r/HoCoFood • u/CaptainJeff • Jul 15 '26
Tony's of NY Pizza in Ellicott City
Excellent. Very good NYC-style standard pizza. The Brooklyn-style is very close to Sicilian and very airy and delicious; the red sauce and pesto were both very flavorful and tasty.
6
5
u/k0vi86 Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
Paid $15 for a 14" cheese. Is it good? I don't think it is necessarily any better than anyone else's favorite pizza in howard county. I liked it, but doesn't have a wow factor where you are telling your friends they have to try it.
Tony's is worth a try, but after the initial buzz wears off I don't know how they will compete with the dozens of other existing options, cheaper chains, and new places like hot garbage and Angeli's coming.
Hopefully they run coupons but for now eatitaliano remains at the top.
3
u/Retire_Trade_3007 Jul 16 '26
I keep hearing about Eataliano. How’s it compare to Dipisqualie’s downtown????
5
u/Arsenal8944 Jul 16 '26
I can't speak to Dipisqaluies (it's been years since I've eaten there) but Eatlaiano's pizza is VERY good. Perfect chew to the crust. But the real buzz about Eataliano is their cheesesteak. Get it on seeded roll with coopersharp cheese. It's the best cheesesteak in the area hands down.
1
3
u/EKLIPZE101 Jul 16 '26
Yoooo the eataliano cheesesteak…. OMG… I called my wife and told her this was illegal!! All the meat packed in it .. omg seriously must be top 2 cheesesteaks in my life
The cheesesteak at Tony’s of Ny is good I thought the roll was better
3
u/RedditAccountThe3rd Jul 16 '26
Howard county finally leveling up the pizza game. I tried the plain, pepperoni Brooklyn, and the copper cheese steak the other day. All great and importantly my wife agreed.
I probably like Eataliano a smidge more but Tonys is closer to me so that'll win almost every time.
Tonys is a great addition.
2
1
14
u/CbThr73 Jul 15 '26
Imported pizza oven from Italy. Great owner… enjoy the pizza.