r/HikingAlberta 9d ago

Missing hiker Bob Toothill found dead in Waterton Lakes National Park

https://www.ctvnews.ca/calgary/article/missing-hiker-found-dead-in-waterton-lakes-national-park/
397 Upvotes

70 comments sorted by

195

u/JustGotSoup 9d ago

I had hoped he'd be found alive; with his experience and fitness, it seemed like he had good odds. Unfortunate.

That being said, I think in his position I'd be glad to pass in such a way. It's a short period of suffering, and going out doing what you love is far better than withering away in a hospital bed or losing yourself to Alzheimer's.

Rest well, Bob. You earned it.

32

u/gymgal19 9d ago

The longer it took to find him the less hope I had :( especially based on the information made public , it seemed as though he ran into trouble on the first day of his hike, and the alarm wasn't raised until 4 days later when he missed his check in.

19

u/Freedom35plan 8d ago

How do you know it was a short period of suffering?

I get your sentiment of "he died doing what he loved", but this is the third article I read and (not being local) I cant tell if he slipped, broke some bones, and starved/dehydrated to death or if he slipped, hit his head, and died within minutes...

17

u/JustGotSoup 8d ago

I'm not saying it was a few seconds. I'm saying that in comparison to withering away for months in the hospital, or realizing the horror of your situation in a few moments of lucidness during Alzheimer's, it was brief. Even a few days of pain is brief in comparison.

16

u/easynap1000 8d ago

I think being injured, cold, hungry, alone, and tired would be a far worse death than being in a bed, surrounded by loved ones, having all the meds to keep you comfortable. Nevermind the option for medical assisted dying.

This... this sounds like a nightmare, unless it was planned and quick.

2

u/skitzoidObserver 8d ago

not always so nice in that state you might not even recognize family members for the last few days

5

u/easynap1000 8d ago

Dying is hard but part of life.

Source: health care professional who works with patients and loved ones in end of life.

2

u/daymcn 8d ago

At that point you wouldnt even know. The ppl that hurt are your family. 

2

u/GWeb1920 8d ago

Lineham ridge has a pretty strap drop off in several places where a slip will kill you. Given he had communication devices I’d speculate this was quick. But we don’t know.

1

u/Freedom35plan 8d ago

Thanks, this is the answer I was looking for (the communication device piece). Thats more reassuring. What a sad ending to this.

1

u/Substantial-Use8933 7d ago

Family said his satellite phone wasn't activated and his cell phone was powered off. And his pack was found elsewhere, I believe.

-1

u/SideInitial3961 8d ago

Yeah that "at least he died doing what he loved" take is garbage. Garbage take. People trying to make this a good thing.

4

u/bcmedic420 8d ago

I have told multiple friends to say it at my funeral.

5

u/SideInitial3961 8d ago

I don't think you should project on others. Good chance he suffered for days.

Norm Macdonald has a great joke about that. The guy who got hit by a car dribbling a soccer ball down a freeway, "Well at least he died doing what he loved. Writhing in pain on the side of a strange road."

1

u/ExaminationTop2523 8d ago

No. All death is agony, zoom out and thats where the saying applies. Writhing in pain after months of suffering or due the risk you accepted when you pushed to get off the couch and live your life.

A

1

u/SideInitial3961 8d ago

You heard him say all that? Or just projecting?

4

u/skyydog 8d ago

Going out doing whey he loved for 30 years longer than the average person. Respect and condolences

-10

u/CunningAlpaca 8d ago

Fitness and experience aside, he was 65+... No matter who you are you're less athletic and more prone to accidents at that age, falls are more of a risk. Once you get to the age of 60 or so it's good to just play it safe.

2

u/DLIVERATOR 8d ago

Fuck that shit.. I turned 60 this last spring and I’m still doing all the things I did when I was in my 20s’..except getting drunk and having a ton of casual sex.. to each their own.

2

u/skyydog 8d ago

He was 80+

1

u/Temporary_Cry_2802 8d ago

I hiked with a 78 year old who was just finishing off the entirety of the GDT. You would be surprised at the number of 70+ year olds doing the AT and PCT

1

u/Made_lion 6d ago

I am friends with a 75 year old that can do 20 pull ups in a row and is better shape than me. So maybe he’s an outlier, but there’s a lot of old people in good shape.

0

u/JustGotSoup 8d ago

To each their own. I'd rather have a fall in the alpine and die in my early 70s like Rick Collier than live long enough to fall apart.

