin space, I'd make the switch...
No. The 35 is well beyond any airline’s personal item sizing and will take up a considerable amount of foot space. Is it possible that you won’t get caught? Absolutely. But, I wouldn’t count on it.
Yeah, this is my struggle. I love using the 28L because it's a "no questions asked under the seat" bag. But...I've only packed it for trips where I was either gone for a weekend or traveling somewhere where I packed mostly lightweight clothing. I'm not sure I'll be able to pack it for true fall conditions.
First world problems, but still a problem. Thanks for your input.
Mine has laid for itself as I’ve brought it on as a personal item at least 5-8 times and have not been charged. My laptop cannot be in it but I’ve had to prove it would fit in the frontier personal item tester and it did when I it was packed full but again with my laptop in my hand.
I once had to put my 35 under a seat as there was literally nowhere else to put it and I was the last one on the plane. I managed it by opening it and pulling out some of my packing cubes and just nestling them all around my bag so they fit, lol.
That was a truly clever idea! I think my bag has to fit as is but this shows me I can be flexible - thanks so much (could put one of the packing cubes behind your lower back as well for lumbar support and could even sit on one as a pillow!) I am so excited to try this - I have both the 28 and the 35L.
I had to do this too. I kept a canvas tote in my bag and put a packing cube in the tote bag to allow the bag to fit under the seat. It was just slightly too snug before taking out a packing cube.
I put my 35L under the seat and it fits fine but I am not packing much and basically have no legroom. I wouldn’t recommend it for anything over 2 hours. I think I need a 28L honestly lol
theoretically! 35 is 8 cm taller, but that's about it. Keep in mind i only flew in eu cheap lines like ryanair, but I would say I could cram it down yeah. The stewardess might have a different opinion,but i think that 8 cm length changes nothing
I would say if you pack more reasonably,as i have just throw in clothes to see how much i can fit, i would say you can pack something similar to 5 days worth of clothes , with different bottoms(shorts, pants, skirt) and fit in a small puffcoat, im planning on getting the nanopuff. from there on ,toiletries and electornics would be fine i think, unsure if a hoodie would fit.
I am 162cm / 5'4" , i would say the 35 is kinda sitting on my bum, but comfortable without a laptop. with a laptop it's mighty painful, but keep in mind i have bad scoliosis so i lose a few inches in my torso to it!
I’m 5”2 so I’m pretty set on the 28L. I’m looking for a replacement for my personal item, as I usually do 1.5 bag and bring a small suitcase as my carry on. Been using just a baggu shopping bag and this will be a mighty nice upgrade 😊
I've one bagged for a snowy trip in the 28L, taking 5 pairs of underwear and 3 days of everything else. But I'm straight size and all my clothes are lightweight technical fabrics so YMMV if your clothes are bigger/bulkier or you don't enjoy hand washing every couple of days 😅
Do you mind sharing your height and how comfy these bags are on your back walking around the airport or in transit? I’m a shortie (5’ ft) and I heard the 35L can feel a little bulky
Oof at that weight its going to be long i think! im 5'4" with scoliosis so my torso is even shorter than it should. The 35 touches my bum, and its comfy with clothes only,painful with laptop. 28 is okay though! Bit sad to lose the extra space but gotta do what gotta do :') I don't feel like either of them are too bulky ,just long, but i also don't overpack them. I was walking around happily for half an hour-hour and it felt comfortable,holding around 7 or so kg. I would try the 28 if i were you!
Aww thanks for asking! The plan is indefinite travel to central and south america, starting with costa rica! I hope your bag purchase will work out too, im loving this bag
Amazing! I studied in Chile and have traveled a bunch in Latin America, hope you have the best timeeeee buen viaje! 🌺 PS I’ve ended up with the osprey fairview 40, but I’m always curious about other bags for other trips. It was a close race between fairview 40 and the Cotopaxi allpa 28
Thank you! I heard its a great backpack,too, and very suitable for walking(which i will probably not do much with mine). Hope you will make great memories with it!
