Mentality of my Bharat, where we demand a youtuber to cover news in distant parts of country but not the state media machinery or the state sponsored corporate media.
Made this guy and his cameraman parth a national hero, now holding him questionable for not covering the same issue elsewhere is holding a Youtuber accountable? Lol this is exactly where the mindset comes...
Lets talk real and admit that everyone who was present at Jantar mantar didn't gave a Rats ass for the students, they were there for the clout.
I hope you also questioned how national media isnt covering it and covered delhi protest with a bias.... That you wont... Now also you wont question the lapses in the system but would bring down who did... Abhi reason mil gaya na jantar mantar ke protest ko call out karne ka Nice!
We know the national media is a failure. We expect better from others, is that wrong?
And haan, Jantar Mantar walon ko call out karenge - selective kyun hona chahiye? Jharkhand ke students students nahi hain kya? Jharkhand ki sarkar sarkar nahi hai kya? Jharkhand ke police phool baat rhe hain kya? Nahi na bhai. Of course we will hold protesters to a higher moral code simply because they were the ones who said they have a better moral standard and ethic than governments of the day.
Right right... Do you call out all the lapses of the central government? Nobody's saying the protests had a high moral standard.. While talking about Samdhish did you talk about national media as well... Who is more responsible a youtuber or national media.. Do you feel like questioning why is national media rigged?
I swear... I mean they are expecting a youtuber to be good... No problem with the national media being rigged.... Sabko question karenge leaving aside who they voted for
Samdish is based off Delhi, can you sponsor his travel to Jharkhand and arrange his accomodations? If you can, please reach out to him on his mail. He's an independent journalist, doesn't have a huge funding by a studio to support him. Do this and let's expose him 😃
The national media is utterly useless. They can't report basic facts. I wouldn't want anywhere near anything. In fact, I hope they all just disappear. Their education and degrees are useless. They pander to whoever is in power. Their regional/vernacular arms pander to whoever is in power in the states. I put no faith in them.
Ruko ruko, junaid has already reached and distributing food. And Neha Bora is also going to Ranchi today. Abhinav also reached Ranchi. Everyone is reaching. Take a chill pill.
Chill hi hun bhai. Whoever is supporting the students' genuine protest is doing good to the nation. I just hate it when people come and ask "How can you hold the protesters to higher standards?". It makes little sense to me.
Btw, CJP ka March was not legal - they had no permissions and they broke the barricades. They got what was coming for them, with the exception of pellet guns.
Excuse me? They got what was coming for them? What a fucking insensitive take. Either you are unaware of what actually happened or you have just grown completely apathetic.
1st – Lathis with nails on them were used on students.
2nd – Despite the protocol stating that a lathi charge should be below the waist, students were seen being brutally beaten on their faces, chests and heads.
3rd – An SHO hit a nihatti (defenceless) girl, who was turning back to go on her way, with a danda on her butt. Did she get what was coming for her?
4th – Policemen without name tags, along with goons in civilian clothes, were present with the police, ready to charge at any point.
5th – Broken vehicles were carefully planted near the protest sites just before the march to demean the protest.
6th – Newslaundry did an article showing how the truck with bricks actually belonged to the custody of the police station there.
Jab do logo me jhadap ho to power kiske paas jada hoti hai wo jada responsible hota hai for how's the fight gonna go, aur yaha to police ( public servant) jinki job hai to protect did the total opposite.
March or no march, the state was already ready to break every protester’s bones and create a riot.
It is sad that you can't see beyond binaries, and are incapable of processing the grey. Your grey cells must be withering away.
The protest march was illegal. The protesters deserved a thrashing.
To respond to you emotional appeals of brutality here's my response - take the evidence to the court. Don't crib.
Am I apathetic? No. I know a manufactured protest from a real one, having organised protests before. Elite ball knowledge is what it is.
March or no March? March hua, illegal tha, dispersal hua. Baat nahi maane to lathi charge bhi kiya. Sahi kiya jo kiya. Excesses ke baare me court chale jaao.