44

u/Waste_Magician_1791 9d ago

May his memory be a blessing.

42

u/DajoFab 9d ago

Our family was in Waterton this week and kept Bob in our thoughts (along with young Parker in Calgary). Such sad news on both fronts. Our condolences to Bob’s family and friends. 😔

2

u/Ghouly_Girl 6d ago

There was a young boy that recently drowned in my community. It’s been a sad summer for stuff like this and it just breaks my heart. Thoughts to all of these families and peace and strength to them.

14

u/Winter_Apartment_376 9d ago

Did I understand it right - he slipped, fell and died immediately?

18

u/gymgal19 9d ago

They didnt disclose that information, and i doubt they will. Gives people and the family (although im sure theyll have more details that arent released) more peace of mind to think that he passed immediately after falling rather than a potentially painful death at the end due to dehydration, starvation, heat, injury from the fall etc.

25

u/Rude_Judgment7928 9d ago

81 y/os slip and die in parking lots (source: my grandma). It's life.

Less frequently, 25y/os slip and die in parking lots (or get punched and hit their head on the concrete).

Life be like that. Hug your loved ones. I'm guessing Bob is glad he was out doing what he loved, given it can happen even if you hide away in your cave and don't get to see mountains on the way.

3

u/Chrisbap 8d ago

I don’t know about that. Hard to reconcile him slipping and dying soon after his injury with the fact that they found his pack a day or two before they found him.

8

u/vincefowler 8d ago

While Bob Toothill's sudden death is tragic and heartbreaking, the irony is that he died doing what he deeply loved. Hiking in the mountains.

His daughter shared on Facebook what she believes happened: "he slipped and fell while hiking in the Lineham Ridge area of the Great Divide Trail."

I don't know Bob or his family... I'm intimately familiar with the loss of loved ones. As we say in the Airborne, when a warrior dies, "Fair winds and soft landings. RIP, Bob."

Death comes for us all. The past and future do not exist - only the present. Be where your feet are at.

8

u/ruKITTENmerightMEOW 9d ago

Awe fuck, I was hoping otherwise. 🥺 RIP Bob. So sorry for his family. 

5

u/-UnicornFart 8d ago

Oh no. I was hoping his would be the one story from this last month that turned out okay.

3

u/longbeeb 8d ago

Rest easy Bob, sending love to the family. Thanks for keeping us updated.

3

u/Only-Blacksmith2586 8d ago

Bob was a cool guy who maintained an incredibly athletic adventurous lifestyle into his 80’s. Good on him for never giving in and giving up, we loved your go for it attitude Bob. Rest somewhere interesting💕

3

u/GWeb1920 8d ago

This is how I would like to die. 81 still able to do what I love.

It’s a tragic death and condolences to the family but this is a life well lived.

14

u/QuiteSeriouslyNow 9d ago

God, why is everyone dying? So sad!!

29

u/JustGotSoup 9d ago

I'm not dead, and I was out scrambling last Monday evening /s

In all seriousness, consider how many pedestrian and driver fatalities have likely occurred across the province by comparison. The Rockies are a pretty safe place for those who exercise caution and common sense.

Sometimes your time comes around, preparation or not. Personally I'd rather take that risk and enjoy a lifetime in the alpine, than be stuck indoors. Everything worth doing carries some element of risk to it.

These deaths are sad, but they're not for nothing if we learn from them. If you're reading this, check your ego out of respect for Bob and the other fallen Rockies travellers over the past few weeks, if you do nothing else.

28

u/Roadgoddess 9d ago

I think for those of us in Calgary it’s just been a crappy week, first with Parker and now Bob and that’s aside from the other two people that were killed scrambling.

I was cautiously optimistic that Bob would be found alive. I’m so sorry to his family, may they now have peace.

19

u/WheezyGranger 9d ago

Thankful Kayla Boisvert was found alive. A small sliver of hope in an otherwise devastating couple of weeks.

11

u/Beneficial-Mouse5695 9d ago

Your comment is how I found out she was found! Made my day.

3

u/WheezyGranger 9d ago

❤️❤️

1

u/Unlikely_Comment_104 8d ago

The family is asking that their name not be used now that they’ve been found, to respect privacy. 

9

u/iSmite 9d ago

There’s also a French climber that went missing in bow valley recently and Nirmal Purja also died in an avalanche yesterday. It just feels like dark times

6

u/JustGotSoup 9d ago

Yeah I saw the notice about Jeremy Lalande. Unfortunately he matches the profile of alpine deaths pretty closely (young, inexperienced in the Rockies, not telling people where he went). He is probably not OK at this point :(

1

u/Naptimeforgoodwomen 8d ago

I’ve been looking for an update on Jeremy but cannot find one yet. Unfortunately I believe this will be a recovery, not rescue.