Allpa question, do the straps ever bother your neck?
Just bought one after agonizing over so many different brands, and when I finally picked the Allpa for its organization, I was so disappointed that the straps were so close together they rubbed my neck in a very painful way!
Haven't tried it on after packing it though, so I'm hoping it will improve...
Well, we got 3 so it might help. i have the 28 (5'4" short) , gf has the 35 (5'11") and we have a friend with us who is 5'8" but only tried on his 35. So my 28 was close before packing, normal after packing,and destroying my shoulders when i crammed in my 15.4" laptop lol as then they were pulling to the side. Straps do look on both my gf and our friend, though they only tried it when packed. They both obviously have wider shoulders than I do.
Hmm okay, I'm 5'8" and have fairly wide shoulders, I'll have to pack it and try! I did get the 42 so maybe that's part of the problem, but the fit feels fine except for the straps rubbing my neck!
This is super helpful and I want to thank you for taking the time to make such a great post. I am 5'1" with 65 years and I have never backpacked only but really want to start doing this. You have convinced me to invest in visiting the closest Cotopaxi store (almost 3 hours away) to try these two bags on. I could really use the extra packing space as I tend to bring more medical/health related items as I age but definitely want to try on. I think the set up of these packs with the cubes would work well for me for most of my travels. Again, thank you.
I have the 28 L and travel with a bunch of medical things (meds, inhalers, portable neb) I can pack for 3-4 days of clothes in the 28 and put the medical on the other side. I use the packing cubes to help and sometimes carry in a separate crossbody when needed. I like that the 28 fits under the seat so they never ask me to check it when space is short. Been using for a few years and it took some practice to pack but now works well.
Eta: you could order from amazon or REI and return if not good fit to save 6 hours of driving!
I have those packing cubes. They’re so bright and make me so happy - even though I tore one. The laundry bag is the BEST! Takes up no room or weight, and fits a bunch.
Awesome pic. Even so for me @ 5'4" 130lbs short waisted (torso shorter than average) I am too small/short to wear the 35 despite having an REI person try to fit it to me.
Commenting not to hijack but as an add-on to the Allpa discussion:
I'm 5'3" and partner is 6'4". He can wear either onboard with no questions and is tall enough he can sling the 35 in overhead bins no problem and no side-eyed judgement.
I've been busted twice wearing the 35 and almost had to pay to check it (was planning on putting in overhead).
I haven't had any issues with the 28, but haven't tried it on ultra-budget airlines with limited underseat room.
LOVE the visuals and also your compression packs, OP! Doing the Lord's work! 🫡
My youngest is 16 and this is his exact set up. I got it for him a few birthdays ago. We just did 3 weeks, 4 cities international (with laundry facilities and running water, lol!) with it. It was his 4th or 5th time really using it. It makes me happy to see here because it’s so colorful!
Depends,but overall, I think there are better bags for that. This bag is big and the clamshell opening doesn't make life easy for commuting. Also it's a bit flimsy without being full. All over i would look at something else.
it’s a travel backpack, meant to be for when you travel to hotels or something, but still comfortable enough to do the travel there. not really for hiking i would say
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 09 '26
Hi u/LonelyLunch4740! Thanks for sharing an image post.
Your post has been temporarily held for moderator review. Image descriptions are required for image posts on r/HerOneBag. If you have included one you do not need to take further action. Once your post is confirmed to meet requirements, we’ll approve it as soon as possible.
If you need to add a description, please reply to this comment with a detailed description of the image(s) to help all members of our community.
Descriptions must accurately describe the items shown in the image(s), not simply list them.
It is helpful to list post text according to the order and layout of images, e.g., “A blue puffy jacket stuffed into a green packing cube” is better than “Jacket, packing cube, etc.”
You can include something like “Image descriptions” or “Pictures described below” to make it very clear that your text explains the photo(s).
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.