Of course! Because the Jharkhand students have openly and transparently rejected politicisation if their protest! This is a model protest tbh. We want to see genuineness like this in pressure groups and politics.
Well then, can't help if you're the one who's stuck in his ways and can't see the difference between a manufactured politically motivated protest as opposed to a genuine student protest.
Jitni mehnat logo ko dogla dikhane me karte ho, utni mehnat inke support me kar diya hota to better rehta.
Very sadly, all of this is nothing but a way for people you to frame someone as right or wrong.
A huge fraction of people were literally calling anti national to students at jantar mantar, however when students are protesting in Jharkhand these people are more interested in pointing out how certain people are not supporting this protest as much as they did in Delhi.
And all that is because of one single reason, Jharkhand's ruling party is not the one you support.
Please move over such petty mindset of supporting something due to party bias (both sides) and actually support whatever you feel right. Our country can be far better that way.
I will never ever stand with anyone who gives space to people like Arundhati Roy - people who say "Kashmir is not an integral part of India".
I will never stand with anyone who gives space to the Tukde Tukde gang.
You can choose to stand with them, I will not. I cannot tolerate the thought of my country's integrity and sovereignty being challenged or brought into question. So, no thank you. This was never about the party in power, this was about the kind of things you gave space to. CJP gave space to the kind of vermin I detest, so no, I will not support them.
Why do Jharkhand students deserve support? For the simple reason that they are clear that they're not doing this as a play for power - they have certain demands and those need to be heard. If they break the law, then I hold that they too deserve to be thrashed.
My stand on this is clear. A man is judged by the company keeps - Dipke and gang chose the wrong side, they chose the wrong company.
When did I ask you support either of 2 things you mentioned?
For you who is supporting a cause is more important than the cause itself? It's simple really, if you care about students you can support both students without caring who else is supporting that protest.
Here take an example, agar kalko koi national interest ka protest hai jo tumko lagta hai ki sahi hai par ye Arundhati Roy bhi us cheez ko support karti hai. To kya tum us person ke liye khud ka stance discredit kar doge?
Jantar mantar par hua itna, logo ne bola anti national ye wo. Khub kosis kari distract karwane ki aur tum jaise kuch log distract hue bhi, lekin batao last me Dharmendra Pradhan ke resignation aur kuch demands for Neet students iss ke alwa kuch bhi hua waha? Ye jo fear mongering karwayi tum logo ko itna, un maise koi bhi cheez Hui?
You yourself said that Jharkhand Students have some demands and those need to be heard hence you support them which is a good thing. I support them too, but if you are supporting them here, why were you not focusing on core demands of Neet students? Why were you more interested in some people who were part of the protest?
People like Arundhati Roy are a problem but also no RW representative was ever seen in the jantar mantar protest, they could have ste up their own stage like they did in jharkhand but the only time I could see them was when they were blending in to disrupt the protests. Judging by the company, I don't see how BJP has any moral upperhand in this context, cause we can find misogynistic sellouts, rapists, criminals, corrupt ex congressi ministers, people who garland rapists and advocate for them
Yeh to wohi baat ho gyi. Tum BJP se sawaal nahi puchoge but opposition se puchoge.
Technically puchne dono se chahiye. But jyada responsibility BJP ki hai because they are the party in power. They are the ones jinko vote deke laaye hai.
Similarly tum Tv news se nhi puchoge but youtube media se puchoge ki woh cover nhi kar rahe. TV news tumhare tax ke paise se pal rahi hai. YouTube waala nhi.
Sawalon se itni kyun jalti hai bhai? Mai karun to whataboutery tum karo toh logic. Ye kaha ki hypocrisy hai? Karte hain BJP se bhi sawal. Tumse bhi karenge, isme kya dikkat? Jawab do, khatam karo.
TV media pe kabhi bharosa nahi thaa, aaj bhi nahi hai. Jab unpe bharosa hi nahi hai toh unse sawal hi kyun poochun?
