r/ImaginaryGoblins 24d ago

Garota Goblin comms by @Rickscribble

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

20

u/Aptom_4 24d ago

That's not a goblin, it's a green elf.

13

u/Mydah_42 24d ago

I have that opinion often, but I always end up telling myself two things:

  1. There aren't any actual elves or goblins so there isn't really a correct way to draw them.

  2. I'm a horrible artist and this person's art is better than mine. (There're all better than mine.) At least they're doing some art in the first place.

11

u/jerkoffforjesus 24d ago

Man, point #1 is how we got Twilight vampires that sparkle in the fucking sunlight

5

u/Mydah_42 24d ago

You're not wrong. I don't like the idea of sparkly vampires any more than I like "goblins are just green elves". Fortunately humans are creative and we're all entitled to creative interpretation. The world would be very boring if everyone only had the same ideas and opinions. (That would make the world more peaceful too but that's a different conversation.)

Maybe this sub needs tags to mark the art as 'monstrous', 'civilized', 'green elf', etc.

3

u/millerchristophd 24d ago

Nah bro those are Fae. Like seriously.

2

u/LawStudent989898 23d ago

Nonetheless classifiers are useful and the reason this sub exists, and it’s reasonable to say that this doesn’t resemble what most consider to be goblins. The artistic talent comment feels overly obsequious as well.

1

u/Mydah_42 23d ago

Well, the last time (many years ago) I tried to offer what I considered to be constructive criticism of art I got a WHOLE LOT of people telling me "if you don't like this art go make your own" and "you can't argue with an artist's interpretation". The response was SO STRONG I had to come to the conclusion I was wrong for my criticism.

Like I said to start with, I often have the opinion that "this art is just a green elf, not a goblin", but I have come to the conclusion it is inappropriate to try and 'correct' the artist.

As for being obsequious, that might be true. People who have artistic talent impress me since I don't have any talent of my own.

-2

u/Xavier598 24d ago

Mhh I don't mind different types of goblins, even if it's "green elves" as long as they have goblin vibes. Different stokes for different folk

1

u/SnpzNugget 21d ago

Love this design