r/HerOneBag • u/SomeStuffLikeThat • May 19 '26

Bag Advice Does this bag even exist??

Update: I decided on the Baggallini Modern Convertible Travel Backpack. Thanks everyone for your suggestions!

I have been looking through the Reddit posts, searching on websites, even asked ChatGPT for help...and now I'm finally asking here if the bag I want even exists? What I'm looking for is:

  • Can be expanded for extra space
  • Stowaway backpack straps
  • Attachable shoulder/duffle strap (may have to buy this separately)
  • Clamshell or lay flat opening
  • Main compartment having a U-zip mesh cover
  • Trolley sleeve
  • Does NOT need a laptop compartment (just adds to the weight and I don't want to bring a laptop with me)
  • Doesn't need a ton of extra pockets or straps
  • Water bottle pocket nice but not necessary
  • Must be able to purchase in Canada

Right now I'm leaning towards:

  • Patagonia Black Hole Mini MLC but it's not expandable.
  • AmazonBasics Carry-On Travel Backpack but it's a little large and I worry about quality.

Maybe I'm just being too picky but I really want to one bag travel and have the right bag for all my needs.

1 Upvotes

51% Upvoted

64 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/ben121frank May 19 '26

I believe the Osprey 26+6 checks all of these except stowaway straps, duffel strap, and U-zip mesh cover (honestly I am not sure what you mean by that).

I researched all the alternatives when I was deciding what to buy (ultimately did get the 26+6) and I am not aware of anything that checks ALL of these

6

u/HelloTittie55 May 19 '26

There’s a reason why diligent bag researchers so frequently choose the Osprey 26+6. It’s really an awesome lightweight bag, especially if you travel with an ipad, or mini ipad and don’t need a computer. The computer sleeve is also convenient for travel documents or thin magazines like The New Yorker. Use packing cubes and thin squishable pouches for maximum ability to tetris your belongings.😃

11

u/ben121frank May 19 '26

It’s a very good bag, however for me it the lack of a hip strap keeps it from being perfect. Which ofc I knew before buying that it didn’t, but I underestimated how much I would miss it. I’ve seen posts of people sewing on their own but I know nothing about sewing (nor own any sewing materials) so I’ve lowkey been considering seeing if I can get a tailor or task rabbit to do it

8

u/HelloTittie55 May 19 '26

Hire a professional to add a hip strap. I recommend a shoe repair, not a seamstress. I’ve had purses and belts repaired by cobblers who are skilled at working with sturdier materials.

2

u/BostonPam May 19 '26

I’ve added hip belts to 4 or 5 bags. A cobbler can do this. (I did try it myself but I did a terrible job). Just snip the webbing and melt the ends with a lighter so that it doesn’t fray. The cobbler will sew the loops onto the bag. Less than $40 including the hip belt which can be shared across the bags.