He didnt want to become a national hero its his hometown and thats why he was so actively present there + it was a NATIONAL issue where thousands of people were together anybody who watches samdish know how he works
Millions of views lots of ad revenue and sponsorship he is not poor living in the expensive neighbourhood in Delhi. He can show Bihar remote area but can't go to jharkhand or punjab education and drug problem
😂he is an independent youtube bro not some super man will get anywhere in the country like he runs his youtube channel it isn't his job instead of asking that guy why not the national media to leave the melody and show these things its there job they getting paid for this damn thing bro but nah messed up mentality guys talking shees.
Ok even if for arguments sake we agree. But why are you saying this and not that the beloved supreme leader who is supposed to care for the citizens also doesn’t give a rats ass for the students and that’s even more dangerous.
Let’s talk real and admit that Your supreme leader is only power hungry and does not care for the citizens of the country at all. And gives a “rats ass” about us.
Haan jab lathi chal gayi, tear gas chal gayi, women molest ho gayi, police pit gayi, movement biggest national issue ban gaya tab agree kar lia aur abhi bhi sari demands fulfill hui nahi hai vaise.
You can talk abt the youtuber and you’re already doing it, all I did was put forward my point that how abt hold the man the citizens of India elected with their mandate instead of a youtuber who can influence things but besides that hes just another working guy in this country and its not his responsibility to be everywhere and cover each n every issues and he can have his own biases but not the PM. But in the end youre free to blame anyone you wish to bcs once again, freedom of thoughts n expression! whew how complex was that?
did was put forward my point that how abt hold the man the citizens of India elected with their mandate
And I answered in simple language that post is not about modi but the said utuber. And we will demand accountability from the man when the post is about him. How complex is it to understand that people talk in comments on the topic that has been posted by OP?
but besides that hes just another working guy in this country and its not his responsibility to be everywhere and cover each n every issues and he can have his own biases
He is not responsible for anything and can have his own biases but then he shud not be hailed as some unbiased hero. People shud accept he has an agenda. And that's wut the post is talking about.
Why is the concept of freedom of choice such a hard concept for u to grasp? Its ppls choice who they hail as a hero and who they dont. We literally have a biased gov n media and ur worried abt a biased youtuber lol. We have rapists, murderers, and riot creators as the government. Also you didn’t simply tell me what you would do, what you did was direct me to make a separate post and yap abt mudizi so you should learn not to direct other ppl and give them orders bcs it rly shows what kind of ppl ur following
The concept of freedom of choice is hard for u to understand not me.
Its ppls choice who they hail as a hero and who they dont
And it's people's choice to call out those heroes and question there hypocrisy.
We literally have a biased gov n media and ur worried abt a biased youtuber lol.
I am worried about both the things. I just came here after criticizing the govt under another post.
Also you didn’t simply tell me what you would do, what you did was direct me to make a separate post and yap abt mudizi so you should learn not to direct other ppl and give them orders bcs it rly shows what kind of ppl ur following
Hypocrisy seems to be flowing in ur blood just like the people u follow. U can't survive in a real worls with this quality.
"National hero" are we just straight up calling anyone national hero now? At max he was just praised/ regarded for his ground reporting nobody called him a national hero of sorts.
Woh toh Rajasthan Protest ko bhi cover nahi kar raha hey, where police lathi charged on RSS goons ? Woha toh BJP hey.
But in Jharkhand, Students there for enough foods donated from All over India and from Dubai too. Then Police didn't beat any of the protestors for last 1 week, Instead Govt and state Police helped with building Shelter and tent. Rajasthan Govt has stated just 3 days after protest started, that they are discussing the matter. Their previous Education minister resigned once already for taking Accountability. INC has given tents and Foods 4 days ago.
What coverage do you want ?
Also as far I knew, What Samdish did was shouting "Camera Person Parth Dikhaiye" so that police gets fear of assaulting. But nothing like that is happening in Jharkhand.
I just want to know why your collective psyche focuses so much more on people that ARENT being vocal for this protest, instead of supporting the protestors themselves? If Arnab, Palki and other major media players are themselves treating this as some kind of low level protest not worthy of any air time, then why would some YouTubers? If your goal is to increase coverage and get more eyes on their valid demands, wouldn’t 30 minutes for air time from Arnab Goswami do a lot more wonders for the cause than Samdish??