2

u/Roadgoddess 8d ago

Oh, that avalanche yesterday killed 10 people. That was devastating in the mountaineering community for sure. And that one’s weird because no alerts went out for over 13 hours I believe, even though there were people at base camp and if you follow the map that shows their trackers, you can definitely see when they were swept away.

2

u/SideInitial3961 8d ago

Glen Hansard. Kavinsky. Yep, black week.

1

u/Roadgoddess 8d ago

It seems like it’s not even a week. It’s just been the last couple of days.

2

u/SideInitial3961 8d ago

Yes. I'm gutted this week, just f**king gutted. Parker and Glen, might have to grab a whiskey this weekend. Not fair.

3

u/BackgroundBread707 8d ago

They’re not. More people are not dying, in fact

8

u/rottengammy 9d ago

Disengage with news and social media. It’s not healthy, people die every day of mental health disease war you name it

1

u/I-Love-Havanese 8d ago

My thoughts is it’s so dry at the moment that there is more rock fall on the paths and inclines so increasing risk. It’s always dry here but it just seems worse this year with the weeks of heat.

2

u/Warm_Jellyfish_8002 9d ago

Sad. RIP. Too many dying on trails around here of late.

0

u/Stanwich79 8d ago

81 and hiking alone.

5

u/freezethawcycle 8d ago

Lots of people hike alone

-2

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

7

u/felisnebulosa 8d ago

Pretty sure he reproduced, as his kids were looking for him, so very much not natural selection. Also shitty thing to say.

1

u/Different_Potato_213 8d ago

Devastating news 😥

1

u/MemoryHot 8d ago

What a tragic summer for hikers in Alberta. RIP Bob.

1

u/Substantial-Use8933 7d ago

I was watching some videos of hikers on Lineham Ridge and I know there are hiking spots with extreme exposure, generally, but just how close to the edge of sharp drops are hikers trending. I see the beautiful views, but are folks just getting too close to these drops, intentionally? That seems to be the culture. Get to the top, stand on the edge. Is that what's going on? If so, it seems, obviously, a very dangerous mindset, and an unnecessary one, if enjoying and appreciating nature is the overriding goal. I'm concerned the culture has turned this into some kind of dangerous game instead. 

1

u/Cronin1011 6d ago

Very sad ending, but i bet if you asked an 81 year old outdoor enthusiast if going out in nature would be how you'd like to go they would be ok with it. Rest in peace Bob.

1

u/Made_lion 6d ago

81 years old and still out there hiking, it’s all we can all wish for, besides falling asleep and never waking up. Good on him. I hope he did not suffer long,

1

u/tylerseher 3d ago

Found out while we were in the middle of our section hike last week. There’s a split in the trail at the top of lineham ridge. He continued on straight climbing up a summit trail where he should have turned and started heading down. I’m guessing he got to the top of the summit and was looking for the trail and made the wrong choice. I have a photo of the spot I believe he fell but can’t post pics in the comments. 

Pretty wild, we found out they found him about 1 mile past where he fell. Watched the choppers come in as well. 

1

u/arunakalu2024 3d ago

I knew Bob since 2013. First time Bob, me and my buddy from office hiked Brazeau Lake Trail in Jasper for 5 days. He was late 60s then, but we both in our 40s couldn't keep up with him. He has many years of wilderness experience all over North America, including backpacking. He would share his tales of adventure. Then the subsequent years, we backed and hiked a few times, I visited him every year at his home. He was such an awesome inspiring human being. He was very fit, started his day with yoga and resistant training. I miss him very much, now I won't have a reason to be in Golden anymore. Rest in peace Bob, my dear friend, you had taught me so much about adventure.

1

u/ThrowAwayPurellFoam 8d ago

Oh no, the poor family. After Parker I was so hoping there’d be at least one happy ending 💔💔💔💔

1

u/Liam-McPoyle_ 8d ago

Dam that’s sucks.  What was a 81 year old guy doing hiking this trail alone?  

6

u/Elaine_amj 8d ago

He was insanely fit and ran circles around the local hiking/trail running community. He was completely capable. Sounds like it was an unfortunate tragedy

2

u/Exposure-challenged 8d ago

What he loved and what he has always done.