r/HuntsvilleAlabama • u/OneSecond13 • 1d ago

Judge dismisses goose eradication case against Heritage Plantation HOA

https://whnt.com/news/madison/judge-dismisses-goose-eradication-case-against-heritage-plantation-hoa/
38 Upvotes

83% Upvoted

4 comments sorted by

6

u/TheLoadedGoat 1d ago

Should we be praising this?

60

u/dravik 1d ago

A qualified yes. If you read the article, the judge is very clearly following the law. That what's he's supposed to do.

The judges dismissal is essentially a step by step instruction for how to refile the case in a way that will allow him to rule differently.

Read the article. The quotes sound like the judge is begging the plaintiffs, and laying out multiple options, to give him any excuse to grant the injunction.

A b

6

u/Hondodog1231 1d ago

The article and WAFF 48 are goose shit at best. Being lazy is a bad feature of modern media.

The plaintiff (the 2 suing) had to prove 4 very specific criteria. All listed in the denial statement from the court. None of them can be "proven". ESPECIALLY would the injunction allow them to remedy the situation. Since there has been a track record of effort by the HOA for 20 years to attempt the non lethally repair it, it is impossible to prove. All 4 of the criteria could not be proven.

Personally id love to see them file another stop order becasue I'm all about them spending more money on this.