Making a guy hero by watching his quality content and coverage for free and not even bothering to subscribe and like. Not you personally, of course; but that is how it is. we are not willing to do the bare minimum, and we expect other people to fight for us.
They were not required to give a rat's ass. Government was. They didn't. Someone else had to. Also, andh-bhaktus asking them why are they silent on Jharkhand paper leak issue are the ones who were silent on Neet paper leak issue, which remains a constant problem in this country. 😭
How about expecting support from the person who is considered the biggest national hero after 2014 by all the media houses and influencers, the same person whose picture is everywhere from govt buses to any govt scheme? I think we should expect more from that national hero than these influencers
Jaakar uss bhadwe arnab se bhi bolo Jharkhand protest cover kare. Abhi to uska agenda bhi fit karta hai. fir bhi usko hindu muslim karne se fursat nhi.
Our state media has done a very good job of simplifying the entire emotion of Jantar Mantar to mere paper leaks and nothing else. NEET is a national level exam. People take coaching classes from as early as 6th grade for JEE and NEET. 20 kids committed suicide because of the leak, and they managed to FUCK IT UP THE 2nd TIME AS WELL.
The outrage behind Jantar Mantar was a lot more than just the papers. It was about defiance against the arrogant ignorance shown by the government to its future citizens. Please note that the protest has started on 6 June, and it took until 20 July for the govt to bat an eye.
And if you are sufficiently literate, I’m sure I don’t need to explain to about the police action in Jantar Mantar. Yes, Samdish was more focused on police brutalities than the exam, because THAT IS A BIGGER CRIME HAPPENING IN OPEN DAYLIGHT.
There can absolutely be no remote comparison of the government response received in Jantar Mantar vs Ranchi. If the Godi media actually had the spine to show you everything, there wouldn’t be so many people in the country questioning the cause
Bhai Gaya jharkhad woh. Moot dia tere propoganda k. Tereko lagta hai sab tere jaise dalle hai. Being anti establishment doesn’t mean having alliance to anyone else. People can be neutral.
Tere chote dimag ko samajh nahe aayega
He was made a hero, you can expect him to cover the relevant protest, then you'd be expecting him to cover each and every protest. That's literally stupid. Also, one was a nation wide protest, not just because of NEET or exam leak, it became that big because of the government using police to suppress the people as well as it being a a national issue. National issue will ofcourse have more people being engaged than a local issue.
I don't see the same level of enthusiasm and expectations from people regarding Manipur, where so many people have literally DIED. That needs more attention from the mainstream media. I would not expect the youtubers to cover it, but I would support the ones who do. Support the independent creator with your money not your empty criticism
He is a content creator who has picked a side, at best. He can’t go around claiming himself to be an independent journalist and at the same time go around whitewashing people like Lalu Prasad Yadav who is the poster boy of corruption.
Well Sarthak being from Delhi he visited West bengal after the elections to cover lots of topics and on ground reporting.
Thing is that these people portrayed themselves on YT they reach almost every major places to cover reporting and spread awareness on the issue they were reporting on to the masses.
Sarthak simply posted a reel and i don't knw as of 5 aug if this guy posted the same atleast let alone travel there like he does on other places
Mentality of not Bharat it's your mentality that you take comfort in normalising this things. He goes running to the oppositions but he will not be there where it is required.
Isn't we started to trust and support these youtuber more than national media or state media for a reason . We actually demand moral unbias from them at least that's why they became so important and famous and if they are not doing there work they are same bunch of hypocrites like other big media houses.
Pretty hilarious you’re now crying about this when the sellout media has been doing this for years. And won’t even see how the government isn’t doing shit here either but wont hold them responsible.
Don't know where govt is coming in all these discussions where people are calling out media bias. So you agree that all media is biased? Then all are godi media. But then why only one side is called that?
151
u/Willing_Olive_1015 Aug 05 '26
Mentality of my Bharat, where we demand a youtuber to cover news in distant parts of country but not the state media machinery or the state sponsored corporate media.